Family car for under £20K (used). Audi vs. Skoda?

Family_Guy81

Family_Guy81

Family_Guy81

Associate
Joined
22 Oct 2020
Posts
6
I need to buy a used car in the next six months to replace my old VW Golf diesel, and need some advice:

- Budget is max £20K. Criteria is car needs to be automatic and petrol.
- Mileage is around 10K per yr, and car will be used for town driving, weekend getaways and holidays.
- I have a 3 & 5y old, so need a decent sized boot for kids clobber (prams on way out thankfully).
- Both me and the wife not fan of SUV's, so thinking saloon/hatch or estate
- Wife will be using it as well, so needs to be something she can be confident driving size-wise.

I'll be honest, I do care about looks and so something that looks refined/sporty. For my budget, I'm currently considering 2-4yr old cars, including;

1) Audi A4 Avant - I heard it can be tight on space (boot and rear seats) for a family of four - any views?
2) Audi A6 Avant - Rare to find in my budget, but is it worth the extra space for the additional cost?
3) Skoda Superb estate or hatch - Boot is huge, but is it really necessary for daily use? Any advice on choosing between estate vs. hatch? Sportline trim in both looks good!

Or anything else I should be considering? VW Passat saloon/estate practical, but looks a bit dull? Mazda 6 touring nice but like goldust in the 2.0 litres version which is the more fuel efficient choice in the petrol.
 
2 and 3 seem to be a bit contradictory, in 2 you are questioning whether additional space in an A6 is worth the cost, but in 3 you're asking if an (i think similarly sized boot in a Superb?) is actually necessary..
You're going to get a lot more for your money going Skoda, only you can decide whether the additional space is going to be useful to you!
 
akaFonzie said:
2 and 3 seem to be a bit contradictory, in 2 you are questioning whether additional space in an A6 is worth the cost, but in 3 you're asking if an (i think similarly sized boot in a Superb?) is actually necessary..
You're going to get a lot more for your money going Skoda, only you can decide whether the additional space is going to be useful to you!
Click to expand...

Yes, I think this is the dilemma we're facing. Bit of a goldilocks situation - want something big enough to cope with demands of family life, but not too big that the wife will have a panic everytime she's behind the wheel. We'll test drive of course, but wanted to get a feel for anyone who has had experience of driving these wagons.
 
Family_Guy81 said:
Yes, I think this is the dilemma we're facing. Bit of a goldilocks situation - want something big enough to cope with demands of family life, but not too big that the wife will have a panic everytime she's behind the wheel. We'll test drive of course, but wanted to get a feel for anyone who has had experience of driving these wagons.
Click to expand...

I'd think that the A6 and Superb will feel rather large, if you want to have a decent amount of space in the car it's going to be fairly big! Though, newer cars with a lot of sensors should make manoeuvring a bit easier!
 
Dis86 said:
Considered a 3 series or one of volvos offerings?
Click to expand...

I did look at the 3 Series Touring, and offer the best driving experience. I have a similar concern to the A4 Avant about real practicality however, and heard they can be a little cramped when its comes to boot and rear passenger space. However, not ruled out and still in the mix! I haven't looked too much as volvo's, but I'm not wholly convinced about the interior styling.
 
We have two kids of a similar age and cope very will with our Yeti. It's more car like to drive than SUV but loads of space and the extra height is nice. Plenty of good options for well under £20k.
 
a yeti lol, i mean come on who in the right mind would hand over such money for a ugly monstrosity like that.
just screams gave up on life.
 
Last edited:
Family_Guy81 said:
I did look at the 3 Series Touring, and offer the best driving experience. I have a similar concern to the A4 Avant about real practicality however, and heard they can be a little cramped when its comes to boot and rear passenger space. However, not ruled out and still in the mix! I haven't looked too much as volvo's, but I'm not wholly convinced about the interior styling.
Click to expand...

