Anyone getting slightly tired of 'JustGiving' requests?

Caporegime
Joined
13 May 2003
Posts
34,562
Location
Warwickshire
I am :D.

I get about five per week at work. They're like permissible spam, but no-one says anything 'cause they know they'll look like a tightwad if they do. Much as I am looking like a tightwad right now.

I give to quite a few of them, but I sort of begrudge it especially when the challenge is actually quite fun for them. Like sponsor me to bungee jump or sky dive. I'd like to hope that they're paying for the jump and that all proceeds go to the charity, but you never really know unless they publish the thank you letter from the charity after the event.

If you're going to do something for charity, do something useful that will actually help like spend a day in a cancer hospice running errands etc., not doing a half marathon with your mates, which won't help a terminally ill child much but will be a flipping good laugh for you and your buddies, or having your own life experience that you pretend will be really terrible for you but that you're secretly really looking forward to.

Every time one comes through into my inbox saying 'sponsor me to make love to Anne Hathaway' or the like I inwardly roll my eyes then sulk at the pressure I feel to stump up yet again. They're no better in my eyes than the plastic bags that get put through my door every day asking for clothes etc. that I have to walk to the bin with (though these can be quite useful if you're having a clear out :D).

I must stress that I am not against charitable donation. I also understand that people's main goal is to maximise donations not to minimise my butthurt...emails and forum posts, Facebook messages etc., being the best way to achieve this. But the world and his wife now has a JustGiving page that they forward to an ever increasing number of people with an ever increasing frequency and with an ever decreasing sense that they're actually doing some helpful for the people that they care about.

I'm obviously going to come across as a giant meanie with this post, but in fact I give a lot to the health service and regularly donate a tenner here and there (to cancer charities especially), but I hate the constant bombarding of my work inbox with them.

Recommendation: imo there should be a central notice board in offices to which all such charity requests are restricted, or on internet forums, a max of one pinned thread per forum, etc.

BAH HUMBUG! :)
 
They raise all this money for their own gap years so they can go out and teach some kids or build a well. Why dont they just hire a professional builder to go out and do a better job in a fraction of the time?

Also especially things like skydiving. Hell, i'd pay to skydive, why do they get paid to do that? seems crazy?
 
Not at all, although after the fees debate, wish people would switch to virgin.
But then I don't feel compelled to sponsor everyone.
And few in my circle tend to do pay for us to do things.

A group just got the world record for longest 5 a side footie (well awaiting confirmation) so all money to charity, a few going bold sponsorships and half marathons etc and I'm paying my own way for kilimajaro.
 
I don't really mind, but the skydiving ones annoy me. Its not exactly difficult, and its a lot of fun, why should I sponsor someone for that?


Best one I've seen was a guy that was spending a week on the streets with no food, money, or communications devices to raise money for the homeless. That, is a challenge worth sponsoring.
 
Generally they don't. They pay for the skydive themselves and all money raised goes to charity.

The same goes for the half marathons. You pay a fee to register yourself for it and then you raise money separately. The Just Giving site makes sure all the money goes to the charity, they don't send it to the person :/

I agree there is stuff people do to raise money that is no challenge. Just don;t give them any money :D. Give the money you would have given them to someone who is doing something hard or to someone who is raising money for a cause that is important to you.
 
I haven't heard of this at all, I was under the impression the fees were minimal?

It's not huge(subjective) but it's a fair bit more on just giving compared to virgin, which is a not for profit organisation.
On a £10 donation, the charity recives:
Just giving is £11.74
Virgin Monie Giving £12.15

So a fair bit when we're talking 10s of millions
 
Last edited:
Nope, I have no issue. As a student I have no issues not paying. In fact, generally I probably am quite stingy with what I give.

Generally speaking however, I'm stingy with what I give because I'd rather give time. I.e. run a half marathon or such like. Although personally I'd be much more interested in swimming a 10k for charity.

If I didn't want to, I won't give, that said, generally speaking, I'm happy to give money if I know that if I donated money the person that is raising money would also donate if I was doing something for charity.

kd
 
I don't really mind, but the skydiving ones annoy me. Its not exactly difficult, and its a lot of fun, why should I sponsor someone for that?


Best one I've seen was a guy that was spending a week on the streets with no food, money, or communications devices to raise money for the homeless. That, is a challenge worth sponsoring
.

Ouch! I spent two days on the street whilst going between places, and even though I had the luxury of knowing it wasn't forever, it was still an experience I'd rather not do again.

The world turns very violent after dark.
 
As long as they pay for themself why not?

Because if its not a challenge, or related to the cause in some way, its like saying:

"Hey man, I'm going to get drunk with a bunch of friends this weekend, and because of that, I want you to give money to cure cancer."

Nothing at all wrong with campaigning for the cause, and then paying your own way to skydive. But linking the two isn't right imo.

It's not huge(subjective) but it's a fair bit more on just giving compared to virgin, which is a not for profit organisation.

Fair enough, good information to know.
 
Fair enough, good information to know.

Example donation added.
On top of that virgin is a one of set up fee for £100
Justgiving is £15 a month.

As to the skydive, I think a skydive for many is hards, heights is a massively common phobia to varying extents, but most people don't like the idea of jumping from heights.
 
^Maybe, but in my experience the people I know who skydived for charity really wanted to do it anyway.

How do you feel about me doing kilimanjaro then?
It's something I really want to do and always have wanted to do, however I am paying for it myself and it is a massive challenge seeing as I'm so unfit and have already totally changed my lifestyle in perpetration and in triaing more than 18months out.
 
How do you feel about me doing kilimanjaro then?
It's something I really want to do and always have wanted to do, however I am paying for it myself and it is a massive challenge seeing as I'm so unfit and have already totally changed my lifestyle in perpetration and in triaing more than 18months out.

That is the difference.

If you really want to skydive, it will not be a challenge for you.
 
I agree on the skydive fear factor

Heights + terminal velocity + ground = terror

I did a skydive last year with the Red Devils for h4h and raised £3k - I did have the option for the donations to cover the cost but that didn't feel right so I paid all the costs involved myself as I didn't want people thinking I was getting a free jump.
 
Robbie G - how come you're getting so many requests? I bet they're coming via Facebook buddy/friends list or other social networking sites. They can't just be off email alone? I get a few a year, normally emailed directly to me off someone I know and I always honour those.

What I don't like is being approached in real life: someone trying to drag me to my bank branch after saying I don't have my bank card on me a la NSPCC! And someone trying to get my payroll number in my work's canteen a la Together for Change! Shoo, bugger off!
 
Back
Top Bottom