• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

  • Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

8800GTS v 8800GTX (Stock & overclocked)

Soldato
Joined
29 Dec 2003
Posts
4,319
Location
UK
8800GTS(G92) v 8800GTX (Stock & overclocked)

There has been a bit of discussion on here as to which of these cards is the best, especially with the current GTX price. I was curious too, so I had a busy day yesterday benchmarking them against each other:)

There are some good reviews already out there, but non seem to put overclocked versions of the cards against each other.

Ive used what I think are typical achievable overclocks with the stock cooler for 24/7 use, I have owned two GTX and have two GTS at the moment and these are my maximum 24/7 stable clocks.

My Rig:

Silverstone Zeus 850W PSU
Asus P5K Premium motherboard
Core 2 Quad Q6600 @ 4.014 Ghz
2 GB Team Xtreme @ 1114Mhz, 5-5-5-15
Nvidia driver 169.21
8800GTX 768MB
8800GTS 512MB (G92)



All tests done @ 1680x1050.


There a couple of odd results in here like the prey timedemo1 being faster with 4AA than 2AA. I have re-run all the tests twice and the results were the consistant.

Here goes...

3D Mark 06




Crysis




Half-life 2 - Lost Coast




Prey - Timedemo1




Prey - Timedemo2





F.E.A.R

 
Last edited:
All good but what resolution?, only other thing I might take issue with is doing the testing with a quad clocked at 4GHz, something more achievable and comparable to users like 3-3.2GHz might be more useful, but I’m just nit picking.
 
Because It overclocks more and looks faster to me in a few games when overclocked, and umm it looks better, its not as long too, runs cooler too and uses less power too.

Who gives a flying **** what it looks like anyway but IMO it's fugly you have bad taste :p

It overclocks more yet struggles to keep up in a fair few games? sometimes lagging by silly amounts of FPS.

Length shouldn't matter if you have a decent case in the first place and not some £20 bargain basement

Temperatures seem similar to the GTX/old GTS to me from people I have spoken to.

It uses 20w less power on load and the same power as a GTX on idle. Really isn't a viable argument IMO.
 
Because It overclocks more and looks faster to me in a few games when overclocked, and umm it looks better, its not as long too, runs cooler too and uses less power too.

You must be having problems reading also, I got this from those results

F.E.A.R - GTX Faster

PREY - GTX Faster by 30-40fps

HL2 - Lost coast - GTX faster @ 0xAA by 10 fps and then a massive 40fps faster @ 4xAA the gap will only increase as you up the AA level

Remind me again why you think it is faster?

If you like your AA the GTX is the one to go for, coupled with having a bigger bandwidth and oodles more memory you'd want your head checking if you'd pick a GTS over the GTX especially at the current price points. People only want the card as it's new on the block, which is fine but what's the point when in actual fact there is nothing wrong with the old tech as one year down the line it's still kicking ass.
 
Last edited:
I'd like to note that in the games the GTX does will in, it does REALLY well in, but in the scenarios the GTS does well in, the GTX is pretty damn close to it.
 
Back
Top Bottom