Thanks for the comments.
sbi5ar: I was quite happy with #2 and the pattern there, but #1 is so clean it makes #2 look too busy when they are looked at together.
The_blue: The Sigma 105mm is also f/2.8 right? You should be able to get the same light. I took that at f3.5, shutter speed 1/160s, ISO400. It wasn't a particularly bright day.