Dead Pixel :(

Soldato
Joined
12 Nov 2008
Posts
3,378
Location
T.O.
Having only had my 1000D for 3 days I've already encountered a dead pixel!
It's down the bottom left hand side of the image and is bright green.

Surely as this is well within the warranty, I would be entitled to a replacement or would they regard this as normal manufacturing error?

I'll try and upload a picture later on tonight.
Shooting to RAW, don't think it will be as noticeable in JPEG but its annoying me :(

Surely, despite this being a relatively budget DSLR, I'm still well within my rights to ask for a RTM?
 
Well, as promised.
This has been converted to JPG but you can still clearly see it.

deadpixel.jpg


Thoughts?
 
Bought online? If so, DSA will cover you. Bought from shop? Walk in, show your image(s) and ask them nicely for a change as it is the retailers responsibility.
 
I bought it Online.
Thanks Mr Jones, I just wanted to make sure that it's not something that happens to every camera.
Will contact them ASAP.
 
You're always going to get a certain amount of pixel defects on most Camera Sensors. They're most noticable when you do long exposures - as in your picture I believe. Some of the individual sensors go hot and stand out from the surrounding ones.

You can do a rough check by taking a long exposure shot with the lens cap in a darkened room. There will not be many cameras that don't show up the odd coloured pixel. (zoom into your picture when you have taken it and pan across it to check).

What you will notice when taking a shot as above (set your camera to Bulb and keep the shutter button held down for 20 or 30 seconds) is that the resultant picture is not 100% black. Each of the sensor receptors exhibit some form of noise, so your black picture is in effect a series of grainy pixels. With a perfect sensor in a pitch black environment the picture should be totally black - but it isn't due to imperfections with the sensors and electrical signal noise.

I've noticed some on my 50D when I did some long exposures. However they're not noticable on normal shots. You can also get signal noise affecting the shot too.

I would also take a look at page 155 of the manual for the Canon 1000D it shows how to set Long exposure Noise reduction to on/off or automatic. Auto basically applies the noise reduction on pictures with an exposure time of more than 1 second. It can take a little longer to record the picture to the Memory card - sometimes as long as the exposure took, as the picture is processed. The upshot of the applied processing is that in many cases the hot pixel can disappear. You can do this whether or not you are shooting in RAW or JPEG.

Also bear in mind that the RAW output is what the sensor sees with no processing applied, JPEG is an altered version with processing applied - hence it might not show up when shooting in JPEG
 
Last edited:
Andy90, thanks very much. Thats quite a detailed post!

I'll be sure to have a look at the manual regarding that feature.
I was unsure about how many dead pixels would contribute towards me being able to return it...

You are right, during manufacture there tend to be a few dead pixels from the start, they are "mapped" so the camera knows where they are and what to ignore.

There are a few different types of abnormalities in pixels from what I have gleaned from various websites.

When viewing in RAW this will show up as a green pixel, regardless of exposure and shutter speed. This I understand is actually a Stuck Pixel.

When decreasing shutter speeds more noise is generally the factor of Hot Pixels overheating and producing a haze of reds and blues.

I know I could always edit this out in Post, but it really annoys me that its only 4 or so days old! :p
 
I know how you feel. My 50D has taken less than 1500 shots and there are 'stuck' pixels on my sensor too.

As for what is acceptable and what isn't well I'm sorry I haven't got a clue - I know Monitor manufactures have some sort of Standard, so I suppose Camera Manufactures may have as well - but I bet it is well hidden.
 
Last edited:
Intrigued by this topic, I've decided to go on an Internet Hunt to see what information I could find on it.

One of my first bits of information was found on another forum dating from 2002 (so its a little old)

http://www.pcreview.co.uk/forums/thread-1561266.php

The first thread seems to be a quote from Nikon Singapore, the information is quite interesting, it mentions the red, blue and green pixels and describes taking a shot of the lens cap as I did above. It calls them 'christmas tree artifacting'.

This is what it says (if that forum is ever unavailable)....

A common complaint amongst digital camera owners of all brands, particularly as their cameras get older, is that of pixels that are always on or off ('stuck' or 'dead').What is STUCK Pixel?
A Stuck Pixel is a pixel that always reads high or is always on to maximum power on all exposures. This produces a bright pixel usually of red, blue or green in color in the final image. A Stuck pixel will occurs regardless of shutter speed, aperture size or any other user settings. It will occurs on normal exposure and tends to be more obvious under dim condition as it tend to stand out. What is DEAD Pixel?
A Stuck Pixel (think this was a typo and should have read A Dead Pixel) is a pixel that reads zero or is always off on all exposures. This state produces a black pixel in the final image. Similar to STUCK Pixel, a dead pixel will occurs regardless of shutter speed, aperture size or any other user settings. It will occurs on normal exposure and tends to be more obvious under bright condition as it tend to stand out.

NOTE : Do note that STUCK or DEAD Pixel will occurs at the same location for all images. If the location of the STUCK or DEAD Pixel occurs at different location, it may be a HOT Pixel.

What is HOT Pixel?
A 'hot' pixel is a pixel that reads high(Light Up) on longer exposures, and can produce white, red (orange) or green (yellow green) pixels in longer exposures. The longer the exposure the more visible the hot pixels. These pixels become more evident with longer exposures. HOT Pixel may also occurs when the camera heated up during prolong usage for certain cameras. This is due to the fact that when the CCD get heated up, more electrons wander off into the substract by themselves and result in false positives. It is not possible to have a image that is entirely clean of HOT Pixels during long exposure. Therefore in most of Nikon Digital Cameras there is a Noise Reduction mode that can be set from the menu or from certain scenes mode to reduce the effect of HOT Pixels.

Testing for STUCK and DEAD Pixels

A common mistake in testing for Dead or Stuck pixels is to cover the lens with the lens cap, set the camera to AUTO. Setting to Auto will cause the camera to lower the shutter speed thus result in taking a long exposure. This produces some red, greenish and sometimes white pixels. This is a normal state and it is referred to as Christmas Tree artifacting. In addition, a dead pixel is dead all the time and would not show up with this test since the pixel is black.
STEP 1 : Take some shots of of normal indoor environment such as a portrait.
STEP 2 : Compare two shot using a photo editor such as Photoshop or Nikon Editor where it allows you to compare two images side by side. If you notice there is a bright pixel occurring on one image, do the comparison on the other image, both should have the bright pixel on the same location. if it is on the same location it can be consider as a HOT pixel.

How do I rectify the problem?
You can bring your camera together with your warranty card to Nikon Service Centre where our technician will be able to rectify the problem.
 
Last edited:
Cheers for that!

I've contacted the company I bought it from and I've arranged a replacement :)

Hopefully this one is slightly better!
 
Back
Top Bottom