Advice needed on replacements or upgrades for two PCs

Associate
Joined
9 Jun 2009
Posts
17
My partner and I each have reasonably specced but aging i7 PCs which are used heavily for gaming as well as other purposes (photo editing, audio recording, development, etc.). I built them in 2011, but using some parts (the PSUs and one of the CPUs) bought in 2009, and I'm ultimately wanting to build two new high spec machines to replace them - budget of roughly £2,500 to £3,000 each, including new monitors. I can't find the exact specs of the existing PCs and I'm not at home right now to check, but it's probably unimportant for the nature of my question.

We currently have a pair of even older monitors which are finally giving up and need replacing. My partner would like one of the ASUS RoG Swift 144Hz gsync monitors, and I'm considering getting the same. This is definitely going to call for new GPUs, and we've been thinking of grabbing a 980Ti each.

I initially looked at building my partner a new PC and then building myself one a bit later (as his current one is lower spec - could really do with more RAM, a bigger SSD, etc.), but my monitor now seems on the edge of death, and I also noticed that new Intel CPUs are not far off.

Should I just go ahead and build one or both new PCs now, or am I better off buying two GPUs and two monitors, and waiting for Skylake to hit before I carry out the new builds? I tried reading around a bit but can't seem to find solid information about how beneficial Skylake will be, or whether it's likely to be more expensive. Some people say wait, other people are saying there's no reason to. Money isn't my number one consideration, but I'd feel silly shelling out a load of cash now if I could get the same for considerably less in a couple of months, or if I could spend the same and get something better. Being more future-proof is a consideration for me, as well.

I'm thinking if I do replace the GPUs I might need to replace the PSUs in both machines as well - they're pretty hefty Corsairs (mine is 1000W, I think the other is probably a 750W), but they are pretty old. Is my thinking right on this, or are they probably fine? It'd be a hassle to switch everything to a new PSU if I'm not rebuilding, but I definitely don't want to put the new GPUs at risk!

Lastly - and this is probably a way down the road - I'd like to have the Asus RoG Swift monitor for gaming and then pick up a higher res IPS monitor to use for photo editing, development, and so on. It'd be nice if I could use them at the same time, but not critical. Is there anything I need to keep in mind to make this work smoothly?

tl;dr version:
  • Should I build new systems now, or just partially upgrade for now and rebuild post-Skylake?
  • Should I replace my powerful enough but old PSUs if upgrading?
  • Do I need to do anything special to power both a 1440p gaming monitor and a 4k or 5k IPS for other uses?
 
Its worth posting the full spec of the PC's when you get home,its possible you have 2500k based systems,which when overclocked are still extremely competative cpu's and upgrading doesnt offer a massive improvement.

The psu's should be fine,would depend on the exact model but most of corsairs PSU's from that era are very high quality.


The only special thing you need to power a swift/4k monitor are GPU's with a display port connector on them.So you may need to upgrade your Gpu's at the same time as getting your monitors to be able to use them.


Probily your best move is to get the cards and monitors now,and wait it out to see how good skylake is.
 
Might be worth looking at the x99 platform as these will surely be viable for a good few years yet.

I would be tempted to just grab the monitors and the GPUs tbh and maybe even the SSDs and see how you get on.
 
Its worth posting the full spec of the PC's when you get home,its possible you have 2500k based systems,which when overclocked are still extremely competative cpu's and upgrading doesnt offer a massive improvement.

They are Nehalems - having had a dig around, I think a 920 and a 960. Nothing other than the GPUs and monitor situation is hugely hurting tbh, other than wanting more RAM in one PC and bigger SSDs for both. They're just getting old enough and things have moved on enough that I'm thinking it's time for a full refresh. Both mother boards, while decent enough at the time, don't have a ton of SATA III connectors, etc.

The psu's should be fine,would depend on the exact model but most of corsairs PSU's from that era are very high quality.

I'll check on the models when I get home.

Thanks for the input!
 
Might be worth looking at the x99 platform as these will surely be viable for a good few years yet.

