Adding an internal floppy drive doesn't work

Associate
Joined
17 Jul 2024
Posts
32
Location
Oxfordshire
Well I guess the first question you might ask is 'why do you want a floppy drive?'.
A lot of old HP test gear has floppy drives for saving plots, data etc and apart from via GPIB, the only way of getting that data out to print is via the floppy.

So I have one of these: https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B0BB5YHT42?ref=ppx_yo2ov_dt_b_fed_asin_title

A rather curious implementation of a 34pin floppy interface to USB. Its far from ideal as:

a) it has a lead with a USB plug on it, which is not what you want for an internal floppy. But you can get internal 9 pin-to-usb adapters, so there is a way of handling that, just not elegantly.
b) it has its own 4 pin power header. This is in addition to the 4 pin header on the floppy. Why both? It won't work without both, sigh.
c) its rather flimsy. The usb lead is tacked onto the pcb with glue. Urgle.

When power to the board AND the usb lead are connected, the PC won't power on. Disconnecting either the usb plug or the board's power connector (not the floppy power) lets the PC boot, but then the floppy doesn't work.

I'm guessing this is because there is a +5v power domain going from the PSU to the floppy, but there is also a different +5v power domain that the usb is connected to on the motherboard. And the PSU doesn't like thrm interconnected and won't power on (note that if you *do* plug the power connector and floppy usb lead in while the PC is powered on, it stays powered on, doesn't trip, and the floppy works. Power off and on again and it won't power up again until you unplug the usb or power connector).

Any ideas how this could be solved? It was not a problem on a Dell PC I also fitted a floppy to, but that had a much simpler power supply. The current one has an EVGA Gold 1000w.

Hope the above explanation is slightly clearer than mud.
 
Sorry I'm of no use to solve your issue but the idea of even trying to use a floppy this many years after they were retired by everyone else gave me a chuckle at least
 
Sorry I'm of no use to solve your issue but the idea of even trying to use a floppy this many years after they were retired by everyone else gave me a chuckle at least

I had 200+ floppies stored away in the loft I recently put a FDD back into use to sort through before disposing of them, also some older relatives who've passed away in recent years still had data on floppies to sort.

They can be a bit problematic these days as USB ones don't support all filesystem formats, interface adaptors like the OP is talking about can be problematic on modern hardware and some boards don't support the original FDD interface at all. Best off like I did - work benched some old Core 2 Duo parts with an old school FDD just to get data off.
 
Well just for the record I got it working. The board has a power connector with the standard +5v/gnd/gnd/+12v and a cable with a USB plug. The +5v of the USB cable is connected on the board to the power connector +5v. Simply disconnecting the +5v wire of the USB cable, so the two 5v power domains are not shorted together, allows the PC to power on. I guess the PSU has some means of checking if its CPU +5V output is shorted to periph +5V output.
 
Back
Top Bottom