A World Cup Rant...

Associate
Joined
17 Aug 2005
Posts
532
Location
north east
:mad:
So here we go – a World Cup Rant (possibly to divert the attention of people who are scrutinising the phones bills of Hartlepool Utd to see who has been talked to and what was said… a watched kettle never boils as my Mum says)

Anyway,

There is something that is really spoiling my enjoyment of this world cup. It’s not the camera angles or the commentators (who are my usual bug bear) – it’s the players.

Somewhere along the line there has been a mix up. Football is a contact sport, it always should be. Now I am the first to be out of my seat when I see a bad tackle or even a tackle that shows no attempt to get the ball. We all know that these should be punished. But the problem is that players fall over at every opportunity. Every attempted tackle becomes a seismic occurrence that knocks a player to the ground. You don’t even have to touch the player. Go for a header and sense the defender is behind you – fall over with your arms in the air – instant free kick. The yellow card is devalued – commentators bring up the idea of sin bins nearly every week.

I have stopped blaming referees now, the disgrace that is this world cup has actually got me feeling sorry for them. How can you possibly be able to tell which is a real foul and which is not when players react to every little touch or bump like it was a premeditated swing for their heads? It’s gone way beyond diving in the box for penalty. People are going down under an attempted tackle on the half way line.

It’s lazy. I remember I used to get annoyed when I saw players ‘settle’ for a corner instead of trying to cross the ball – I thought that was lazy, then they started to settle for a throw in on their own half way line. This falling down thing is 100 times worse. It stops players having to actually do anything. Hoof the ball forward get your striker near a defender and then watch as he falls over. Instant free kick – no skill needed. By pass the midfield take out any possibility of losing the ball or having to deal with any players that might have the audacity to use their ability to take the ball off you and punish you by launching an attack. It’s like American football – move the ball forward get tackled, re-group and launch another set piece.

I have seen a number of teams come to pools and take the tempo out of the game by falling over at every opportunity – sadly they happen to be the teams nearer the top of the league unfortunately. I always put it down to the lower standard of football, the desire to kick like a pit pony to get out of the division. Then I watched the world cup. It works – but it has taken any attempt to play football out of the game. How many free flowing moves have you seen lately? Watching Ukraine game yesterday there weren’t any offside, there weren’t any shots that I can remember in the second half (the Swiss were so out of shooting practise that 3 of them couldn’t even score a penalty). It was stop start, stop start, and roll over a bit in agony. Long ball, fall over, look at the ref before you hit the ground.
Does it all stem from the desire not to get beat? Has that taken precedence over the desire to actually win? (And win well?).

So what do we do? The refs at the World Cup have started to splash the yellow cards around, but maybe they should be punishing the one that falls over and waves his arms in the air (don’t even think about the ones that wave imaginary yellow cards about). Do we appeal to any sporting nature these professionals may have? Think about all the kids watching their first world cup and going out and emulating their favourite players - they wont have any skills, goals (or even shots) to re-enact it will be the diving, the feigning injury, the rolling over and begging the ref. It will be the lazy footballers opting for the easy option time and time again.

Well thank you for your time!
Probably nothing you weren't already thinking but I feel better for having vented...
 
Last edited:
i agree about the contact thing... protecting the skill.. what a load of tosh.. chris waddle had a right go about it on five live yesterday and rightly so.

players arent diving to get free kicks half the time, it seems as they are playing for the challengers sending off or booking.. and a yellow card is as good as a sending off in this world cup.. as soon as you get one your pretty much out of the game because you cant go for the ball.

at the beginning of the world cup i thought the referee had done good jobs.. now as its gone on its been outwieghed by some really flimsy yellow's and sending off.

a good defender has more strengh than skill most the time, so protecting the skill might as well eliminate a teams defence as they are supposed to watch it seems.
 
Get some form of panel together and review the games after they have taken place. Then ban everyone that dives, play acts, waves yellows around etc.

That'll soon stop it all :)
 
i reckon tv footage for officials..

and a bit more common sense :p

a strong challenge can be a good challenge.. and can be skill... dancing around the ball and falling over is not skill.

dancing about the ball and being taking out in a very blatent way is skill and a poor challenge :)

but maybe the officials are under a lot of pressure and become confused and clouded when having to make a decision. FIFA need a common sense value, not just with rules.. but rankings more than anything ;)
 
I feel very disappointed and let down by this World Cup as a whole. I was really really looking forward to it, and so far the football just hasn't lived up to a good Champions League or Premiership match. Where is the passion and display of skill we've all come to expect when players step out on the pitch for their country?

This tournament has so far been a far cry from the show put on by Zidane and Ronaldo in World Cup 98 and filled with less heart than the South Korea/Japan performances in 2002.

