Case choice for NAS?

Associate
Joined
4 Jan 2010
Posts
10
Location
UK
So, I'm completely stuck for choice here. I'm building out a new NAS, using off the shelf hardware (mostly used... I'll do it 'properly' eventually)
However, I'm uncertain what way to go.
I've got two distinct routes, with about 5 cases and 1 outsider to pick from
First, I'll start with what I have:
  • ATX mobo
  • Gen1 Ryzen 3
  • 16GB DDR4
  • 8GB DDR3 ECC
  • 4 x 3TB Ironwolf drives
  • 1 x WD Black 250GB M2 SSD
My plans for the NAS
  • PLEX
  • CCTV (Storage, from BlueIris)
  • Photo Storage (Amature Photographer)
  • Eventually get some Ironwolf SSD's
My two paths are ATX or mITX. If I go mITX, I'll probably get the Biostar A10N-8800E.
ITX Cases
  • In-Win IW-MS04-1
    • 4 bay hot swap
    • reviews nicely to work on
    • 2 2.5" bays for SSD's
  • Silverstone DS380
    • 8 bay hot swap
    • Doesn't review nicely to work on
ATX Cases (all silverstone, as they appear to own this market...)
  • CS380
    • Tower \ ATX version of the DS380.
    • 8 Hotswap drives
    • Plenty of work space
  • GD07
    • Fits in a rack (no rails though)
    • 5 3.5" internal bays
    • 4 5.25" drive bays
      • Will likely end up being used with adaptors for more disk drives
  • GD08
    • Fits in a rack (no rails though)
    • 8 3.5" bays
    • 2 5.25" bays
  • CS350B
    • Fits in a rack, has rails
    • 5 hot swap bays
    • Most expensive (probably the big blocker tbh)
While I wont be rack mounting yet, it's a consideration for the future, when I get out of my flat.
It also goes without saying that I'm going to need a controller card for additional drives.
 
So having spoken to a few people at work as well on this. I've decided that I'm going to go for the GD08 case.
Why?
  • Fits better with long term plans (rack)
  • mITX is expensive, while same spec on ATX is readily available and cheaper.
  • More Drives (I have no doubt I'll be expanding here)
  • I don't feel like I NEED hotswap, though it's a definite nice to have.
  • It'll be quieter and run cooler
  • Makes better use of my existing hardware.
In answer to Avalon, getting a regular ATX case did cross my mind, and I seriously considered it, but I feel spending a smidge more and getting something like this will ultimately suit better.
 
Back
Top Bottom