VLC didnt work - will try MPC..
+1Movie BD's aren't going to play because of encryption etc which is why you pay for those that do
You can rip with something like DVDfab but like the players its not free. DVD encryption is fairly simple and was cracked a long ago but with BD its hugely obfuscated and they change the keys regularly hence you need a paid product+1
Can you rip them or do you really need the menus
MakeMKV is freehence you need a paid product
And can do UHD discs if you have the right drive.MakeMKV is free