Beefing up our RDS platform (client with GPU)

Soldato
Joined
30 Sep 2005
Posts
16,736
Hi all,

I'm about to open a huge can of worms here

My client is struggling to keep their client machines on the 5 yearly refresh cycle. They are getting behind and it's been estimated that they will require around £1 million to refresh properly.

They are trying to balance the books and look into alternatives to reduce cost, whilst keeping up to date and current.

Even if they manage to secure funding, this problem never goes away and in another five years they will be back to square one.

There is an RDS platform in place which works well for general office type applications, however thousands of users require rich multimedia. This is where the can of worms comes in.

Ideally we need to build a new RDS platform (perhaps in 2016 using Server 2016) and buy in thin client terminals.

So.....there doesn't seem to be a good way of delivering multimedia.

RemoteFX just isn't there, and it's heavily dependant on codec identification which kicks in well after video playback.

Nvidia Grid. Expensive and generates a lot of heat. The back end platform gpu grunt is user based (ie: 30 users for one quad core gpu). When we scale this out to 4,000 users that's a lot of graphics cards.

The holy grail is buying in a terminal which has a graphics card on-board, but how on earth do we reference the local graphics over RDP.

I know there are companies who looked into a software solution which sits over RDP but I heard it's messy and very hit and miss

Has anyone undertaken a project like this?

The company doesn't mind spending money if they can see a ROI over 5 years and beyond

Thanks :D
 
Last edited:
There are solutions out there - VMware Horizon View would be the route I'd be taking at the moment, as PCoIP is excellent at handling multimedia.

There's lots of zero-thin clients, such as those from 10zig, that are designed for multimedia. You could also invest in some grid cards like you say for the more intense users.

The latest version has also brought its RDS support bang up to date.

Unfortunately, it's not going to be cheap, and won't be worth doing unless you can invest in good kit.
 
When we looked at VDI, we also looked at ways of continuing to use existing kit (We eventually just did a full hardware refresh with no VDI).

We stumbled across ThinStation, which is an opensource barebones linux OS with clients for the main VDI players baked in - We were particularly interested in redeploying machines as diskless VDI terminals that would pull down the OS via PXE.
At the time, the multimedia performance wasn't good, but for general office usage it would have been ideal.

I can't tell if the project is still actively being updated, but it might be worth a bit of investigation if money is truly a big problem and you're looking to save on licensing.
 
Horizon DaaS with Grid would be my suggestion; pay a service provider for the desktops and let them worry about the hardware costs.

Edit - I work for a horrizon daas sp so am somewhat biased. Your mileage may vary.
 
Back
Top Bottom