EA Hints at Dropping PC Retail Games!!

Soldato
Joined
8 Dec 2005
Posts
10,934
http://www.edge-online.com/features/upping-the-game

Sounds as though they want to release all their PC titles on their own digital distribution system. Not a good move as if they go ahead you can bet others will follow and all PC games will become digital before long. From this article its not clear if they are talking about their PC sports games or all PC games.
 
EAs distribution system is awful, and plagued with problems. Going to a fully digital method of selling games is OK with a platform like steam, but doing it with the EA download is a huge mistake.
 
whys that a bad thing?

Because at the moment for most publishers it just seems like a way of making massive extra profit?

Just look at some of the stuff on Steam.

Empire:TW for example, £40. Retail, it can be had for ~£30 if not better. If we moved to a system whereby you can only buy games from the publishers own digital system you'd be screwed for shopping around and they could just sell at whatever price they wanted, which as many have demonstrated with Steam would probably be stupidly high.
 
whys that a bad thing?

no more bargain bins? no more picking up games for bugger all.

no more hefty discounts from certain online stores that sell for cheaper than shops/digital download.
bf2 complete collection from EA 20quid, from a shop 7quid

maybe 13quid isnt much to you thought? but to me its a takeaway or another game
 
what nonsense, firstly the online stores are ONLY expensive because they DON'T want to compete with high street prices, if they cease to care about high street prices they will sell at a price that gives them the most sales/profit ratio, which will be a cheap price, probably cheaper than retail. As for internet connections, thats a load of crock aswell, the newest releases you can preload slowly for days beforehand. Even a slow slow connection can generally download FAR FAR faster than delivery of a game and if you compare to going into a store which most people are sensible enough not to do because online is almost always cheaper, if not far cheaper, then so what the majority of games would still only take 5-6 hours maybe on a 512kb connection which is pretty widespread in terms of speed.

as for the EA download manager, again if they switched to ONLY using it they'd upgrade it, almost certainly improve it. But to be fair, i bought BF errm, whatever it was 2142 i guess, had no problems buying, downloading and getting it uber quick as it was and that was several years ago now.

Again prices you compare now are very much on purpose meant to NOT be competitive because firstly they haven't set themselves up to be a online only distribution if suddenly every single person in the world bought their next title online only the whole system would crash. If they switched to only delivering digital content they would change prices and the delivery system.

As for bargain bins, people don't stop making threads about how many deals are on for older games on steam. Steam is massively more used than EA's because EA really aren't promoting, pricing or trying to persaude people to go that route yet.
 
Steam is massively more used than EA's because EA really aren't promoting, pricing or trying to persaude people to go that route yet.

I agree, if/when EA actually TRY with an electronic download platform, they will almost certainly start pricing more agressively.

Dont forget, they allready offer some games on STEAM, just not in the UK.
 
Reading that, it seems this just concerns the EA Sports division. They cant be having much joy with the PC platform, but then sports games were/are always better suited to consoles.
 
the majority of games would still only take 5-6 hours maybe on a 512kb connection which is pretty widespread in terms of speed.

Speed wouldn't be the issue for most people, download caps would be. Even so, I suspect your time estimate for 512k would be closer to double if you assuming a game would be about 2.5GB in download form (ie. compressed, not just a 4.7/9GB DVD image)
 
I for one would love to see a TRUE Next gen Tiger Woods and NHL 2010 on the PC be it digital download or not.

Would just be happy to see it, EA can deliver it to me any way they please, as long as its not via their current EA downloader :)
 
what nonsense, firstly the online stores are ONLY expensive because they DON'T want to compete with high street prices, if they cease to care about high street prices they will sell at a price that gives them the most sales/profit ratio, which will be a cheap price, probably cheaper than retail.
I'm sorry, but that's just simply not true. I don't know if you've ever run a business before but with a business, the bigger the profit margin the better. With a company like EA, the BIGGER the profit margin, the better. EA would not sell at 'a cheap price' as they will have no competition and therefore, no need to price war. Obviously they'll still be competing with retailers distributing games and products from other game companies, but be under no illusion that EA have any interest in anything other than making maximum profit.
 
I'm all for digital downloads, but I won't be buying a single game over EA's awful distribution system.
 
If you've ever experienced the download manager for the sims 2, which EA released to go along with their content 'shop' its diabolical. I've heard of a lot of different problems from it (in one case they paid for the content and it never registered with their game)

I imagine a game downloader that they would think up be similarly plagued by problems.

I'm with the people that prefer to have real copies of games not some digital version sitting on my PC.
 
going digital is a goodthing.. And to say thats its horrible and bugged, if they were to go 100% into it you can bet theywill invest tomake it perfect...
 
The main problem with Digital Downloads is that unless they just use one platform it gets a pain in the backside to manage.

If everything was on Steam (at a decent price) then fine. If you have D2D, EA, MS Live, Steam, GOG and no doubt the countless others that will want a piece of the market it becomes a nightmare. You end up having countless usernames and passwords and it's just not worth the hassle.

I much prefer my games in a nice big box with proper instructions, maps, etc. rather than the crappy DVD case with an online manual.


M.
 
going digital is a goodthing.. And to say thats its horrible and bugged, if they were to go 100% into it you can bet theywill invest tomake it perfect...

They will never make it perfect. There is no such thing as perfection just something to stride towards. Steam is the best example and still far from perfect.


M.
 
Back
Top Bottom