***Antec P193 case review***

Caporegime
Joined
17 Jan 2010
Posts
66,731
Location
weston-super-mare
bannerAntecmassive3_zpsb709d7a7.png



OcUK Product page - http://www.overclockers.co.uk/showproduct.php?prodid=CA-123-AN&groupid=2362&catid=160&subcat=


Today I am looking at the above mentioned case, it is a mid sized tower case with a sleek looking exterior and some interesting internal design implementations and features.

A few unique features are,

• Mini-ITX, microATX, Standard ATX, Extended ATX support.
• Three speed fan controller for the included fans.
• Easily removable HDD cages.
• Lockable front door with brushed aluminium front insert.
• Large Big Boy 200mm side fan
• 6 internal 3.5" drive bays (two can accept 2.5" drives).
• 4 external 5.25" and one 3.5" external drive bays.


Packaging and accessories.

IMG_2799_zps721ccf31.jpg


Antec have always done this well, the cardboard box is uber tough and the soft cell foam inserts are so much better than normal polystyrene inserts, the case arrived in pristine condition and also had clear plastic film protecting the brushed aluminum front and side inserts.

IMG_2723_zps8181f3a9.jpg


IMG_2725_zps48d3eade.jpg


Inside the actual case was this rather large box, inside it was this bunch of accessories, more on some of these later.


Exterior.

IMG_2688_zps3540113a.jpg


IMG_2663_zps51459ce5.jpg


The front looks really nice, I like the aluminum insert a lot, the chrome vents on the right are actually plastic.

The front door is also on a double hinge so it can be kept flush against the side panel.

IMG_2675_zpsd0f21378.jpg


Plenty of room for air to enter the front down both sides of the door.

IMG_2664_zps5998f704.jpg


A lock for the door, eSATA, 2XUSB2.0 ports and microphone and headphone port.

IMG_2665_zps3909f87d.jpg


The power and reset buttons and activity LED's are behind the lockable door.

IMG_2666_zps24cb18c8.jpg


The two front dust filters are hinged and are held shut by spring latches, they are also easily taken off, the case doesn't include front fans but they are easily fitted.

Between them is a 3.5" quick access drive bay (not setup as hot swap-able, but can be) also with dust filter.

IMG_2670_zps6b4e60d5.jpg


ac9268a4-874f-4e4b-ac1a-9d8b25110ea8_zps0256d665.jpg


Everything is well filtered to keep dust at bay.

IMG_2676_zps20e3eaa3.jpg


IMG_2677_zpsdc56e6c5.jpg


IMG_2679_zpsbc527d83.jpg


The right side has a 200mm that has been mounted in a way to not take much room up inside for components.

IMG_2681_zpsab5f6cb6.jpg


IMG_2682_zps2d886227.jpg


It also includes a dust filter that is really simple to remove.

IMG_2792_zps17de4ddc.jpg


The side panel fan is a Big Boy 200mm and powered via a molex connector it also has a three speed controller, unfortunately you can only adjust the speed with the side panel removed. There must be a way a future design can have the speed controller easily accessed possibly on the outside where the fan actually sticks out of the side.

IMG_2793_zpsa0126ff3.jpg


The sides are constructed with a steel and polycarbonate dual layer design. They are extremely sturdy and heavy, I think they are the heaviest I have yet experienced and have zero flex to them.

The polycarbonate helps insulate noise, foam strips are also added along the edges to keep vibration and noise to a minimum.

IMG_2674_zps1c1b40a6.jpg


The left side panel is plain but again uses a steel and polycarbonate construction.

IMG_2687_zps4b5bcd56.jpg


The roof includes two 140mm fans.

IMG_2683_zps8e331495.jpg


The rear which has a single 120mm fan included.

IMG_2684_zpsbd21ed85.jpg


This is the fan controller for the two top fans and single rear fan, there is low, medium and high settings,

Fanspecs_zpscead2325.png



IMG_2685_zps838cea68.jpg


Seven expansion slots and two grommeted holes.

IMG_2686_zps82d0112e.jpg


A standard ATX PSU can be fitted or a Antec CP series PSU can be fitted.


