• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

  • Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

From 4890-5870

Haha, so you know what you want to upgrade to but don't know what it'll get you...do you have the spending itch? ;)
5870 should be a nice upgrade, but are you having any trouble with the 4890 as it is?
 
Depends on the game. I went from 4890 to 5870 on a Q9550 @ 3.4ghz and in games and settings where 4890 struggled, there was a big difference. Best examples so far are Crysis @ v.high/8xaa and STALKER: Clearsky, where it genuinely feels almost twice as fast.

Games like L4D2, NFS:Shift, Mass Effect, etc feel barely any faster.
 
A 5850 is almost the same as a 5870 in performance. And if you overclock the 5850, it can even beat a stock 5870 in performance. Plus, you get DirectX 11.
 
Did you think about the option of buying another 4890? I'm running two and play any game at max @ 1920x1200 including games like Arma (60FPS).

Let's face it. You are not going to see huge reams of games for DX11 for a good while. So why not spend £100/120 on another card to boost your performance.
 
Thing to bear in mind is your 4890 is worth a heck of a lot on the 2nd hand market!
They seem to be going for around £100 presently! imo this is to much, but if I had one I would capitalise on this and upgrade the card right now and replace it with a 5850.

So your looking at around £120 to upgrade to a significantly more powerful card once you sell off your 4890. I think its a better option than a pair of inefficient 4890's in xfire config. I think a pair of 5770 is a far more tangible idea if you have an xfire capable board.

I really think the 5870 is proportionally to expensive against the 5850, for the cost of a single 5870 I would instead like to go mad and have a go at a tri 5770 xfire setup (mb dependent of course and probably cpu bound), which if recent reports are correct would scale to incredible levels far surpassing a 5870! and only cost £40~ more and probably consume less power than a pair of 4890's!
Im not for one second saying tri fire 5770 is a good idea though :D
 
Last edited:
because in most test the 5870 beats the 4890 crossfire

I am not sure what tests you speak of besides stuff like vantage or whatever benchmark is the current indication of how a gfx card perform but when I had the crossfire 4890 it was stupidly fast.

Then when i changed to a 5870 I noticed this difference. The 5870 did bring lower power usage and less heat overall produced by my setup. Not to mention a quieter setup overall.

But it couldn't couldn't beat my 4890 setup. Probably the only game I played where I felt the 5870 was better was in Company of Heroes. Not so much in max framerate but min framerate. The 5870 was the only ATI card I have owned so far which I felt was good for that game. But all other Ati cards running the game have left me wanting.

To be perfectly honest if I knew then what I knew now it is probably unlikely I would have gone the 5870 route as I thought the 4890cf setup was very very good and far better performer than the current bang per buck card the 5770 in single or crossfire configuration which I liked for the most part. But when I was running cf4890 I didn't get the issues that I got with cf 5770's although that was offsetted by low temps and less noise than the 4890's. But that didn't didn't bother me too much.
 
Read - This - about the differences in 5850 and 5870 in standard and overclock.
he's saying that even at max overclock on both 5850 and 5870, the 5870 is still faster.
P.S I love my 5870's :-)
 
Back
Top Bottom