Gigabyte Or Asus For C2D

You read my mind keeny
i have a tuniq tower coming monday from ocuk
mine was ds3 vs p5b deluxe though
just need to find out if tuniq fits ok on p5b del now.
I hear it's better than the ds3 for overclocking a 6400.
Cooling looks better too.Better build quality than the ds3.
 
I already have the p5b deluxe wifi and find it a good board - but everyone keeps ravin on about the ds3/ds4.
 
Well my only problem with the ds3 is the cooling
the northbridge heatsink looks very cheap
i'm still not decided i would like a board that can clock
a 6400 to say 3.5-3.8 ghz on the least volts possible
thus creating less heat i would'nt be able to sleep at night knowing
my northbridge was hitting 65-70 celcius.
But if the ds3 can do the job i see no reason why not to get it
seeing as it's far cheaper.
 
Given that the feature-set of the new Rev. 3.3 DS3P is almost exactly the same as the old DS4, why spend any more? I haven't had a P5B, but those that do seem to like them. The highest overclock I have yet seen 'proved stable' was done on a P5B-E by BlkNoel (4GHz on an E6300 I think) which must be some kind of recommendation.
 
my p5b temps are prety good - with my asus silent square cooler and a 6400 clocked at 2670 i get 31 idle and 44 loaded with orthos
 
They are both good boards.
geff_r said:
Well my only problem with the ds3 is the cooling
the northbridge heatsink looks very cheap
It does get hot but doesn't affect overclocking a great deal. Worth having a silent 80mm fan covering the board/chipset/memory anyway.
 
yea thats what i dont want to hear i want a board that
doesnt require me to suspend a fan blue peter style over the nbridge
looks like abit quad gt or p5b deluxe then.
 
Sorry for the stupid question what board is a ds3 Rev. 3.3.I never knew how hard it was to get a new mobo ive had 2 pointed out to me
Inno3D 680i SLI Socket 775
EVGA nForce 680i SLI SKT775
but i dident realy want to pay tha much
 
Asus clocks higher but has issues like cold boot issue and vdroop, personally i'd go for the asus but gigabyte is a problem-free board with easy overclocking options, asus has some more advanced options extra though...

All depends what kind of user you are:
If you dont care about cold boot issue and get good cooling and u know a lot about oc's: get the asus.

If you want a problem free board and you are a beginner in overclocking or dont need the extra overclock options the asus gives: get the gigabyte
 
Last edited:
I have the DS3 with a 6300 @ 460 fsb, fully stable, and no extra cooling.. I'm sure the cpu will go higher. but my ram is geil 5300 running @ 920.

I've tried a few other boards, including the Asus p5n sli plus, and none compare to the DS3.

On tuesday I will have the new DS3P, which really is the DS4 without the heat pipe.
 
Servo said:
I have the DS3 with a 6300 @ 460 fsb, fully stable, and no extra cooling.. I'm sure the cpu will go higher. but my ram is geil 5300 running @ 920.

I've tried a few other boards, including the Asus p5n sli plus, and none compare to the DS3.

On tuesday I will have the new DS3P, which really is the DS4 without the heat pipe.
The ds4 is £10 more than the ds3p so why bother? just get the ds4?
 
The only 3 boards worth considering now after a massive amount of research
seem to be
Abit ab9 quad gt
Asus p5b deluxe
Asus commando

Everything else seems to have a yea but when you look deeper.
 
geff_r said:
The only 3 boards worth considering now after a massive amount of research
seem to be
Abit ab9 quad gt
Asus p5b deluxe
Asus commando

Everything else seems to have a yea but when you look deeper.

Abit: nvr read much info about it, how does it clock?
p5b deluxe: good board yes, p5b vanilla is fine though too seen a guy @ 4 ghz on it (with a c2d 6400)...
Commando: overpriced p5b with lcd on back and bragging rights ''republic of gamers'' imo
 
snowdog said:
Abit: nvr read much info about it, how does it clock?
p5b deluxe: good board yes, p5b vanilla is fine though too seen a guy @ 4 ghz on it (with a c2d 6400)...
Commando: overpriced p5b with lcd on back and bragging rights ''republic of gamers'' imo
erm the commando has reports of going way over 500 fsb as does the quad gt
 
had for various builds

3 ds4s 1 failed
3 ds3s all good
2 s3 all good

all with e6600 clocked to 3150
or e6300 clocked to 2450

not greedy lol
all on stock volts

always had asus, fancied a change,
when i suffered their RMA!
 
Back
Top Bottom