+1
The DVI-I give you the option to use a DVI to VGA adapter to hook up older monitors.
DVI-I will also drive standard DVI-D monitors (or HDMI monitors with a cheap adapter) just as well as a DVI-D port.
If your monitor's resolution has a 60Hz refresh rate, DVI-D input and 1920x1200 or less resolution, then I would personally use the DVI-D connection. As most cards that have this DVI arrangement (like the recent AMD cards) have the DVI-D as only single link, while the DVI-I is dual-link (higher bandwidth). Therefore, if your first monitor can be run on the single-link connection, then this leaves the higher bandwidth and more versatile dual link DVI-I connection free to use with future monitors (which could be 2560x1440+ res or 120Hz refresh rate).