General Opinions requested - my situation

Soldato
Joined
26 Apr 2004
Posts
9,789
Location
Milton Keynes
Im gonna start off by saying what Im trying to say is not very easy for me, so I do apologise if some of what I say comes off as a little self-conscious, or self focused etc, Im generally fairly inwards, and due to past experience I can be somewhat secondguessing and worrying, however something's been playing across my mind, and I'd like some opinions, and whilst perhaps a forums isnt the best place to ask, at least there would be a varying range of viewers and I'd like some perspectives.

To set the record straight, before we begin, its regards a girl.

A year ago approximately, I dated a girl, was really very very fond of her, however we broke up, as some things we probably both did wrong, and I guess perhaps this banged trust a bit, not to mention there was some external issues, like my ex's grandad had just died, and one of her friends hated me, and fancied her himself (as did a couple of others of hers, but I guess Im digressing now), but basically I guess we broke up because of stress and external issues putting pressure on trust, not seeing eye to eye with a few friends (she now no longer talks to the main one afaik) etc, and she made it clear she still really wanted to be friends with me.

At this point, I really wanted her back, however, speaking to her (later on turns out she was likely drunk) on the phone at one point, it seemed she didnt want me to ask her back out (this was a few weeks down the line), so I never did ask her back out, much as I wished to. A little while later, I discovered this may actually have been her drunk, and not quite meaning what she said, and that had I asked when she'd been sober, she may well/likely would have taken me back (I forget the exact words, it was almost a year ago), however by this time, it was a bit too late, or it seemed to me, so I let it be, although it took me a few months 'to get over her'.

Since then, I've spoken to her a bit, mostly letting her contact me, as I guess, in part I was nervous that she'd turn round and throw very horrible things at me like my first girlfriend did, and I didnt want to let myself get hurt like I did the first time round, which tore me apart for several weeks. I guess we've spoken 5 or so times in the 10/11 months its been since we broke up, however some of the calls we did have were fairly long catch up calls, lasting towards an hour, not something you'd generally do if you hated someone.

A few days ago, she told me she broke up with her now-ex, (one of the reasons I'd consigned any hope as lost), because the arguments etc got too much, and we've ended up exchanging a fair few texts. I've tried to be open and tried to forget and put things in the past between us over the months, and almost dated another girl.

However, with my friend telling me shes been sick etc, having a similar thing to what I had, and shes been upset because this has been a fairly big few days, I've found myself feeling worried about her sometimes, and have been trying to make sure shes been doing ok by text. Since we've talked a fair bit for us in the last few days, text and a little via phone, its almost as though some of the stuff I thought had gone away has come back, stuff I didnt really expect myself to still let myself feel, and I found myself thinking about her sometimes, not all the time etc, and the warmth in my chest i used to feel about her every time I spoke and though about her has started to make a comeback, I guess Im a little too emotional for my own good sometimes.

We've arranged to meet up tonight, and have some drinks, only problem is, knowing us two, we'll get completely hammered and more and more thoughts about us have played on my mind, and Im worried I'll slip up when we're drinking, or I'll say something I really shouldnt, or make a move I really shouldnt.

Im trying to work out whether what Im feeling is a resurgence of memories, or immediate lust/desire on my behalf to not be alone etc, or whether its a genuine return of feelings I thought I'd buried and forgotten. Im almost trying to work out what I should do, I've been accused now of being the nice guy (that finishes last), and Im almost worried that tommorrow when drinking, I'll mention *us* or bring up stupidly how if there was ever a chance, I'd still want her back, and whether I should even be worried, because if we're both drunk, any advances etc I could make could be put down as the drink etc talking, and yet at the same time I dont want to seem a cold hearted *******, but more and more Im finding myself wondering what could/would happening if I at least hinted now shes technically free, that I'd want/take her back.

Now that shes single again, considering how we broke up, and despite the time etc, Im not sure why Im wondering what could happen whether we could get back together, and Im not sure why Im thinking about it, i guess I know i shouldnt, yet a small part of me wonders whether she'd ever let us go beyond good friends again, and should/would I do anything tomorrow when under a lot of drinks, in a club alone with her, chatting and catching up.

To put it simply Im lost, and this is rather largely turning out as a brain dump, and Im kinda almost shivering sitting here because Im feeling slightly emotional because as I wrote above Im usually fairly inwards and dont usually sort of talk about this stuff, even with my best mate. I dont really know what to do, because as I said earlier, I dont know whether Im generally having a moment of desire for whatever reason, whether its genuine because we used to bond so well and I generally do still care (not gonna say the cliched 'l' word) and its coming back now we're more in contact again, like they say it can, whether Im just worried about her because shes been sick (but why would I be if I didnt care?!), or what to do about it and whether Im being a selfish ******* who shouldnt even think about this stuff.

