• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

  • Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

7950 OR 660Ti?

1.) No, because that isn't logic.
2.) Yes, I agree there had to be a game, and I never thought it was to show Nvidia up, until they've done something else with the Dirt series which shows Nvidia up.

Twice, with the same game series, they've done something superior than their competitor.

Coincidence or not, it still shows them up, with the same game series, which are what? AMD Gaming evolved titles, arguably Dirt 2 was the first when AMD really took a lead.

Well it's hardly a surprise considering DiRT 2, 3 and Showdown were all "Gaming Evolved" titles. Nothing really happened with DiRT 3, which if they were trying to be underhanded, they would have used that as another chance to do something. With the DiRT games, they are just pushing recent technology.

There are plenty of Gaming Evolved titles where they could have tried to gimp performance on nVidia, but it's not really happening.

nVidia show themselves up anyway, it's widely known that developers don't really like working with them, and to be honest no one really likes working with them because they try their best to make things hard.

As we know, it's looking very likely that nVidia won't have anything to do with any next gen consoles either because of how companies don't like working with them.

Which is why these game enhancements run poorly on Nvidia GPU's.

Its Nvidias own doing :)

I know, that's what I was saying in the first place.
 
Last edited:
Maybe and I did read it all. Claims of Nvidia being disingenuous but no proof.

Also:

http://www.bit-tech.net/custompc/news/602205/nvidia-offers-physx-support-to-amd--ati.html

Not my statement but take from that as you will.

Nvidia’s director of product PR for EMEA and India, Luciano Alibrandi, told Custom PC that ‘We are committed to an open PhysX platform that encourages innovation and participation,’ and added that Nvidia would be ‘open to talking with any GPU vendor about support for their architecture.’
Well that is good news, hopefully.

But "open to talking" is not the same thing as saying "here is the source code, do with it what you will"

The question is not only will AMD take it up, it is also how far will Nvidia go in letting it go.

I know, that's what I was saying in the first place.

ok :)
 
I guess you didn't bother to read it Humbug. That was from the 10th March 2008 (almost 5 years ago).

The SDK is free to all game developers and they said they would make a free API available to anyone.
 
Last edited:
I know Dirt Showdown runs pretty poor on Nvidia.
I think that's pretty shady.
But Shogun 2 etc? When the GTX680 launched it was bashing the 7970 about in Shogun 2 and Dirt 3, showdown never launched till after launch.

I know it's not the case now with the 7970 GHZ Editions and 12.11.

AFAIK,the lighting effects on Hitman use standard methods,ie, DX11 Directcompute.

Its nothing to do with gimping,more a case that the HD7970 seems to run DX11 Directcompute better:

http://images.anandtech.com/graphs/graph6025/47486.png

If you look at things like the GPU cloth and particle sections of 3DMark,the GTX680 does better and in cases of extreme tessellation.

Guess what Crysis 3 will be emphasing??

AMD has increasingly starting to use the compute advantage of their current GPUs in many games,whereas Nvidia will push things like large amount of particle effects and extreme tessellation.
 
Last edited:
Maybe and I did read it all. Claims of Nvidia being disingenuous but no proof.

Also:



http://www.bit-tech.net/custompc/news/602205/nvidia-offers-physx-support-to-amd--ati.html

Not my statement but take from that as you will.

The first quote you made was from the guy who co-founded Ageia (the originators of PhysX).

He will have a very deep understanding of PhysX, but beside that, people clued up on PhysX know that it wouldn't be that straight forward.

We all know that nVidia would take EVERY chance they could to make sure everyone knew that "PhysX runs best on nVidia" and have stuff in place to make it a "reality".

I think you'll struggle to find many people with more than a very basic understanding of what PhysX is, that would agree that AMD being let in on it would be a good thing.

It's not good for anyone for such an API to be owned by one manufacturer.
 
I guess you didn't bother to read it Humbug. That was from the 10th March 2008 (almost 5 years ago).

So did they talk? how did those talks go?

This is not "AMD can have it" this is "we will talk" with no result from that.
 
AFAIK,the lighting effects on Hitman use standard methods,ie, DX11 Directcompute.

Its nothing to do with gimping,more a case that the HD7970 seems to run DX11 Directcompute better:

http://images.anandtech.com/graphs/graph6025/47486.png

If you look at things like the GPU cloth and particle sections of 3DMark,the GTX680 does better and in cases of extreme tessellation.

Guess what Crysis 3 will emphasing??

Compute IS gimped on the GTX6 series though, the GTX5 series outperform the 6 series in CUDA applications.

The main issue here is that the previous generation, we all knew that games would be moving towards compute performance, nVidia were also hyping it up, so it's really their own fault completely for gimping their own compute performance.

Crysis 3 is also a Gaming Evolved title too.
 
So did they talk? how did those talks go?

This is not "AMD can have it" this is "we will talk" with no result from that.

You see it how you want and I see you already have. An official statement and again you pop your blinkers on.

Edit:

I have shown you how it was made available to "anyone". Can you show me where AMD/ATI said it wasn't?
 
So did they talk? how did those talks go?

