• Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

Difference between P4-m and Mobile P4

Soldato
Joined
21 Oct 2002
Posts
14,595
Location
Wellington, NZ
Just wondering if I can replace my 2.4GHz P4-m with a 3.06GHz Mobile P4? They are both socket 478... P4-m runs at 400fsb and Mobile P4 at 533mhz I think...

Will it work?
 
Depends if your mobo supports a 533mhz fsb and if your cooling is up to it really. What laptop is it?
 
Would it just not work or could it run it at 400fsb?

It's an old Dell C640, running 2gb ram and winxp.
 
The 2.4 "Northwood" based P4-M is a 35W part with a 400mhz FSB as you said, There are several 3.06 models, two based on the northwood core, with or without Hyperthreading which are 70W parts, and a Prescott version which is 88watts.

All the 3.06's are 533mhz FSB parts. Biggest issue is going to be the cooling, unless the Laptop was designed to support faster CPU's jumping from a 35W cpu to a 70W (or more) cpu is bound to cause some heat issues. Even if dell sold that model with a 3.06 option, it might not have used the same cooling system.

Whatever you decide, do it with care, as some laptop batteries can become unstable when subjected to additional heat especially lithium ion battery packs, and of course if the CPU overheats to much it will just throttle back and end up slower than the 2.4 cpu anyway.
 
Avoid any mobile prescott like the plague. Have repaired quite a few laptops with 'Northwood upgrades' as the power draw of the prescott caused random overheating and juiced out batteries damaged beyond charge, dead psus and dead mobos due to power regulator failure. The ones i saved at work and for customers are probably still ticking over with the NW mobiles (usually 2.6 and 3.06 models if i remember right).
 
Back
Top Bottom