Sorry, there's probably more to be said, and I know I probably would have more sort of luck throwing this at a shrink, but its almost like I cant think about anything else, once the lack of distractions have gone away, and I dunno what do do, because Im generally a loyal guy, and tend to devote myself when Im with someone, and whether what Im feeling is meaningful, even as Im stuck here thinking about her, and what happened between us, and what I feel/felt for her as I write this, whether its a phase, or whether I should do, worry, or even care what happens tomorrow along those lines, or whether Im being selfish, which I dont want to be, but then again, I dont want to be someone who's the nice guy, always thinks of others, never makes a move and comes out last.

As I say, sorry this is a brain dump, Im not used to sort of righting out part of my inner workings and I guess it shows, but I guess I just wanted some other experience and sort of perspectives on what I said, and any opinions on what I should do, because generally Im fairly relaxed but this is actually making me feel slightly stressed, like I cant get it off my mind or chest, not to mention when we're proper talking on the phone etc, Im almost feeling the warmth and such as they put it, as I used to feel, or remember feeling.

Generally Im lost, help, opinions/advice/whatever, pls
 
Last edited:
Alexrose1uk said:
Im gonna start off by saying what Im trying to say is not very easy for me, so I do apologise if some of what I say comes off as a little self-conscious, or self focused etc, Im generally fairly inwards, and due to past experience I can be somewhat secondguessing and worrying, however something's been playing across my mind, and I'd like some opinions, and whilst perhaps a forums isnt the best place to ask, at least there would be a varying range of viewers and I'd like some perspectives.

To set the record straight, before we begin, its regards a girl.

A year ago approximately, I dated a girl, was really very very fond of her, however we broke up, as some things we probably both did wrong, and I guess perhaps this banged trust a bit, not to mention there was some external issues, like my ex's grandad had just died, and one of her friends hated me, and fancied her himself (as did a couple of others of hers, but I guess Im digressing now), but basically I guess we broke up because of stress and external issues putting pressure on trust, not seeing eye to eye with a few friends (she now no longer talks to the main one afaik) etc, and she made it clear she still really wanted to be friends with me. At this point, I really wanted her back, however, speaking to her drunk on the phone at one point, it seemed she didnt want me to ask her back out (this was a few weeks down the line), so I never did ask her back out, much as I wished to. A little while later, I discovered this may actually have been her drunk, and not quite meaning what she said, and that had I asked when she'd been sober, she may well/likely would have taken me back (I forget the exact words, it was almost a year ago), however by this time, it was a bit too late, or it seemed to me, so I let it be, although it took me a few months 'to get over her'
Since then, I've spoken to her a bit, mostly letting her contact me, as I guess, in part I was nervous that she'd turn round and throw very horrible things at me like my first girlfriend did, and I didnt want to let myself get hurt like I did the first time round, which tore me apart for several weeks. I guess we've spoken 5 or so times in the 10/11 months its been since we broke up, however some of the calls we did have were fairly long catch up calls, lasting towards an hour, not something you'd generally do if you hated someone.
A few days ago, she told me she broke up with her now-ex, (one of the reasons I'd consigned any hope as lost), because the arguments etc got too much, and we've ended up exchanging a fair few texts. I've tried to be open and tried to forget and put things in the past between us over the months, and almost dated another girl. However, with my friend telling me shes been sick etc, having a similar thing to what I had, and shes been upset because this has been a fairly big few days, I've found myself feeling worried about her sometimes, and have been trying to make sure shes been doing ok by text. Since we've talked a fair bit for us in the last few days, text and a little via phone, its almost as though some of the stuff I thought had gone away has come back, stuff I didnt really expect myself to still let myself feel, and I found myself thinking about her sometimes, not all the time etc, and the warmth in my chest i used to feel about her every time I spoke and though about her has started to make a comeback, I guess Im a little too emotional for my own good sometimes.
We've arranged to meet up tonight, and have some drinks, only problem is, knowing us two, we'll get completely ******, and more and more thoughts about us have played on my mind, and Im worried I'll slip up when we're drinking, or I'll say something I really shouldnt, or make a move I really shouldnt. Im trying to work out whether what Im feeling is a resurgence of memories, or immediate lust/desire on my behalf to not be alone etc, or whether its a genuine return of feelings I thought I'd buried and forgotten. Im almost trying to work out what I should do, I've been accused now of being the nice guy (that finishes last), and Im almost worried that tommorrow when drinking, I'll mention *us* or bring up stupidly how if there was ever a chance, I'd still want her back, and whether I should even be worried, because if we're both drunk, any advances etc I could make could be put down as the drink etc talking, and yet at the same time I dont want to seem a cold hearted *******, but more and more Im finding myself wondering what could/would happening if I at least hinted now shes technically free, that I'd want/take her back. Now that shes single again, considering how we broke up, and despite the time etc, Im not sure why Im wondering what could happen whether we could get back together, and Im not sure why Im thinking about it, i guess I know i shouldnt, yet a small part of me wonders whether she'd ever let us go beyond good friends again, and should/would I do anything tomorrow when under a lot of drinks, in a club alone with her, chatting and catching up. To put it simply Im lost, and this is rather largely turning out as a brain dump, and Im kinda almost shivering sitting here because Im feeling slightly emotional because as I wrote above Im usually fairly inwards and dont usually sort of talk about this stuff, even with my best mate. I dont really know what to do, because as I said earlier, I dont know whether Im generally having a moment of desire for whatever reason, whether its genuine because we used to bond so well and I generally do still care (not gonna say the cliched 'l' word) and its coming back now we're more in contact again, like they say it can, whether Im just worried about her because shes been sick (but why would I be if I didnt care?!), or what to do about it and whether Im being a selfish ******* who shouldnt even think about this stuff. SOrry, there's probably more to be said, and I know I probably would have more sort of luck throwing this at a shrink, but its almost like I cant think about anything else, once the lack of distractions have gone away, and I dunno what do do, because Im generally a loyal guy, and tend to devote myself when Im with someone, and whether what Im feeling is meaningful, even as Im stuck here thinking about her, and what happened between us, and what I feel/felt for her as I write this, whether its a phase, or whether I should do, worry, or even care what happens tomorrow along those lines, or whether Im being selfish, which I dont want to be, but then again, I dont want to be someone who's the nice guy, always thinks of others, never makes a move and comes out last.