This is not "AMD can have it" this is "we will talk" with no result from that.

Well it depends, we all know nVidia have a track record of having an aversion to the truth.

I have a hard time believing nVidia really were willing to offer it to AMD considering nVidia's actions generally have said otherwise.

For example, the way they block hybrid PhysX, surely if they were genuinely willing, they would have no reason to block hybrid PhysX.
 
Compute IS gimped on the GTX6 series though, the GTX5 series outperform the 6 series in CUDA applications.

The main issue here is that the previous generation, we all knew that games would be moving towards compute performance, nVidia were also hyping it up, so it's really their own fault completely for gimping their own compute performance.

Crysis 3 is also a Gaming Evolved title too.

If you look at the tech demos released for the game they were emphasising extreme tessellation and large amounts of particle effects. Unless AMD leverages their compute advantage I can see Crysis 3 running better on Nvidia hardware. Crysis2 was renowned for using tessellation for silly things, needlessly increasing the load on GPUs for no visual improvement1 :mad:

BTW,anyone know why AC3 runs so much better on Nvidia hardware ATM??
 
You see it how you want and I see you already have. An official statement and again you pop your blinkers on.

Edit:

I have shown you how it was made available to "anyone". Can you show me where AMD/ATI said it wasn't?

No you haven't, you've shown a quote from the Founder of Ageia, and then an opinion from a Custom PC writer.

It is very clear that nVidia is only interested in using PhysX to make their cards look good.

It's what they do, they were trying to block SLi from running on anything but their own chipsets until they couldn't keep up with it because people weren't interested in their chipsets.

They had some crappy arse argument that SLi wouldn't work without their chipset as it had a "special" chip in it for SLi.

You should have a read of this article before you continue to discuss any more PhysX related stuff:

http://www.realworldtech.com/physx87/

Also, there is a quote out there of an AMD exec claiming that nVidia have no intentions of letting them use PhysX or CUDA.
 
Last edited:
If you look at the tech demos released for the game they were emphasising extreme tessellation and large amounts of particle effects. Unless AMD leverages their compute advantage I can see Crysis 3 running better on Nvidia hardware. Crysis2 was renowned for using tessellation for silly things, needlessly increasing the load on GPUs for no visual improvement1 :mad:

BTW,anyone know why AC3 runs so much better on Nvidia hardware ATM??

In that regard, I would expect them to use tessellation sensibly in Crysis 3.

We all know that a lot of tessellation was pushed harder than necessary simply because nVidia at the time were better at it, despite it not offering any increase in visual quality over lesser tessellation values.

Extreme tessellation generally means tessellation far beyond a value you can resolve, rather than highly detailed meshes.
 
No you haven't, you've shown a quote from the Founder of Ageia, and then an opinion from a Custom PC writer.

If it was lies, CustomPC could be up for Libel. I don't feel they would post something that would leave them that open do you? Especially knowing how Nvidia would react.

And as for that Opinion, when something is in print like that, I tend to believe it. You can dismiss it if it doesn't suit your opinion and that's fine. I have shown my thoughts and for fear of suspension, I feel I should step out.
 
If it was lies, CustomPC could be up for Libel. I don't feel they would post something that would leave them that open do you? Especially knowing how Nvidia would react.

And as for that Opinion, when something is in print like that, I tend to believe it. You can dismiss it if it doesn't suit your opinion and that's fine. I have shown my thoughts and for fear of suspension, I feel I should step out.

I didn't say it was lies. I'm saying that they've quoted the founder of Ageia, and then the part where they say "it's up to AMD" is their opinion based on the quotes from the Ageia founder.

And you essentially believe anything you read in print? Did you really just say that? :confused:

They are merely passing their opinion on what the founder of Ageia means in his quote. Come on, surely you can see that?

Basically;
"Ageia founder says all this" our opinion of what he's said is that PhysX is available to AMD, we just need to see if they want it.
 
Last edited:
You see it how you want and I see you already have. An official statement and again you pop your blinkers on.

Edit:

I have shown you how it was made available to "anyone". Can you show me where AMD/ATI said it wasn't?

AMD, or for that matter any game developer do not need Nvidia to play any sort of role in over seeing Physx implementation.

Physx is based on OpenCL direct compute, OpenCL is OpenGL and OpenGL is AMD Drivers and their entire architectural design.

All they need is for Nvidia to relinquish their exclusivity of the software.
AMD can integrate it in to their OpenCL Drivers better than Nvidia can for obvious reasons. Hell it will probably work better given that AMD GPU's are by natural OpenGL design a far more powerful compute engine, hhmmm?

All the devs need is not to seek Nvidia's permission to use the Physx engine in game regardless of GPU.

All Nvidia have to do is put it back on the Open Source market where it originated.

There is nothing to talk about, unless Nvidia have strings attached or want AMD to bring their checkbooks with them.

Your article does not say Nvidia are relinquishing control of it, nothing even close to the sort, what it says is "We are willing to talk to AMD"

What those talks involve and thier outcome are perfectly reasonable questions to ask, for we are all greatly intrigued as to know if game developers can now include AMD in Physx titles.
 
Back
Top Bottom