Was unlikely to be PSU, imho. Mobo, CPU or RAM, then (in that order of likeliness). My worry is your mobo is damaging the GPU(s), so if I were you, while you know the GPU is OK (perhaps re-confirm that is the case in your friends rig since it has been back in your mobo) I wouldn't be wanting to put it back in that mobo. What mobo does your friend have? If you can try your CPU and RAM in his mobo, and all is OK, you've eliminated everything but your mobo.