It's like every single team is going out with the aim not to lose, as opposed to going out to win their matches. Obviously no one wants to be knocked out of the World Cup at this stage, but would you be much prouder to take part in a performance like the Switzerland/Ukraine game and get a scoreless draw that begs belief for sheer boredom/lack of scoring effort?

I totally agree about the lack of free flowing attacking football - something I think we were all expecting from Brazil given that it's the last World Cup for the old boys and the first chance for Robinho/Kaka etc. to play with the experience they've gained at club level. Why on earth Ronaldinho came out and said he didn't want to play his club role for his country I'll never understand. Skillful runs and weaving interplay are what we want to see.

Other than some amazing individual goals (Lahm, Maxi Rodriguez) the only times I've been out of my seat are for the amazing Spain and Argentina team goals.

The thing that has characterised this World Cup for me has been players reactions to being fouled, which seemed to establish a trend in the first couple of days of the tournament. Players would hit the ground like a sack of bricks, roll around screaming as if they've just been stabbed with a rusty spear then as soon as the offending tackler was booked they'd pop up to take the resulting free kick.

Seriously, what the **** are you playing at? Do you not think the millions of people across the world and the thousands in the stadium will notice the miraculous recovery from what seemed to be a life threatening injury just seconds before? Did a memo go out to all players saying that bonuses would be awarded post-tournament for the most entertaining/spectacular show of non-existant injury?

Unless we get some really high quality football in the quarter finals and remaining second round games this World Cup will have been a huge let down.
 
Players play percentages, if they dive reasonably well a certain number of times then he will get at least one decision. Referee's are under pressure not only from the players/managers trying to win freekicks/penaltys but also from the 2 assessors on the sideline. If a ref wants to ref in the big competitions they have to toe the line. All that pressure plus the human error factor and you get shambolic performances.

I remember I used to get annoyed when I saw players ‘settle’ for a corner instead of trying to cross the ball

Most likely a corner is more likely to produce a goal than a cross, its the bolton/allardyce way of thinking. Play the percentages and you'll come out on top more often than not.

On the issue of 'protecting' the skillfull players I suspect that football will become a sport where if you attempt a sliding tackle you'll be booked. Its practically like that now. Why FIFA are trying to make the biggest sport in the world more popular I don't know. Possibly they want to tap that US market that might add a few more 0's on their bottom line.
 
Ian said:
Get some form of panel together and review the games after they have taken place. Then ban everyone that dives, play acts, waves yellows around etc.

That'll soon stop it all :)

I'm not sure why they haven't done this yet. They must have thought about as it's such an obvious thing, and therefore must have rejected it for some reason.

Another thing which annoys me is that FIFA doesn't like to undermine the decisions a referee makes, no matter how obviously wrong they are. Case in point being the Figo headbutting/stroking incident. The rules state that because the ref took action during the match, the offense can't be looked at again.

The Guardian came up with a good idea: Pink cards for diving. I'd like to expand this idea... A player who dives in a match (decided either during or after) is required to wear clown makeup for the following game.
 
FIFA are trying to make it bigger and bigger and make more money off it, you will end up with the true footie fans swtiching off and justget your part time fans watching it.

I dont mind the ads and PR side to it but they are ruining the game with stupid rules, BLATTER OUT.
 
sinister_stu said:
The Guardian came up with a good idea: Pink cards for diving. I'd like to expand this idea... A player who dives in a match (decided either during or after) is required to wear clown makeup for the following game.

Why not make them play with no boots or shinguards? :)
 
IceBus said:
The thing that has characterised this World Cup for me has been players reactions to being fouled, which seemed to establish a trend in the first couple of days of the tournament. Players would hit the ground like a sack of bricks, roll around screaming as if they've just been stabbed with a rusty spear then as soon as the offending tackler was booked they'd pop up to take the resulting free kick.

Seriously, what the **** are you playing at? Do you not think the millions of people across the world and the thousands in the stadium will notice the miraculous recovery from what seemed to be a life threatening injury just seconds before? Did a memo go out to all players saying that bonuses would be awarded post-tournament for the most entertaining/spectacular show of non-existant injury?
I ******* hate football players for this very reason. If you put a football team on a rugby field they'd all fall over dead within 5 seconds of kickoff.
 
They should be allowed to ban players for driving by video evidence after game to stop the diving **** :mad:

It will stop the driving ******* right in there tracks :mad:
 
Fifa should create a panel of Video Physicists to calculate the angle of dangle for every dive after a game. Its obvious when they do it, anyone with a basic grasp of the theory of conservation of momentum and that knows that player A traveling at velocity X and coming into conatct with player B, cannot somehow instantaneously develop a velocity of X^2 with addtional rotational velocity of 2w*X^7, without Y kilojoules of energy being created by player A himself through the act of exerting diving muscles. We should call it Pires' First Law. Anyone falling foul of the Pires Law should be banned for 10 games.

The reason footballers do anything cheatwise is there is not enough deterant to make them think twice.
 
Back
Top Bottom