England v England - Who would win?

[Vegetarian]

England against England - who would win - All players at prime of their playing skills - discuss!

Team A
----------------Robinson--------------
----Terry-------Ferdinand-----Campbell---
-----------------Robson(c)--------------
Beckham-Gerrard-----------Scholes--A.Cole
----------------Rooney-----------------
-----------------Lineker-----------------


----------Owen------Shearer-----------
---------------Sheringham-------------
---Lampard------------------Gazza-----
----------------Ince-------------------
Pearce---Adams-----Butcher---G.Neville
--------------Seaman--------------------
Team B

 

[Killerkebab]

I'm tempted to say TeamA.

 

[BrenOS]

Questionable formation, but Team A has the better personnel.

 

[ballistic]

imo B

 

[KizZ]

A imo

 

[wedgie]

Going purely off the players in each team I would say team A

 

[MR_Punk]

A just gets it by a whisker 17-16 on pens!

+44

 

[Nix]

A just gets it by a whisker 17-16 on pens!

+44

That's where you're wrong

Seaman > Penalties

I think they're pretty even though.

 

[wedgie]

Team B seems to have the better penalty takers as well so I would have to agree with Nix, if it went to penalties team B would probably take it

 

[newbiejim]

Team B has a superb defence, Butcher was truly awesome, Adams also.........(not at driving tho )

so Team B

 

[memphisto]

team B.

 

[Gilly]

In those formations team B would kill team A. You've hinged your team on a centreback that can't play in a back three.

 

[mc_bob]

Team B.
Seamans too good to let anything in.

MC_Bob

 

[Gilly]

Team B.
Seamans too good to let anything in.

MC_Bob

Did you ever watch Seaman for England?

 

[mc_bob]

Did you ever watch Seaman for England?

Lol, may of been too young to remember?
I just remember him being a complete goal keeping ledgend.

MC_Bob

 

[EasyG]

gazza in his prime and with those 3 solid strikers team B would murder team A, don't think robinson could cope with owen , shearer and teddy.

plus ferdinand and campbell would get run ragged.

 

[fozzybear]

Team A because i have no idea who Peace and Nevelle are!

 

[Chunky]

Team A only just

 

[Pumpkinstew]

Two formations with no wingers favours the long ball merchants in Team B. They just have to lump it forward and wait for Ferdinand to make a mistake and pinch one.
Lineker will get kicked off the park, and as for Pearce versus Beckham.........

 

[FeFiDoh]

team b easy! tbh the team back then seemed to work really well and linked plays were awesome! plus shearer is in it LEGEND! what a game it would be tho.