• Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

ATI 2D better than nVidia ? proof inside!

  • Thread starter Thread starter mrk
  • Start date Start date

mrk

mrk

Man of Honour
Joined
18 Oct 2002
Posts
105,188
Location
South Coast
In around 30 mins when I install my new HIS 4870 and and finally switch from my trusty 8800GT OC :D
 
Sorry had to re-calibrate my screen too in the process and make sure all settings are to my liking :D

pc_case_interior.jpg


I love it! 2D somehow just looks clearer than the nVidia 2D quality, I don't know how better to describe it other than in a photographic term, like you stuck a cheap unbranded UV filter over your lens then replaced it with a branded high quality one of the same type. The difference is subtle but it's clearly there if you're in a 2D environment a lot!.

This forum for example the blue shades are more prominent yet not too bright or fatiguing against the grey text input post box!

Here's a photo example of nVidia 2D then the ATI 2D, click for full res (10MP)


nVidia:




ATI:

 
Last edited:
I've been using nVidia forever and I've never heard of such tweaks...
 
ATI 2D owners have been saying the same thing for years, at least with analogue output & CRT monitors. With DVI it should be much closer.
 
I've been using nVidia forever and I've never heard of such tweaks...

Digital Vibrance option in "Adjust desktop colour settings" inside the Nvidia control panel. I seen this also when changing to Nvidia but once this is set to a certain level you get the vibrancy back that you get with stock ATI cards.
 
no it's not vibrancy it's clarity and sharpness, vibrancy is a total 100% no for people like me since I run a calibrated screen so cannot have colours being made more vibrant!
 
i thought that was a given

my old ati looked better than my 8800gt and my current 9800gtx in desktop
 
no it's not vibrancy it's clarity and sharpness, vibrancy is a total 100% no for people like me since I run a calibrated screen so cannot have colours being made more vibrant!

i thought that was a given

my old ati looked better than my 8800gt and my current 9800gtx in desktop

Ah fair enough. It's been a while since I used ATI as I've had the GTX so I've not noticed much except the difference in vibrancy when I was benching the 2900Pro. I'll be getting a 4870 or X2 4870 soon myself, I only commented on this as I've seen a few who after changing the vibrancy level were content.
 
Yea coming from an 8800GT to a 4870 I noticed something looked better too.

But IMO those screenshots above dont show it :p.
 
if you setup both for 6500K the colors should look identical - digital vibrancy is a no no imo anyhow. Any difference in clarity is probably down to the difference in color. As for sharpness some driver versions seem to be better than others :( thats one thing I've not liked about nVidia - you can get one driver thats really sharp and clear and the next will be slightly fuzzy.
 
difference is minimal and i wont be selling my card for pittance only to buy a new card for slightly better 2D graphics when i can adjust everything i want with my monitor/control panel
 
No you dont buy it just for better desktop, people buy these as they are faster by quite abit than the GT and GTS G92, GTX, Ultra etc..
 
I now play GRID with "ultra" settings, reflections on 1024 because of the VRAM not playing fair with only 512MB ram but with Ultra @ 4xFSAA 1920x1200 I get 60FPS.

Fair !

I used to have to have a mix of high, 512 reflections and medium trees + some ultra on the 8800GT in order to peak 60fps !
 
I now play GRID with "ultra" settings, reflections on 1024 because of the VRAM not playing fair with only 512MB ram but with Ultra @ 4xFSAA 1920x1200 I get 60FPS.

Fair !

I used to have to have a mix of high, 512 reflections and medium trees + some ultra on the 8800GT in order to peak 60fps !

Cool, well I gots 2 x 4870's on there way, they should be here tomorrow :cool:.
 
Back
Top Bottom