• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

Automatic small car for older relations

Anything I've driven the restart is probably like 1/3rd of a second before you can start moving - still a pain in the rear though and I can't see it having any worthwhile benefit on most of my trips.
 
It's simply not an issue. The car is always ready to drive by the time you've selected a gear in a manual or lifted off the brake in an auto, at least with everything I've ever driven which had it fitted.
 
It's simply not an issue. The car is always ready to drive by the time you've selected a gear in a manual or lifted off the brake in an auto, at least with everything I've ever driven which had it fitted.

It hasn't been quite instant in anything I've driven - even though it is ready to go in less than a second - maybe I'm a bit eager but I find it an unnecessary intrusion as slight as it usually is. Certainly I've never had it delay me to the extent people would get the impression I was dithering about though.

I just find it annoying as I'll spend 20-30 minutes in traffic on the way to work where it wouldn't be the worst thing for it to activate and it rarely does but then coming home at night with nothing around it will seemingly activate every moment I even think about stopping. (I usually remember to deactivate it when I start up but not always).
 
Last edited:
How do you know this is what they are doing?
regular run, I stop 5/10mins to recover at a roundabout to be entertained by driver/lemming behaviour,
frequently, there is a gap to join roundabout, but by the time the engine has started they've wasted the opportunity.

even though it is ready to go in less than a second - maybe I'm a bit eager but I find it an unnecessary intrusion as slight as it usually is
similarly on the Cambridgeshire roundabouts he who hesitates is lostdelayed
 
regular run, I stop 5/10mins to recover at a roundabout to be entertained by driver/lemming behaviour,
frequently, there is a gap to join roundabout, but by the time the engine has started they've wasted the opportunity

Unless you're in the car with them how can you possibly know the reason they didn't join the roundabout was because of start stop?
 
If you lift off the brake to anticipate the gap the engine will have restarted by the time you are ready to accelerate.

The problem is numpties who can't predict what is going to happen in 3-5 seconds' time, not stop/start tech.
 
yes, I concede the numpties are lacking prediction, but they end up risking the safety of other users when they enter roundabouts erratically, so the technology is not helping
(doesn't contribute to WLTP results I believe)

Unless you're in the car with them how can you possibly know the reason they didn't join the roundabout was because of start stop?
I'm standing 10m away I can hear the engine and see the roundabout gap they are considering
... yes it's an odd place to stop during a run, especially with pollution, but its kinda like watching people at the beach say.
 
If you lift off the brake to anticipate the gap the engine will have restarted by the time you are ready to accelerate.

The problem is numpties who can't predict what is going to happen in 3-5 seconds' time, not stop/start tech.

I think part of the problem is the instinctive side of it with a restarting engine you kind of delay for it, possibly longer than the actual ready state of the vehicle maybe.

It isn't always ready by the time you accelerate though - I'd forgot to disable it the other day and it kicked in on me at a tricky junction and I had to abort pulling out when a gap came up as the car didn't get going in time.

Pain in the rear junction that you have to shoot out when it is busy when a chance comes up or you'll be sitting there all day: https://goo.gl/maps/ACEwT9C5nTFbSqNi9 frequently the site of accidents.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps not all manufacturer implementations work the same but on my car (auto) the Stop Start system activating can be controlled by the brake pedal, so at a critical junction for example, just don't press the brake pedal particularly hard (you can still brake to a stop safely) and the engine won't stop. In a similar sense, if it has stopped and you want it to restart before you feel you'll need a quick response, you can slightly release the brake pedal to restart the engine without the car moving.
 


Older (Over 70s) car drivers and all car drivers share the same top 2 contributory factors. However, a larger proportion of older car drivers are allocated contributory factors relating to driver failed to look properly (47.0 per cent) and driver failed to judge other person’s path or speed (23.9 per cent), than all car drivers.
Also, a larger proportion of older car drivers are allocated factors relating to poor turn or manoeuvre, loss of control and driver nervous, uncertain or panic compared to all car drivers. In 2016, 16.3 per cent (1,053) older car drivers performed a poor turn or manoeuvre, 13.5 per cent (869) were allocated a loss of control contributory factor, 4.8 per cent (311) were allocated a factor of driver nervous, uncertain or panic

Front visibility and minimal A pillar size probably important criteria for older drivers - reducing blindspots (... need those honeycomb A pillars I think volvo were talking about )

with modern ncap5 etc. cars, at junctions, imhop have to adjust your head position once(ie. two modes) to get a complete view, and the last glance is probably less reliable.
 
Last edited:
It used to be - now its the Honda Jazz...
I still can't stop myself from calling it the Jizz!!

If you lift off the brake to anticipate the gap the engine will have restarted by the time you are ready to accelerate.

The problem is numpties who can't predict what is going to happen in 3-5 seconds' time, not stop/start tech.
Or the numpties who try to predict and anticipate what's going to happen, but get caught when something different occurs.
I was always taught to "never anticipate what other drivers might do, but to leave a safety gap for when they do what you didn't anticipate"...
 
Number of times lately it has paid off leaving enough room to accommodate people doing things I'd never have anticipated is unreal - I dunno what is to blame but driving standards really have fallen off a cliff this year.
 
Number of times lately it has paid off leaving enough room to accommodate people doing things I'd never have anticipated is unreal - I dunno what is to blame but driving standards really have fallen off a cliff this year.
People not driving throughout Covid will be a big factor. It's a perishable skill like any other, though few people will even realise this. They'll just assume they're as great as ever, like those Born Again Bikers.
 
Back
Top Bottom