• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

  • Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

Sell watercooled GTX285 to fund a 5870? What would you do?

Associate
Joined
11 Oct 2006
Posts
1,405
Location
Reigate
I have the temptation to sell on my GTX285 which is watercooled with an EK full cover block.

The reason being I just upgraded to i5 and although games are running smoother the increase was not as much as I'd hoped.

The question is - would you sell your GTX285 in my position to fund a 5870 right now?

Or wait untill Fermi launches?

Do you think an asking price of £200 for the GTX285 right now is fair?

Tom
 
Wait for fermi.

Nothing could make me depart with my nvidia, ati always seem to be dodgy.

Just this weekend they have admitted to some driver issue causing grey screens.

Why put yourself through so much pain and suffering?
 
You can buy a brand new ATI 5850 for £220 which will be a little bit quicker than the GTX285 and have DX11.

Maybe more like £165-175 would be more reasonable.

However who knows what someone might pay in an auction...you just might get £200 for it.
 
I have the temptation to sell on my GTX285 which is watercooled with an EK full cover block.

The reason being I just upgraded to i5 and although games are running smoother the increase was not as much as I'd hoped.

The question is - would you sell your GTX285 in my position to fund a 5870 right now?

Or wait untill Fermi launches?

Do you think an asking price of £200 for the GTX285 right now is fair?

Tom

I think the price of the EK water cooled GTX 285 is very fair and you will sell it quite easily. As to your future purchase although I do favour the red team I would wait and see what the fermi is like.
 
Yes if it includes the block as well.
As for waiting for Fermi....... it's a tough one, but I will explain why I 'personally' wouldn't.

1) I don't think it will be out before end of March
2) I think availability will be EXTREMELY poor
3) I think it will run pretty Hot with all the talk of needing a Fermi certified case for SLI.
4) Probably going to be Noisy and Loud
5) Some think the leaked performance charts are from the 360 but I don't buy it, I think they will end up being the 380
6) Will be Expensive
7) Drivers will no doubt be buggy because of the different arch, and Nvidia's declining driver quality.
8) If the above turns out to be wrong and you want the extra performance, simply sell the 5870 and get the Fermi instead.
 
Last edited:
Wait for fermi.

Nothing could make me depart with my nvidia, ati always seem to be dodgy.

Just this weekend they have admitted to some driver issue causing grey screens.

Why put yourself through so much pain and suffering?

And just this week Nvidia have admitted they have an issue which makes some peoples machines stutter heavily regardless of what its doing. Yep those Nvidia guys are SO much better.

Why put yourself through so much pain and suffering? ;)
 
Source of this nvidia statement? Cause I aint heard or seen a thing about it!

P.S Inquirer and fudzilla don't count as a reliable source!
 
Source of this nvidia statement? Cause I aint heard or seen a thing about it!

P.S Inquirer and fudzilla don't count as a reliable source!

You DO know that Inquirer is pro ATi and Fudzilla is pro nVidia right?

When Fud posts something negative about nVidia, you KNOW it's true.
 
Thanks for the informative posts guys I appreciate it!

Yes, I would be selling the GTX285 with the EK waterblock as it seems silly to sell them seperately when the block was fitted professionally by a company and I won't be able to use it on the next card I buy (obviously!).

As to the decision, I am glad to hear you guys think £200 is reasonable as the card is hardly that old at all and I have overclocked it to

730 CORE
1600 SHADER
1300 MEMORY

It never goes above 40 when gaming either!

I appreciate what someone said about getting a 5850 but I like to have the fastest single card solution available (I am not a fan of SLI/Crossfire/Dual GPUs) so it would have to be the 5870 if anything at all.

Is Fermi likely to be uber expensive?!
 
Should be different models for different pockets.

But I expect some ATI troll to say it will never be released/too expensive/hot/crap
 
Should be different models for different pockets.

But I expect some ATI troll to say it will never be released/too expensive/hot/crap

Huh? :confused:

I don't think anyone really believes that FERMI isn't ever coming out.

We know it'll be expensive, and we know it'll be hot.

What card that is supposed to pull 300w isn't hot? :confused:
 
Source of this nvidia statement? Cause I aint heard or seen a thing about it!

P.S Inquirer and fudzilla don't count as a reliable source!

Dell/Clevo, and Nvidia's Tech Support have come forward on thier own forums acknowledging the issue and asking for people to report it.
It primarily affects mobile users, various machines with various cards.
Nvidia are having to look into it, because although its not everyone, its been noted by some users from Dell/Clevo/Toshiba and I believe Lenovo.

Its a big enough issue Dell have publically got a page about it in thier community section regarding M17x, and have stated they are having to work on it with Nvidia.


Point being ATI and Nvidia have as many issues as each other affecting groups of users, ATI as recent have been more honest on such things, like the grey screen bug, Nvidia have just as many of thier own (the mobile cards with a design flaw they tried to cover up would be another example).
 
Last edited:
Mostly. Point is still quite relevant though, Nvidia are by no means perfect and drivers are not to previous standards recently either.
Google DPC latency and Nvidia and you will no doubt find results. Also early NV Vista drivers were so poor there was a lawsuit against them in America.
 
Last edited:
Wait for fermi.

Nothing could make me depart with my nvidia, ati always seem to be dodgy.

Just this weekend they have admitted to some driver issue causing grey screens.

Why put yourself through so much pain and suffering?

Yes because Nvidia have never had any problems with anything..... Their 8600m GT's were are the BEST EVER.... Bunch of freaking cowboys....
 
Back
Top Bottom