As I say, sorry this is a brain dump, Im not used to sort of righting out part of my inner workings and I guess it shows, but I guess I just wanted some other experience and sort of perspectives on what I said, and any opinions on what I should do, because generally Im fairly relaxed but this is actually making me feel slightly stressed, like I cant get it off my mind or chest, not to mention when we're proper talking on the phone etc, Im almost feeling the warmth and such as they put it, as I used to feel, or remember feeling.

Generally Im lost, help, opinions/advice/whatever, pls
doesn't this belong in the agony aunt forum?

wait...
 
Last edited:
Personally i would just try not to get too drunk yourself and keep yourself not talking crap. I wouldnt dive in there straight away,maybe go out a few more times to see if its all still there and then say what you want to say to her.

I still feel for my ex from over a year ago and both genuinely look out for each other but i do occasionally over analyse things that i really shouldnt. I would make it clear you still like her and care for her a lot but not so much you end up pushing each other apart.

(you appear to only be 19.....i decided to forget relationships and just concentrate on pure partying and see what you get from that rather than worrying about commitment and shizzle at this age)
 
6thElement said:
Genius right there :D

I read half then lost where I was and headed down to the replies :D

Sorry its a bit long, as I said, Im feeling somewhat lost right now, and Im not really accustomed to explaining my inner thoughts, but at the moment Im looking for perspective. I see nothing shameful about my OP, the only reason I'd edit it would be to make things clearer, where I realise I have explained badly, as I say, its a brain dump, with my current not entirely rational thinking, Im finding it hard to see whats the true right and wrong.

And yes I am 19, doesnt help me be who Im not though, I enjoy partying, but it doesnt stop what I feel, even if the consensus of a lot would be Im too young, thanks for what you said though, I will think on it.

More opinions and perspectives would be really appreciated too. As I say, Im kinda lost, and not really sure what to think. Im not good at these sorts of things either way, and I feel Im likely to mess something up anyway, as Im not to good with girls, and understanding hints etc despite meaning well, Im not good explaining myself, Im generally just not very confident or experienced in this department, so I feel Im gonna mess up, all I can state is what i feel.
 
Last edited:
Alexrose1uk said:
Sorry its a bit long, as I said, Im feeling somewhat lost right now, and Im not really accustomed to explaining my inner thoughts, but at the moment Im looking for perspective. I see nothing shameful about my OP, the only reason I'd edit it would be to make things clearer, where I realise I have explained badly, as I say, its a brain dump, with my current not entirely rational thinking, Im finding it hard to see whats the true right and wrong.

And yes I am 19, doesnt help me be who Im not though, I enjoy partying, but it doesnt stop what I feel, even if the consensus of a lot would be Im too young, thanks for what you said though, I will think on it.

More opinions and perspectives would be really appreciated too. As I say, Im kinda lost, and not really sure what to think. Im not good at these sorts of things either way, and I feel Im likely to mess something up anyway, as Im not to good with girls, and understanding hints etc despite meaning well, Im not good explaining myself, Im generally just not very confident or experienced in this department, so I feel Im gonna mess up, all I can state is what i feel.

Me again but if you have the balls to do it.....do it when your sober or not THAT drunk. What have you got to lose? If she says no then at least you can accept she said no and you can get on with life. If she says yes......then its a result,go for it.
 
