Affinity Photo 2

MouthBoy

MouthBoy

MouthBoy

Soldato
Joined
6 Apr 2010
Posts
2,898
Location
Cambridgeshire
Does anyone use Affinity Photo 2?

I ask as I am wanting to move away from Adobe, and I need to replace Lightroom and Photoshop. This is for two reasons, the subscription fee and I am not generally liking what Adobe are up to these days.

I have downloaded the free trial tonight that lasts for 7 days and have been playing a bit, and my first thoughts are that this is steps back from Lightroom - but - is that a bad thing for what I personally do? I mainly do landscape and a bit of wildlife photography, I shoot RAW and like to develop 95% in RAW in Lightroom rather than jumping into Photoshop.

A few issues I have found;
- There is no DAM and so I would be using Windows File Explorer and dragging the photos I want to edit into AP each time
- Due to no DAM, there is no method for me to rate and favourite photos, which I do a lot of so I know what my best photos are quickly
- RAW editing is basic, and it seems like AP wants you to make basic adjustments and then move to their non destructive editor for the rest - this may not be a bad thing when I get used to it?
- Subject selection...I find myself using this a fair bit with wildlife photography, but due to "no AI" in AP, this feature is missing and its mainly manual selection

The pros?
- £79 for an entire suite of applications (around £33 just for the photo bit) and its a one off payment
- The tools that are available do seem to the commonly used ones, and if I get used to their workflow it may be ok?
- I don't edit "heavy" so the basic RAW editing may work for me?

Anyone else made the switch?

Also, any thoughts on Capture One instead? I know that is £290 but its still a one off and seems to be VERY powerful for photos and RAW processing, and it has a DAM too?
 
What I mean by basic is if you look at the tools just in the develop persona (mode) in AP there is far less than LR and they seem far less detailed. Also something I noticed is that AP never seems to find my lens for lens correction without manually doing it.

I got a trial of CO last night too and straight away it felt better, all lenses found, simple DAM features but they are there...but, it is 4 times the price.

Then I looked at DXO, and that may be an option. It seems very powerful and it's at a price I'm ok with paying. Still testing though.

Interestingly I opened up a RAW file in LR, AP and CO last night side by side and for some reason the AP one looked hazy and soft, where LR and CO appeared sharper initially. Unsure if there is some processing happening behind the scene, but it's a tad odd.
 
Bought DxO and I am really impressed. Spent tonight sorting out my catalogue now that LR will not be managing it, but feels good to get rid of photos from around 20 years ago that I have no idea why I kept... :D
 
GMac11 said:
One thing to get straight from the outset is that Affinity is in no way, nor ever has been, a replacement/alternative to Lightroom. It is more akin to Photoshop.
For straight up RAW editing Affinity is not very good in my experience - although I admit I haven't used V2.

If you really want to get away from Adobe (I have actually just gone in the opposite direction) then you need a proper RAW editing program to run alongside Affinity. My choice for years (mainly because I shoot Fuji) was Capture One and that combination worked very well for me.

However, the cost of Adobe is very reasonable now compared to Capture One alone and the fact you get both Lightroom and Photoshop bundled as well as the mobile and tablet apps made it a no brainer for me.
I pick up a year's subscription to Adobe when it's on sale on Amazon (circa £80ish give or take). For an equivalent £6.66 per month it's an absolute bargain IMO.
Click to expand...

Yea I found thos during my testing.

I have purchased DxO as my RAW editor and am going to pickup affinity suite for the gap that would have been photoshop.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom