• Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

2900 Cooling

Suspended
Joined
22 Oct 2004
Posts
1,884
I'm ordering a 2900 today :) And going for some third party HSF, looking at the 2900 card it looks like the required holes are the same as on the Radeon 1900,

I was going to try the Zalman FC-ZV9 Fatal1ty Dual Heatpipe VGA Cooler.



Any thoughts?!
 
Can I ask why you're going for a 3rd party cooler straight away? Why not see how the stock one performs first?

PK!
 
My 2900 should, barring citylink disaster, arrive today. I have a VF900 I might stick on it if it fits, but I am a little concerned of all that hot air in my case :rolleyes: .
 
AthlonTom said:
I'm ordering a 2900 today :) And going for some third party HSF, looking at the 2900 card it looks like the required holes are the same as on the Radeon 1900,

I was going to try the Zalman FC-ZV9 Fatal1ty Dual Heatpipe VGA Cooler.



Any thoughts?!


it's the same mounting system yes, but the shim around the GPU is higher then normal, so you either have to take it, goodluck, or file it down
 
yup, shim is higher so other sinks won't work without help. an extra thick layer of thermal tape doesn't sound ideal but might work, filing down a little bit of the base of heatsink so sticking out bit fits inside the shim. possibly removing the shim though it sounds epoxied on, i believe the 8800 series ones are just screwed down and easy to remove.

you'll have to see, you can always remove the shroud of the stock heatsink and take the fan off, rig up a quiet fan to it. i think i might be using something along the lines of a 120mm fan with 120-80mm adaptor and have it roughly blowing down onto the sink and see how that works.

i've said it before, and again, and will keep saying it. blower fans are pure crap, tiny airflow, higher cfm blowers = insane amount of noise, getting heat out of case is pointless, at the moment my case is almost silent but has 3x 120mm's and a 200mm at the top(antec 900), i don't care if heat from card is inside case as that heat is removed very very quickly. still 90-95% of users have few or no pci cards, no crossfire or sli, so 95% of us could have a gfx card with a thermalright ultra extreme sized heatsink underneath it, insanely good silent cooling and most of us could fit that in fine. theres no reason for the stock sink to be small, or have crappy airflow and high speed fans.

why does the pitifully small zalman heatsink work better than a x1900xtx stock sink, because its got a real fan on it, despite probably 1/5 of the copper and like 1/20th of the surface area.

EDIT:_, theres also no reason the pci slots have to be so restricted, if you had pci slots with much thinner metal so much bigger holes basically, then you could have a big heatsink filling the space under the card, and have the fan blow most of the hot air out the pci slots if you want. i get that some people do crossfire/sli, and some people have sound cards(way fewer than you think), so do some cards with smaller cooling solutions, but theres probably only 5 or 10 out of 100 people on these forums that can't fit a massive sink under there.
 
Last edited:
drunkenmaster said:
why does the pitifully small zalman heatsink work better than a x1900xtx stock sink, because its got a real fan on it, despite probably 1/5 of the copper and like 1/20th of the surface area.
Because the Zalman cooler is designed with quiet operation while the stock heatsink has to be as cheap as possible.
 
AthlonTom said:
My mates turned up earlier - I cant put up with that racket. I have a very quiet PC, got a bit of a thing about noise!

Are loud/louder than the x1800/1900 coolers?

I had to replace mine when I had my x1800XT. Very loud.
 
markyb said:
Are loud/louder than the x1800/1900 coolers?

I had to replace mine when I had my x1800XT. Very loud.

It's difficult to judge, does seem to be driver dependent, though apparently theres a utility kicking about from the 9800 series that will allow manual fan speed adjustment
 
Back
Top Bottom