Interior.

IMG_2690_zpsa3aa395b.jpg


Initial impression after taking the side panel off is a serious lack of decent cable management holes and what are there are not grommeted at all, also the interior is unpainted.

I am not bothered about the lack of a painted interior, you wont see it and modding a window into the side panel will be extremely difficult if not impossible due to its construction.

IMG_2693_zps01033cd6.jpg


IMG_2696_zpsbbbdc12e.jpg


Anti vibration strips have been added along the raised edges, it helps seals the top and bottom compartments from each other.

IMG_2692_zpsf8e19fd9.jpg


The PSU sits on anti vibration strips too, there is no vent in the floor for the PSU so it relies on the air that enters the front of the case.

IMG_2694_zps378f9ec7.jpg


The fans supplied are powered by molex connectors.

IMG_2699_zpsb07ad853.jpg


IMG_2700_zps8fd22363.jpg


Sections in the floor can be removed then refitted to pass cables through from the PSU.

I think some of the rolled edges of the cuts could be better.

IMG_2703_zps05698ee9.jpg


A 120mm fan can be fitted behind the lower HDD cage.

IMG_2704_zpsbbc55d78.jpg


Remove the securing screw and then pull on ring to remove the cage.

IMG_2705_zps15ea7bc6.jpg


IMG_2708_zps1f2f6fdb.jpg


The lower front panel fan mount takes a 120mm fan.

IMG_2706_zpse777f68b.jpg


The HDD cage has rubber anti-vibration mounts for four drives.

IMG_2709_zps28f263c6.jpg


IMG_2710_zps983ca5c0.jpg


The middle cage is also easily removed and another 120mm fan mount for the front panel is then accessed.

IMG_2715_zps6afec5eb.jpg


IMG_2719_zps55bc9786.jpg


IMG_2735_zps3c1ec577.jpg


IMG_2733_zps10928273.jpg


The quick release caddies for this middle HDD cage will take 2.5" drives and again uses anti-vibration mounts.

IMG_2738_zps70d0f50c.jpg


IMG_2716_zps7ba46ce8.jpg


A little storage box is also fitted presumably for screws etc.


HDD cage accessories.

Included in the package of parts supplied with the case are a couple of extras.

IMG_2727_zpsb1922609.jpg


Two fan clips to add another 120mm fan to the rear the middle HDD cage sucking air through the cage and into the top compartment.

IMG_2728_zps95d6d5eb.jpg


IMG_2729_zps6720c43c.jpg


A PCI card holder, but this is only useful for really long expansion cards.

IMG_2730_zps26ee80f6.jpg


The 5.25" drives are fitted with these rails screwed into both sides.

IMG_2731_zps04dfaf3e.jpg


Then slotted home, this method is really easy to use, just squeeze the sides in and the drive can easily slide out again.


Installation of parts.

IMG_2786_zpsdc2532b0.jpg


With the lack of cable management holes it was difficult to make a tidy build inside, the fact that there is no side window does mean that it is not as important unlike cases with a side window or indeed without (but can have one modded afterwards).

IMG_2784_zpsf9577632.jpg


With a tall heatsink such as the Coolermaster 612S as fitted, it is not possible to close the side panel as the side panels fan takes up a bit of the interior space.

Antecs homepage says a 140mm maximum height heatsink is all it can accept

IMG_2798_zpsacddb7ab.jpg


The Big Boy fan takes 15mm of space up inside, so I acquired a Thermalright true spirit 90M which at 124mm tall had no fitment issues.

IMG_2847_zps6ddf3564.jpg


Water cooling isn't really possible, the rear 120mm fan is too close to the side (radiators are a bit wider than a 120mm fans frame) and the top fans are too close to the motherboards VRM area and heatsink to be able to also get a radiator in there.

So to sum up, this case is best for stock cooling or for a small aftermarket heatsink, the cable management is nowhere near as good as other cases I have used, but there are a lot of clever little features in its favour.

The noise levels are extremely quiet as long as the fans are on their lowest settings, increase their speeds to medium of high and the noise is substantially increased with a very strong "whoosh" of air flow at their maximum speed.