Took a couple photos of my A4 Avant, excuse the mess. Hopefully that helps.

eCEBEvKl.jpg

eYJCwObl.jpg
 
As a serial Audi A4 and A6 Avant owner (6 in the last 20 years) I wouldn't buy either over a Skoda unless you're concerned about the badge or there is a specific feature you want. I always had allroads and the lease deals on them meant I kept getting them. The dealer maintenance costs are significantly higher than for Skoda and once they are out of warranty they can go wrong and when they do go wrong it's VERY expensive to fix them. You'll also struggle to get a petrol A6 as between 2013 and 2019 they were diesel only unless you wanted an S6 or RS6.

The Superb is available with the same 4 wheel drive system as the Audi's if that's of interest and the bigger power engines (3.6 V6 and 2.0l 280PS variant) are really nice to drive and tend to be exceptionally well equipped (although you only get the best auto cruise control, night vision and HUD on the Audi models). The Skoda is the best example possible of why truly excellent cars die a death because of unfashionable badges in the UK.
 
WJA96 said:
The Superb is available with the same 4 wheel drive system as the Audi's if that's of interest
Click to expand...

Not quite correct, they are completely different systems. Superb/Octavia 4 wheel drive systems are akin to the A3/Q3 4 wheel drive 'haldex' system rather than the proper quattro system found on A4/A5/A6 etc
 
I think that might have been the case previously but I'm 99.9% certain that now only the Q7 and RS models have the "better" system. The only way to tell really is if you check the manual and you have to replace all 4 tyres because the system can detect a difference in the wheel speed as a result of replacing one worn tyre and the other three being a smaller diameter.
 
WJA96 said:
I think that might have been the case previously but I'm 99.9% certain that now only the Q7 and RS models have the "better" system. The only way to tell really is if you check the manual and you have to replace all 4 tyres because the system can detect a difference in the wheel speed as a result of replacing one worn tyre and the other three being a smaller diameter.
Click to expand...

Nah, the engines are mounted longitudinally still in the A4/A5/A6 and transverse in Superb/Golf/Octavia/A3/A1/Q3 etc. Completely different layout
 
LiE said:
It will be fine. I only have a 5 year old in ours but there’s plenty of space.

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202009113602172?advertising-location=at_cars&year-from=2016&price-to=20000&postcode=MK2 2LQ&sort=year-desc&fuel-type=Petrol&include-delivery-option=on&transmission=Automatic&model=A4 AVANT&page=1&aggregatedTrim=S line&make=AUDI&onesearchad=Used&onesearchad=Nearly New&onesearchad=New
Click to expand...

Thanks for the pics, really useful. How is it for a week away? Do you find you can get what you need in the boot, or find yourself resorting to the roof box or stowing stuff in the footwell's?
 
WJA96 said:
As a serial Audi A4 and A6 Avant owner (6 in the last 20 years) I wouldn't buy either over a Skoda unless you're concerned about the badge or there is a specific feature you want. I always had allroads and the lease deals on them meant I kept getting them. The dealer maintenance costs are significantly higher than for Skoda and once they are out of warranty they can go wrong and when they do go wrong it's VERY expensive to fix them. You'll also struggle to get a petrol A6 as between 2013 and 2019 they were diesel only unless you wanted an S6 or RS6.

The Superb is available with the same 4 wheel drive system as the Audi's if that's of interest and the bigger power engines (3.6 V6 and 2.0l 280PS variant) are really nice to drive and tend to be exceptionally well equipped (although you only get the best auto cruise control, night vision and HUD on the Audi models). The Skoda is the best example possible of why truly excellent cars die a death because of unfashionable badges in the UK.
Click to expand...

Really, really useful comments and definitely gives me food for thought - running costs as well as ongoing maintenance high on my list, and need this to be a reliable servant for the next 5yrs+ ideally. I have seen Skoda does really well on reliability rankings, and is another big factor in its favour. In fact, I'm struggling to find reviews that have much bad to say about them at all with the exception of badge snobs, and the sheer size of the vehicle making it a bit cumbersome to drive. Oh, and the fact that you could be mistaken for an taxi driver from time to time ;) All of which I'm prepared to swallow for a decent spec but reliable, safe and practical family car. All also why I'm tempted to go for the sportline to just indulge a bit of my ego on the looks front.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom