Does the system hard lock or remain usable? As in, while the image is corrupt, can you still see a mouse pointer moving about in the sea of crap?
Dodgy PCI-E lane perhaps? Tried in different slots or only have one? Perhaps the act of swapping cards seated the GPU in a working position and, over time, it's shifted or otherwise and has failed with the same result?
Seems a little unlucky to have 2 cards fail with the exact same symptoms.
Are you sure it's not the monitor and/or monitor cabling? Tried swapping them out?
Dodgy PCI-E lane perhaps? Tried in different slots or only have one? Perhaps the act of swapping cards seated the GPU in a working position and, over time, it's shifted or otherwise and has failed with the same result?
Seems a little unlucky to have 2 cards fail with the exact same symptoms.
Are you sure it's not the monitor and/or monitor cabling? Tried swapping them out?