Hey Alex, haven't spoken to you for a while...

I guess it comes down to whether you think a potential relationship with this girl would be a good thing. Course you still care about her - that's the way it goes, feelings don't just vanish at the end of a relationship. Reckon you should go and meet up with her, but don't allow yourself to get caned... you won't if you make an effort not to. Take it as it comes... it's too easy to think yourself into a dead-end where you don't know which way's up. If it's meant to happen, it will probably happen.
 
Aye, long time no speak Matt, I see you got yourself into oxford as well, still doesnt surprise me, you always were the A* student.

And yea, seeing whats been said elsewhere, Im thinking Im just gonna go with the flow, take care I dont say anything stupid or over the top, perhaps drop a slight hint, dependant on where the wind blows, and how she acts, and otherwise just have a good night just catching up as friends, and see what happens, and be there for a friend for her right now, but not forget the entire thing.

Will try not too get too ******, but if drinking double jagerbull/JD+coke that might get quite hard :D

I must stress it was her not me, who decided alcohol, I offered coffee too lol
 
Sweet jesus that's a long paragraph! :p

Summary:

Boy dates girl
Break-up, but 'still friends' (he wants to be with her, she wants the attention)
Inconclusive end to relationship.

Fast-forward a year

Girl breaks up with her current bloke, thinks "ah that guy's nice, he'll give me attention" - calls you and invites you out, thinking "well, course he'll be over it now, we're just mates of course.."

Guy (who still hasn't got over her, due to being strung along and lacking a clean break) is now in a headspin and doesn't know what to think.

Now, my advice.

Sure, go out and have a few drinks with her, but be legendary. :cool: Make her aware in every way that you haven't been pining after her but have been awesome. Don't chat about the past with her, talk about the past without her! Arrange for a group of mates to meet you later so she isn't getting 100% of the attention all night. Make her think "damn, I know he was a nice bloke when I was with him, but now he's awesome as well, what have I been missing?". Now you've reversed the tables and make her want you....now use that power in whichever way you want, but if you want to get back with her don't pull her (yet!)! That's giving in! Play games, have fun be awesome!!

And if all else fails, just get really really drunk and whatever happens deny all memory of it :D
 
Last edited:
Rich_L said:
And if all else fails, just get really really drunk and whatever happens deny all memory of it :D

This works wonders :D Works well with girls u really not that keen on as a whole but want to continue getting end away with too as u can both deny all knowledge :D
 
To me, it sounds like because you stayed in contact with her since the split, you've still held onto hopes of getting back with her again.

I think you really needed at least a couple of months apart after splitting, before thinking about meeting up for a friendly drink. This allows time for things to sink in to your head, and lets you "process" those emotions.

If it were me, I'd directly ask her what she wants tonight. If she says just friends, then propose some time apart first and see how you both feel. Don't ignore your feelings, by tarting around with other girls or drinking yourself stupid - those aren't real-life soloutions which will lead to a long-term relationship.
 
if you're so worried about what you might say when you're drunk then dont get drunk, simple
 
God my eyes and my brain is stressing...I had to stop :( Im sure the good members of ocuk will advice you on what to do. Goodluck.
 
Rich_L said:
Sweet jesus that's a long paragraph! :p

Summary:

Boy dates girl
Break-up, but 'still friends' (he wants to be with her, she wants the attention)
Inconclusive end to relationship.

Fast-forward a year

Girl breaks up with her current bloke, thinks "ah that guy's nice, he'll give me attention" - calls you and invites you out, thinking "well, course he'll be over it now, we're just mates of course.."

Guy (who still hasn't got over her, due to being strung along and lacking a clean break) is now in a headspin and doesn't know what to think.

Now, my advice.

Sure, go out and have a few drinks with her, but be legendary. :cool: Make her aware in every way that you haven't been pining after her but have been awesome. Don't chat about the past with her, talk about the past without her! Arrange for a group of mates to meet you later so she isn't getting 100% of the attention all night. Make her think "damn, I know he was a nice bloke when I was with him, but now he's awesome as well, what have I been missing?". Now you've reversed the tables and make her want you....now use that power in whichever way you want, but if you want to get back with her don't pull her (yet!)! That's giving in! Play games, have fun be awesome!!

And if all else fails, just get really really drunk and whatever happens deny all memory of it :D

Thanks Rich ;)

And I agree with everything he says/recommends totally. Good Luck!

BB x
 
some classic advise there from Rich agree with every word tbh.

It seems like she's using you a fall back cause she's feeling lonely and vunerable now that she's single again.

my advise to you is try not to over analyise things dont read into everything and just generally try to relax and take things as they come, if there is something there still between you investigate it but dont move too quickly.
 
Back
Top Bottom