• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

  • Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

£160 Card upgrade

Yeah that's true, I guess it all depends if you are going to overclock or not. Myself, at least at the moment I can't be doing with the hassle. I guess there is always the option of getting a factory overclocked card.

4890 1Gb's are still £169, which is great value but what with the driver issues I'm having and the excellent recent run of Nvidia products, I'm still a green fan.
 
+1 for a 260GTX.

The benchmarks above don't do it justice - obviously been cherry picked results.

They weren't cherry picked, I could have picked pretty much any set of benchmarks from a dozen sites, as I said there isn't much in it between the two and the 260 has some definite positives and I did try and find some (non-Futuremark) benchmarks that show the 260 winning but unfortunately all the reviews I keep looking at now don't show the 260 with better results unless its an OC version being compared to a reference 4870.

I'm looking to upgrade and am still leaning towards the 260 even though it might be a couple of FPS slower as the quieter running is a priority for me, plus I just generally prefer Nvidia as had some problems with ATI in the past so not an ATI fan boy by any means. If you can cite some articles where the 260 wins out please feel free to post rather than making such comments.

EDIT:

I found some benchies on Firing Squad and have posted above, unfortunately only seems to beat the 4870 at DX9 and interesting article on PhysX here http://www.firingsquad.com/hardware/...ce/default.asp

me1920.gif
 
Last edited:
Agree with the above, the 260 is good but won't beat the 4890 in most test situations.

The 4870 and the 260 are on an even footing in most games, I saw a round somewhere recently and the ATI card was faster on 3 games and the Nvidia faster on the other 3 with them basically equal on the 7th title.

Either card will give you a nice boost, I have heard the stock Nvidia card is quieter than the stock Ati one but some of the cards now come with custom cooling solutions so will negate this, although I believe the Ati's still draw a fair bit more power on the PSU.

Below are a couple of benchmarks from Anandtech.

18717.png



18708.png


Overclocked 260GTX c216 = roughly to a 285GTX if you clock it high enough and the 285GTX >>> 4890 in those charts ;)
 
This is confusing O,o
People say the 4890 is on even footing with the 260, yet reviews tell me it evenly trades blows with the GTX 275 :S
 
This is confusing O,o
People say the 4890 is on even footing with the 260, yet reviews tell me it evenly trades blows with the GTX 275 :S

Because people seem to be talking about an overclocked gtx 260. But for some reason ignore that the HD 4890 overclocks to 950-1000mhz.

Most reviews I've read, the HD 4890 is comfortably ahead of the gtx 260 when both are at stock.

Heres xbitlabs review on the HD 4890

http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/video/display/radeon-hd4890.html

The gtx 275 is missing in this review but, the gtx 260 is there and the gap is very large in most games (as there should be considering the price gap). You do get the odd game (e.g. fallout 3 and Mass Effect) where one architecture is massively favoured over the other though.

Yesterday I had the choice between a gtx 260 216 core (pre oced to 621mhz) card at £144 and a HD 4890 at £165. It wasn't a very hard decision.
 
Last edited:
This is confusing O,o
People say the 4890 is on even footing with the 260, yet reviews tell me it evenly trades blows with the GTX 275 :S

It does. Seems the thread has filled with misinformation.

GTX260 = 4870
GTX260-216 = 4870 1GB
GTX275 = 4890

ATi and nVidia match up just about even at the mid-range (£125-£200). There's absolutely nothing in it.

Comparing overclocked cards against cards that don't overclock is lunacy. It's a lottery. Anyone could get a great clocker, or a bad one. You can't really factor it into your buying plan.

For £160 i'd be picking either the OcUK GTX260-216 at £147, or the 4870 1GB at £151 - it's really neck and neck.

Pick one, they're both fantastic cards. :)
 
Not really. I was comparing a 4870 vs GTX260. I don't think the 4890 is worth an extra £50 bang for buck however it is well worth an extra £20.

If the OP can get a 4890 for £160ish then that's the one to go for. End of story.
 
It does. Seems the thread has filled with misinformation.

GTX260 = 4870
GTX260-216 = 4870 1GB
GTX275 = 4890

ATi and nVidia match up just about even at the mid-range (£125-£200). There's absolutely nothing in it.

Comparing overclocked cards against cards that don't overclock is lunacy. It's a lottery. Anyone could get a great clocker, or a bad one. You can't really factor it into your buying plan.

Thanks for clearing that up, I can now sleep at nights :P
 
It does. Seems the thread has filled with misinformation.

GTX260 = 4870
GTX260-216 = 4870 1GB
GTX275 = 4890

ATi and nVidia match up just about even at the mid-range (£125-£200). There's absolutely nothing in it.

Comparing overclocked cards against cards that don't overclock is lunacy. It's a lottery. Anyone could get a great clocker, or a bad one. You can't really factor it into your buying plan.

For £160 i'd be picking either the OcUK GTX260-216 at £147, or the 4870 1GB at £151 - it's really neck and neck.

Pick one, they're both fantastic cards. :)

finally someone with some sense.

I really want a gtx 275. If only it was £20 or so cheaper i would go for it.
 
Back
Top Bottom