I had been tempted, particularly for mine - but yeah, if I were going to wait a little longer than maybe it'd make sense for both. Does anyone know much yet about how the X99 platform and Skylake will compare? They're both DDR4, right?
 
Check out the Acer Predator monitor as an alternative to the ROG swift. It has an IPS panel rather than TN. It might even be good enough for working on.


YOUR BASKET
1 x Acer Predator XB270HU 27" G-Sync IPS 144Hz Gaming Widescreen LED Monitor - Black/Red (UM.HB0EE.009) £739.99
Total : £739.99 (includes shipping : Ex.VAT).




Your current power supplies will be fine to reuse. For a 1440p screen and heavy gaming then go with a 980 ti. It can support multiple monitor setups.

If you need more cpu cores then look at X99. With a £2.5-£3k budget you can easily get an i7 5820K system.
 
I had been tempted, particularly for mine - but yeah, if I were going to wait a little longer than maybe it'd make sense for both. Does anyone know much yet about how the X99 platform and Skylake will compare? They're both DDR4, right?

Skylake will only have 4 core cpu's in it's lineup. Broadwell-E and Skylake-E are both a while off (Q1 2016 and Q3 2016).

If you want 6 or 8 cores then go with X99.
 
YOUR BASKET
1 x Asus Rampage V Extreme - Intel Core i7 5930K Six Core CPU & Motherboard Bundle ***£20 Saving*** £849.94
1 x Acer Predator XB270HU 27" G-Sync IPS 144Hz Gaming Widescreen LED Monitor - Black/Red (UM.HB0EE.009) £739.99
1 x EVGA GeForce GTX 980Ti Superclocked ACX 2.0+ 6144MB GDDR5 PCI-Express Graphics Card (06G-P4-4993-KR) **OcUK Exclusive** £569.99
1 x Corsair Vengeance 16GB (4x4GB) DDR4 PC4-23000C16 2800MHz Quad Channel Kit - Blue (CMK16GX4M4A2800C16B) £169.99
1 x Samsung 500GB 850 EVO SSD 2.5" SATA 6Gbps 32 Layer 3D V-NAND Solid State Drive (MZ-75E500B/EU) £155.99
1 x Seagate Barracuda 2TB 7200RPM SATA 6Gb/s 64MB Cache - OEM (ST2000DM001) HDD £57.95
Total : £2,558.84 (includes shipping : £12.50 Ex.VAT).




I haven't added a case as I don't know if you want a new one, also lacks a cooler to fit said cases.

Those power supplies should be fine to reuse, but just for your info other brands have over taken Corsair for quality in that area when you do come to replace.
 
Cheers for all the advice, everyone - I'm going to pick up monitors and GPUs shortly, then do new builds a bit later. Eyeing up some SSDs with the money saved on PSUs or rebuilding my partner's PC in full - love how the SSD prices keep dropping lately!

I think we'll stick with the ASUS monitor; it's on offer this week, we both like the look of it more than the Acer gsync monitor as far as looks and features, and I'll ultimately want a higher res IPS anyway. Tough choice though, I had to do a fair bit of reading up to make a decision. I wish we could see both in person.

I am a little worried by all the quality control complaints about both monitors, but they seem to have calmed down a lot for the ASUS model (and I realise there's a confirmation bias as people who've had trouble are more likely to review things). I was almost tempted to buy a couple of cheap-ish monitors and wait until there are more options available, but I don't think I can put up with a poor quality monitor for long, it's yet another expense that could go into other components, and it would feel like a waste of the awesome GPU.

Undecided on the architecture for the new builds at the moment, but it might well end up being an X99 build for me as it'll be getting used for VMs, lots of data crunching, etc. The PC for my partner might end up being a Haswell as I get the feeling the extra hundreds spent on X99 or even Skylake would be wasted (it's mostly just for gaming, photo editing, and a bit of sound recording - and he has no interest in 4K or massive multi-monitor setups), but I'm thinking we might as well see whether the price drops after Skylake comes out, if nothing else.
 
Back
Top Bottom