Car Battery Replacement Question

LowEndTorque

LowEndTorque

LowEndTorque

Associate
Joined
6 Mar 2024
Posts
709
Location
Cheshire
Hi Folks,

Now that the tyres question is out of the way, my next target is getting a replacement battery for my Mk5 Mondeo 2.0 TDCi Estate. As with the tyres I do not want to wait until something goes wrong.

The current battery had shown signs of little struggle over the past month. Whilst doing the tyre replacement last weekend I requested the KwikFit staff to check the battery too. They mentioned it needs charging and suggested a long drive. Now, I cover about 50+ miles each week for my work when I work from office one day a week. Almost 90% of that journey is Motorway and A roads (60 mph). I doubt the battery would need charging.

The current battery is a Lion brand one. As per the battery checker on the Euro Car parts website this battery is not compatible with my car. I presume that's because the battery is not Stop/Start compatible. God knows why the previous owner would do that other than getting a cheap battery. The description states the battery is of the type 'Wet Flooded'. I have tried searching to confirm if that translates to EFB type but I cannot find factual information for that.

My research brings me with two options that I would prefer. I am going with AGM type batteries based on what I read.

1) Bosch AGM Car Battery 12V 80Ah Type 115 S5A11
2) A6 Varta Dynamic AGM 110 Car Battery 12V 80Ah

Coming to my question. Is it worth getting the AGM battery over an EFB? Mind says I can go with either as both are Stop/Start compatible. AGM only for more durability and its maintenance free nature. Since I don't know about the Lion brand and the battery appearing to be incompatible I believe it is best to get it replaced.

TIA.. :)
 
Some vehicles require AGM but a lot of stop-start vehicles are fine with EFB, I'm not familiar enough with your car to know but generally you can use EFB fine (A quick Google suggests using an EFB battery is perfectly fine with that model).

EDIT: Don't know if it is relevant here but it used to be recommended to avoid using AGM if they are in close proximity to hotter parts of the engine and use EFB instead.

Usually there is very little difference between equivalent tier Bosch and Varta batteries - they are basically the same thing under different names. The odd model aside where sometimes they are manufactured by Exide.
 
Last edited:
@Rroff I will look into the AGM aspect of being closer to the engine. It is closer in the Mondeo, as it sits on the rear LHS of the engine (RHS when you are standing in front of the car). Car is a 17 plate and at about 108,500 miles.

Exide is also one of the brands I incline towards.
 
Regarding brands I only buy Bosch, Yuasa or Varta. I believe halfords batteries are rebranded Yuasa or they used to be. The car will likely need it's battery monitoring software reset, my 62 plate Focus did. This can be done without specialist tools though: To reset the Battery Management System (BMS) on a 2017 Ford Mondeo after a battery change, enter the car, turn the ignition on (engine off), flash high beams 5 times, and press the brake 3 times. A flashing battery light on the dash confirms a successful reset.
 
I called Tayna batteries after doing some light reading on AGM batteries and their degradation when installed in Engine Bay. They mentioned AGM batteries are ok in the Engine Bay and have no issues with regards to their placement.

One interesting thing they said was I cannot downgrade the battery once upgraded. For example, if I upgrade to AGM I cannot go down to EFB as a replacement and similarly from EFB to Standard.

Edit: Fattest finger pressed enter before completing my comment.
 
Last edited:
I played around with Copilot today and giving the summary below. Please take it with a pinch of salt as I spotted mistakes in it too.

Finding the correct battery for fitment.

✅ Yes — an AGM battery is perfectly fine in a 2017 Mk5 Ford Mondeo 2.0 TDCi after a BMS reset.

In fact, it’s not just “fine” — it’s the correct type for that generation of Mondeo if the car has:​

  • Start‑Stop
  • Smart charging
  • Regenerative braking
  • High electrical load
Most Mk5 Mondeos with the 2.0 TDCi engine were factory‑equipped with AGM.
Click to expand...

Clarifying the differences between Bosch, Varta and Yuasa.

1. Bosch vs Varta — the secret you’re not supposed to notice​

Here’s the twist:

Bosch AGM and Varta AGM are the same battery.
Manufactured by the same company: Clarios (formerly Johnson Controls).

They come off the same production line.Same plates.Same separators.Same chemistry.Same performance.Different sticker.

The only differences are:
  • Bosch tends to be slightly more expensive
  • Varta tends to be easier to find
  • Warranty terms vary by retailer, not manufacturer
So between Bosch and Varta, you’re choosing branding, not engineering.

2. Yuasa — the quiet overachiever​

Yuasa is the one that actually breaks the pattern.

Yuasa AGM batteries are:
  • Built in different factories
  • Using their own plate design
  • With slightly thicker lead grids
  • And a reputation for handling deep cycling better
Yuasa tends to excel in:
  • Cars that do lots of short trips
  • Cars with heavy electrical loads
  • Cars that sit unused for days
  • Cars with start‑stop that triggers frequently
Where Yuasa often wins is longevity — they’re known to last a year or two longer in harsh conditions.
Click to expand...

Summary:

Yuasa YBX9115 AGM​

The longest‑lasting, toughest, most resilient choice.
If he wants the best value:
Strengths:
  • Exceptional deep‑cycle durability
  • Handles short journeys better than Bosch/Varta
  • Often lasts 1–2 years longer in real‑world use
  • Very stable under high accessory load
Weaknesses:
- Usually the most expensive
- Slightly heavier

Best for:
Drivers who do short trips, lots of stop-start, or want maximum lifespan.

Varta A6 AGM​

Same performance as Bosch, lower price, excellent reliability.
If he wants the Bosch badge:

Strengths:
  • OEM‑grade quality (Clarios manufacture)
  • Excellent cold‑start performance
  • Very stable under smart‑charging
  • Usually the best price-to-performance ratio
  • Widely available
Weaknesses:
  • Not the absolute longest lifespan under harsh short‑trip usage
Best for: Drivers who want top performance without paying a premium.

Bosch S5A11 AGM​

A Varta in fancier armour.

Strengths:
  • Identical construction to Varta (same Clarios factory)
  • Strong brand reputation
  • Excellent cranking and stability
Weaknesses:
  • Often priced higher than Varta for no technical advantage
Best for: Drivers who like the Bosch name or find a good deal.
Click to expand...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom