• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

IGN PS3 Review - 6/10

Permabanned
Joined
15 Nov 2006
Posts
16,474
http://uk.ps3.ign.com/articles/747/747413p1.html

Ending statement:
The competition. <Pic of Xbox 360>
I'll close with this: given the momentum of the Xbox 360 right now and the strong reactions to the Wii's launch last weekend, the PS3 didn't come out swinging hard enough to cement its heralded position as king of the next generation this year. It's a long battle, of course, and Sony is well equipped to deal with it for the long run (as its PS One and PS2 victories have proven). But as the old saying goes, you only get one chance at a first impression -- and for this chance, the PlayStation 3 didn't dominate, it just showed up.
 
Pretty much as expected from me tbh.

The PS3 isn't that far ahead of the 360 technically, and at the moment obviously it can't compete on the games front.
 
wedgie22 said:
Pretty much as expected from me tbh.

The PS3 isn't that far ahead of the 360 technically, and at the moment obviously it can't compete on the games front.
I heard the differences between them won't show hardly at all from some other site a while ago tooo.

Graphics wise anyway.
 
wedgie22 said:
That's the impression I get, certainly not 15-16 months difference in graphics terms.


thats because the system was scheduled for launch march 2006, blu ray delayed that, and in that time the RSX lost 50mhz clock speed.

i'll put £1000 on the fact that the best looking game on the 360 will look better than the best looking game on the ps3 come the end of this generation.

there are technical facts that back up my apparently outlandish statement
 
wedgie22 said:
That's the impression I get, certainly not 15-16 months difference in graphics terms.

well it was never going to be... the 7800GTX has been out for AAGES now, and the ATi chip in the xbox was the same or slightly better so...
 
wedgie22 said:
I know that, I think there is going to be a lot of Sony fanboys who think otherwise, in for a shock.

yea unfortunately there is a percentage of the population with zero understanding of chipsets, polygons etc. they may be surprised somewhat - but wouldnt be if they actually looked into what they were buying...
 
The thing that people fail to mention regarding graphics is that the gpu in the ATi Xenos Xbox360 is actually more powerful than the chip in the nVidia RSX PS3. As this is what governs graphics mostly then we should see similar graphics on both, though as noted the PS3 will probably have a lower framerate (like we have seen with the launch titles).
The games where people think there is more detail on the PS3 version will probably be down to it being the primary development format.
Not sure what advantage that the dedicated GPU memory will have on the PS3 over the unified memory architecture of the 360 though... slightly better textures maybe?

Where the PS3 is stronger is in the physics/AI parts of the game, though i doubt this will be noticeable due to the tough architecture, for at least a few generations of titles.

So really, as mentioned they are pretty much on a level footing overall, the 360 being that much easier to develop for, however, should count for a lot.
 
Its quite funny really i and many people knew this was going to be the case all along now its been proved the PS3 is out and well thats about it

The 360 and wii will own gaming well in to next year by the time there are enough PS3 in peoples homes and the creators have got to grips with the system it might be too late

Right here right now you can play games like gears of war the PS3 has nothing that even comes close to it and wont for ages

I know a lot of PS3 fanboys who are changing there mind about the PS3 and getting 360 this christmas

And any decent gamer will do the same cant wait for my wii now!!!
 
well we might know this but standing in a shop the other day with a PS3 there was a seemingly endless amount of people coming through gawking at it.

Seeing Ridge racer which has graphics which are nothing special, exclaiming "wow look at that!" "its amazing" " I cant believe im playing a PS3!"

One guy actually just walked in looked at it, and said "well that beats halo 3 on its own"

i have no idea what he actually meant by that but he was serious.

I think its too easy to forget the PS brand carries an immense amount of force, in this country anyway, with the gerneal populous.
 
Yes, I read an interesting 3-part article on Eurogamer about the history of the PlayStation. There are soooo many similarities between the PS2 launch and the PS3 launch that it's almost like deja vu. The next few years will be interesting to see if the PS3 comes out on top despite all this adverse publicity just as the PS2 did.
 
wedgie22 said:
Pretty much as expected from me tbh.

The PS3 isn't that far ahead of the 360 technically, and at the moment obviously it can't compete on the games front.


I wouldn't say its ahead technically at all really, it has the cell cpu which according to devs is gonna be a pain in the ass to get the most out of, as for the 360 its graphics chip is a lot better than the scaled down 7800gtx in the ps3.
 
Interesting read that editorial.

Like a lot of people on here are pointing out, despite the fanfare and brainwashing of the fanboys that Sony have been doing, the PS3 aint all that technically. Its not better than the 360 in any way. But on the same note, its not any worse either. Pretty much even.
 
Gerard said:
I wouldn't say its ahead technically at all really, it has the cell cpu which according to devs is gonna be a pain in the ass to get the most out of, as for the 360 its graphics chip is a lot better than the scaled down 7800gtx in the ps3.

Whilst I don't disagree with your post in general, I don't think the difficulty to develop for the PS3 has any bearing on whether or not it's more powerful, that just means it's harder to get the most out of it.

I think the difference between the 360 and the PS3, even when they have been around for a while and developers have started to push them, will be negligable.
 
So IGN's rating of 6/10 is in fact a rating for their first impression of the PS3 :confused:

The 360 was the first big boy on the block.
The Wii is quirky.
The PS3 is playing catch up because after 11 months of the 360 we've all got over the "OMFG.... Next gen rulez" phase.

At this stage the PS3 was never going to amaze us straight out of the box.
 
No one really expected that much more (well some might of), but it doesn't really matter, great games on multiple platforms & we're all winners. :)
 
You know what.....this review "n" stuff.........well er ;) ..............er...yea well you know what...."we already know" :D

[feeling mischievous] I hear the reason Sony have only sold 300,000 units is that they have stopped production and given up[/feeling mischievous] Ub3r! :p

#non-sly ninja edit

Sorry was feeling very sarcastic earlier. What I meant to say was the IGN review was poor, brings nothing new to the table and was basically...meh.
 
Last edited:
PS3 launch has been a huge success over in the States, some were selling for $30,000 on ebay on the day of launch. Though most on the day went for anywhere between 3-8k. (But of course no one wants one) The japs have also gone crazy for them. The X360 has been an utter failure in Japan.

Launch titles have been a little weak, but lets think back one yr, was it any different with the X360? Well apart from the not so desperate bidding on ebay and it being a success in Japan.

I think there can only ever be two at the top, and my guess is this round will belong to Sony and Nintendo. Sony's machine has a certain aura about it, when you've actually got one in your hands you know you own something special, the X360 just doesn't have that feel about it. Don't get me wrong it will have gfx as good most probably and it will still be in with a fighting chance, but Japan is a BIG thorn in it's side. not right now, but down the road. All depends how Nintendo pull off the nunchuk ?? I'm personally already thinking of selling mine for a X360.

Sony's price is high but when you add everything you get then it's actually better value than the 360.. anyway time will tell.... time will tell.
 
Back
Top Bottom