Do to the fact that I had to use different cooling for the CPU to be able to use the case, I have not included any temperature results as I would not be able to compare it to the other case reviews I have done in the past which did use the Coolermaster 612S.


Conclusion.

Currently as I type the Antec P193 is on offer at £74.99 (normally £84.98) this represents good value for a case that is extremely quiet, looks good to me with the aluminium fascia and side inserts giving a touch of class to the style. The cooling opportunity is excellent with fantastic fans fitted as standard and the possibility for a lot more to be added. The cable management is as I mentioned not up to the standards more modern cases have but again the lack of a side window makes this a bit of a moot point.

The lack of available room inside for heatsinks does mean that nearly all the good ones on the market will not fit, so this does limit you to whats available, this has a knock on effect that you shouldn't be using the case for serious overclocked rigs that do need a large heatsink to keep the CPU temps in check.

The quality of the panels and construction is high with the panel gaps being very tight, my only bugbear is that some of the cut holes should have larger radius rounded edges.

A quiet office, home, music creation/editing environment is where this case truly belongs I feel.


The bottom line.

Are you looking for a case to use in a quiet environment with good stock cooling, extremely well built panels and overall high levels of fit and finish and some unique touches such as the lockable front door, HDD cage options and the variable fan speed controller then this case could be for you.

awardvfm_zps3cea0444.png
 
Very good review. I've had one of these for years, here's my tips:

Pros:
- Easy to work in
- Room for long graphics cards
- Excellent airflow (install 2 fans in front)
- Very quiet (fans on low)
- Excellent build quality
- Dust filters everywhere
- Very well priced

Cons:
- Front-most roof fan interferes with CPU cooler fan. Turning the roof fan off doesn't affect temps but does reduce noise.
- I needed a 4-pin and 24-pin extension to get those round the back.
- Can't fit larger CPU coolers. Freezer 7 Pro is fine for modest clocks, but stulid's cooler looks better.

AcH77lt.jpg
 
Last edited:
bit of a disjointed discussion have multiple copies of a thread.
I can see the need to hit the different forum sections, but surely the threads can be linked together somehow so there's just one conversation.
 
Had the Antec p182 for a few years kept pretty cool but dust was a big problem and cable management wasnt the best and having a door on the front got on my nerves after a few months.
 
The build quality of the p series cases by antec are really top notch. I've had my mini p180 the baby brother of this case review and its a splid performer. Airflow is excellent and if you mod the case abit you can seriously squeeE a ton if watercooling into it.

I currently have over 480mm of radiator space in mine and may even be able to squeeze another 120mm out of it if i swap out the 240mm for a 360mm in the roof.

My only gripe with the case is finger prints on plastic and especially on the aluminium fascias. They are quite hard to get off!

Cable management is also much better in the mini P180 than the P193 with bigger cable management holes.

Even though its an matx case, it looks and feels more like a mid tower.
 
that side vent is hideous

whats the point of making a sleek looking case then something that sticks out like a soar thumb ?

i think it looked to similar to the original case so they did it so it looks like a new one. a lot better looking cases for the money.
 
For that price you would expect a painted interior, at the least grommeted cable management holes. The side panel fan implementation is questionable. Some USB3.0 ports on the front panel should be a necessity for this price. Cases that cost less than half the price of this one feature them.

Although...

The design looks quite nice. A big fan of the brushed aluminium look. I like how easy the fan filters are to take out and clean. The inclusion of a fan controller is very neat indeed.

If I were buying a case within this price range I would definitely go with another case. The design is good but in my opinion the features do not justify its price tag.
 
I have a P180 and have been looking for an upgrade for a while now. It has no SSD bays and my 7950 barely fits inside. Is this a good upgrade?
 
I have a P180 and have been looking for an upgrade for a while now. It has no SSD bays and my 7950 barely fits inside. Is this a good upgrade?

This will take a 7950 (there's plenty of room) and can take two SSD's.

So if you like the case? then get it quick while its on offer.
 
Back
Top Bottom