• Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

11th gen I5-11500T

Soldato
Joined
28 Dec 2002
Posts
6,662
Location
South Coast
Moving to a low power PC, anyone had any experience with about CPU from Intel?

Currently using an i7-5820k and 1660 Super GFX card, but decided time to migrate and sell off surplus items.
 
No plans for gaming anymore, it's just a case of office stuff, internet, music etc.

Consolidation of kit as I've also got 2 x Optiplex Micro 7040 PCs to sell off. Clearout and get a factory outlet PC with 3 years warranty etc. £490 +VAT. Three PCs into one and keep it simple, got other items too for virtualisation and firewall. PowerEdge T340, i3-6300T PC for the FW and a spare Pondesk FW appliance. The other item to go is a Dell PowerEdge R220 1240L V3 CPU.

So the aim was a i5-11500T based PC, 16GB RAM and I'd move my M2 NVMe, M2 SATA and SSD drive over, which equates to 3TB of storage.
 
Generally speaking with Intel CPUs, the T or S models offer very little benefit because they're not much better (if anything) at idle and they tend to take longer to complete tasks which negates the lower power draw (obviously it depends if it is a continuous task like gaming, or a finite workload). Ironically, K models with turbo turned off tend to fall quite comfortably in the highest efficiency point of the architecture, as do the lowest models like the 10400.

Without a GPU, the motherboard usually makes a bigger difference to idle power than the CPU. ITX motherboards are usually better than other formats and ASRock tend to be the best mainstream brand for M-ATX, but it varies a lot. Intel and Fujitsu are historically excellent.

GPUs add quite a lot to idle power, unfortunately (more than just the card itself, because they prevent the CPU reaching lower idle states, unless something changed recently that I'm not aware of). The RX 6500 and 6600 cards are excellent, as is any Pascal card. The 1660 Super isn't bad, so probably not worth upgrading. High refresh rate monitors and multi-monitor setups can significantly increase idle power, AMD historically have been much worse than nvidia for this (Polaris was pretty bad, up to 30 odd watts at idle!), but I don't know if that has continued with current gen.

With a good choice of components, getting sub 30 watt idle is fairly easy with Intel, but lower than that needs you to be pickier about the GPU and motherboard. Less than 20 usually means no IGP and less than 15 a highly efficient, probably a pico-type PSU. OEMs can often offer lower idle than a typical desktop setup / PSU because they're simplified.

From what I'm aware of, NAS forums are a good place to go for advice and there's a long running thread here: https://gathering.tweakers.net/forum/list_messages/2096876/10

I'm not aware of much specific advice on 11th or 12h gen. 8th/9th gen has really established boards and setups and the performance increase of 10th/11th wasn't really worth it for desktops or NAS. Kontron are supposed to be releasing 12th gen boards in Q2 and they've said they will prioritise power consumption like the 8th/9th gen Fujitsu boards did.
 
Consolidation of kit as I've also got 2 x Optiplex Micro 7040 PCs to sell off. Clearout and get a factory outlet PC with 3 years warranty etc. £490 +VAT. Three PCs into one and keep it simple, got other items too for virtualisation and firewall. PowerEdge T340, i3-6300T PC for the FW and a spare Pondesk FW appliance. The other item to go is a Dell PowerEdge R220 1240L V3 CPU.

So the aim was a i5-11500T based PC, 16GB RAM and I'd move my M2 NVMe, M2 SATA and SSD drive over, which equates to 3TB of storage.
sounds like a lot of hassle for not a lot of gain tbh
why isn't consolidating to your current pc feasible?
 
Margins are probably fine etc. lol

It's also more a dumping of kit and tidying things up. If I dump my Nvidia 1660 as intended I'll need a GFX card for the. Intention is to ditch motherboard, CPU, GFX card, spare Optiplex 7040
 
Last edited:
In my experience (12700T) if you keep the T parts power use in check the performance per watt is impressive. If you need the turbo frequency and IGP then triple the power use. At that point the 56/5700G on a A520/B550 is probably the way to go.

You also have the Ryzen GE parts that might offer better performance per watt again.
 
Back
Top Bottom