Cheap projector suggestions

Soldato
Joined
31 May 2009
Posts
21,457
Cheap projector suggestions

I am after a cheap projector for use outside in the evenings, to screen onto an opened awing while we sit in the hut tub and ignore the world.
Small speakers would be a bonus, as would the ability to play direct from a usb stick etc.

I've no idea at all in the world of projectors.
 
I bought one of these a couple of years ago, I think it will play movies off a USB stick but not 100% certain. Needs to be night time to be effective though, its pretty much useless in a room unless its more or less pitch black. I used it for PP so no idea with Home cinema/outdoor use TBH. I paid £200 from the purple shirt place when it was on offer, I think they still sell it.

Small & has a built-in battery (Didn't know that!) Speaker is not good but it has bluetooth so good bluetooth speakers should solve that.

https://www.lg.com/uk/projectors/lg-PH150G
 
How cheap is 'cheap' in your eyes?
This is the point, as I have no experience, and I am not looking for something for everyday usage, i don't plan to watch proper stuff on this, just use it as a background distraction outside in low light, twilight or potentially a bit of daytime (summer is 20 hours daytime now).
What i am wondering is if any of these £100-£200 amazon plastic jobs are remotely worthwhile for that purpose?
Or what the alternative bottom of the price barrel would be? as in how much should i be spending on something useful as a budget projector?
 
I'm interested in this too, for me it would be for occasional use in the bedroom where we don't have/want a TV.

Reviews on Amazon seem to show people generally happy with their £100 ("HD") - £200 ("1080p") ish projectors but who knows.
 
I guess if it's just as a 'background distraction' then something such as the Apeman 5000 Lumen Mini Portable Projector at £130 would be passable. The exact model is LC550, but that isn't mentioned in the headline description. The brightness spec is a bit of a work of fiction, but they've been honest with the resolution which is 1280x720 pixels.

I was going to list what's missing from the spec for comparison purposes to a proper home cinema projector. However, this and many similar projectors don't have a proper specification list.

There are some inevitable compromises made to achieve the price. Internally, they need to make these as simple as possible, so they do away with the standard 3xLCD panel array or DLP chip with colour wheel that you'll find on mainstream projectors. Instead, what you have is a single display panel a bit like a small Sat-Nav or phone display stripped down with light shining through it. It works to a fashion, but the image loses brightness and the focus suffers towards the edges of the screen.

The optical path isn't good. On the older models (other brands) I've seen stripped down there's only a rudimentary light alignment and UV filter in place between the lamp and panel. This explains the loss of brightness towards the screen edges, and doesn't bode well for the life of the imaging panel.

Once the image leaves the panel, the main focussing lens it passes through is also very basic. There's no zoom, and it lacks the multiple elements and lens coatings that help reduce refraction and focus issues. With better quality projectors, the image has good top-to-bottom and side-to-side focus when the projector is level with either the screen top edge or bottom edge. These cheaper units lack the optical elements to match this. The best focus is achieved with the projector level with the centre of the screen/projected image. That puts it smack in the middle of the user's view of the screen which isn't ideal.
 
Lucid is obviously far more knowledgeable than me on this subject so I hope he chimes in on that. That said from what I was looking at the Epson EB-S41 at around £300 seemed to be the next rung up from the £100-£200 projectors on Amazon. It has the 3xLCD Lucid mentions I believe.
 
Last edited:
Lucid is obviously far more knowledgeable than me on this subject so I hope he chimes in on that. That said from what I was looking at the Epson EB-S41 at around £300 seemed to be the next rung up from the £100-£200 projectors on Amazon. It has the 3xLCD Lucid mentions I believe.
800 x 600 :eek::eek::eek::eek::eek::eek::eek:...........................:eek:
NO
 
Price-wise I'm going to say £500 just to plant a flag in the ground and get the conversation going. But like all things, it's not the final word.

Ignoring the Chinese projectors, there are something like 130 different models under £1000 currently available from reputable projector brands. Although the lowest cost projectors with either 3xLCD or DLP light engines start from as little as £250 (e.g. Acer X118), you really don't want something like this for home entertainment.

Within the projector market, there's 'budget' and there's 'entry-level'; these two things are not the same. Budget products are the cheapest of the breed that a manufacturer can make. All the fat is cut away, and quite a bit of the lean, too. You end up with the lowest spec and lowest performance. These things are designed for occasional workplace use where no one is being critical of the image. They might be noisy, have low resolution (SVGA 4:3), maybe some image brightness issues at the edges, and definitely low fidelity when it comes to motion handling and scaling and colour accuracy.

For home entertainment or home cinema, and entry-level machine isn't the same as a budget projector. These are designed with video in mind. The light output is tuned for contrast, and the panel will invariably be 1920x1080 HD. The motion processing and scaling will do a fairly decent job of handling upscaling and movement. The fan noise will be quieter because, in most cases, the light output won't be screwed to the max for PowerPoint.

An Optoma HD27e is an entry-level home entertainment projector at £450 new that's worth owning. Around a similar price you also have the Benq W1050 and Epson EH-TW650.

These are still at the shallow end of the market. On paper, there won't appear to be that much difference between these and 1080p machines at £4000-£6000, but performance is another thing altogether. In fact, I could show you the Benq, then the Optoma, and you see an improvement, then show you a s/h JVC for £700-ish that would have been £3500-£4000 new and you'd be absolutely floored with the difference.

I wouldn't use a JVC for what you're planning. It's a big old Hector, so is far better suited to permanent installation; but the point really is about the steps up in performance. The cheapest proper machines aren't in the game for video at all. You'd be just as well with the £130 pj from Amazon. Even the higher-level business machines are relatively poor for video, and that includes product at £2000+. Doing video justice, even if its as a background, means getting something designed for the job.
 
I have an Anker Nebula Mars 2, it's a really cool little gadget and the picture quality is OK. No chance of being able to watch it before about 10pm in the summer though.
 
Back
Top Bottom