• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

GRAW - PC v 360

What's so different about the PS2 and GameCube? The PS2 you have to buy loads of 'upgrades' for it, like ethernet, hard drive, memory cards and all that. The 360 and Xbox are more consoley since they include everything you need in the box.
 
The Xbox 360 is not a traditional PC, far from it. When was the last time the GPU in your PC could read the L2 cache directly from the CPU? When was the last time all the memory on the PC was just a single pool that the GPU/CPU/Sound chip could read/write? When was the last time a PC had a GPU that had a secondary co-processor with its own embedded memory purely for post-processing effects (such as FSAA). The console barely has something that looks like an FSB (or HyperTransport for that matter).

No, the Xbox 360 is not a 'PC'. If anything it shares more with super high-end workstations (talking Xeon MP here, not Xeon DP).

Nintendo's offering may well be more PC-like, we don't know how it works internally yet. The PS3 is still up in the air too, so you can't really comment on that one either. I guess if you really want to push, you could say the PS3 is a lot like the Cell servers.

But all this is mute, so what if any console IS a PC? Does it really matter? Surely the lack of upgrades, the availability of good games, a unified service, etc. are what matter? ie. What the product DOES as opposed to what it IS? If the Xbox 360 had 3 Athlon64s, a 7800GTX and 1GB RAM, I wouldn't care. What I care about is value for money and the games contained within.

A PC is just a Personal Computer, and with that definition a lot of devices could be considered PCs. PDAs (they compute, and they're used for one person - personal), consoles, calculators, laptops, Apple Macs etc.
 
Warbie said:
What suprises me is how many are jumping on the console bandwagon for the 360, yet didn't before.

I've wondered that too. I think a lot of the people coming to consoles for the first time with the 360, and being very impressed, would have been impressed with the first Xbox too - I know I was when I bought one in December.
 
dirtydog said:
I've wondered that too. I think a lot of the people coming to consoles for the first time with the 360, and being very impressed, would have been impressed with the first Xbox too - I know I was when I bought one in December.

The Xbox is HD, so the imagery is no longer a blur :)
Also PC games have slowed right down tbh, they either need the fastest (and the cash to back it up) PC on the planet or aren't that good. Also a lot of the good games were actually ports from consoles (KOTOR mmmm).

All imo of course.
 
Boogle said:
The Xbox is HD, so the imagery is no longer a blur :)

When you say Xbox I take it you mean Xbox 360? Well plenty of people buying a 360 only have a standard television so they obviously haven't bought it because of HD :)
 
dirtydog said:
When you say Xbox I take it you mean Xbox 360? Well plenty of people buying a 360 only have a standard television so they obviously haven't bought it because of HD :)
A heck of a lot bought it for the HD factor. Of course plenty of people haven't bought it for HD (since they don't have it), to suggest otherwise is crazy.
 
Mr Spew said:
A heck of a lot bought it for the HD factor. Of course plenty of people haven't bought it for HD (since they don't have it), to suggest otherwise is crazy.

I didn't suggest otherwise :) Personally I'm one of those weird people who buys a console because of the games on it, not the resolution they run at but that's just me.
 
I have 5 mates in my office who own 360's - every one of them have high definition displays (be it LCD or Plasma),

The high definition image that the 360 displays gives a level of immersion in games that previous consoles couldn't. As well as being 'eye-candy', better graphics DO add to the gameplay/enjoyment factor (whatever you want to call it).

Im not surprised there are so many people jumping ship from 'pc-gaming'.

Personally, even with a 7900GT in my rig, my PC barely gets a look.
 
dirtydog said:
I didn't suggest otherwise :) Personally I'm one of those weird people who buys a console because of the games on it, not the resolution they run at but that's just me.
I don't think many people do that, people have got 360s because yes, they do HD, but to use HD they have to have games to utilise that, so of course people are buying them to play games.
 
bigbilly50 said:
IThe high definition image that the 360 displays gives a level of immersion in games that previous consoles couldn't.

The 360 still hasn't matched the best offerings from Nintendo and Sony when it comes to immersion. It's early days, and I have no doubt this will change some over the next few years, and HD will certainly help.

It isn't HD that's praised in the majority of posts around here, though. It's hassle free gaming and being free from the expense and trouble of having to upgrade every 6 months. This is what suprises me - it's been like this for years and years. Other than Live, the 360 feels like every other console I have owned. The improvement in visuals granted by HD is certainly no more than the boost each new generation of consoles offered in the past.

I suspect that HD and, for many pc gamers, being able to plug the console straight into their monitor were big reasons for splashing out on a 360. Now they're enjoying the benefits that console owners have been enjoying for years.
 
Warbie said:
The 360 still hasn't matched the best offerings from Nintendo and Sony when it comes to immersion. It's early days, and I have no doubt this will change some over the next few years, and HD will certainly help.
The 360 has only been out since December 2nd.
 
Warbie said:
The 360 still hasn't matched the best offerings from Nintendo and Sony when it comes to immersion. It's early days, and I have no doubt this will change some over the next few years, and HD will certainly help.

It isn't HD that's praised in the majority of posts around here, though. It's hassle free gaming and being free from the expense and trouble of having to upgrade every 6 months. This is what suprises me - it's been like this for years and years. Other than Live, the 360 feels like every other console I have owned. The improvement in visuals granted by HD is certainly no more than the boost each new generation of consoles offered in the past.

I suspect that HD and, for many pc gamers, being able to plug the console straight into their monitor were big reasons for splashing out on a 360. Now they're enjoying the benefits that console owners have been enjoying for years.
How is it like every other console though? Xbox Live Arcade is an extremely innovative idea that was trialled on the original Xbox, it has Media Center functionality, again, nothing like previous consoles.

Oblivion is immense in it's immersion, especially for a 5 month old console.
 
NokkonWud said:
The 360 has only been out since December 2nd.

Sure, it wasn't a criticism. It was a respone to the claim that the 360 was offering immersion that previous consoles couldn't match - which isn't the case at the moment.

Mr Spew said:
How is it like every other console though? Xbox Live Arcade is an extremely innovative idea that was trialled on the original Xbox, it has Media Center functionality, again, nothing like previous consoles.

Oblivion is immense in it's immersion, especially for a 5 month old console.

Agreed, I did say Live was the one area that set the 360 apart from the rest. Oblivion is also great :) - but it isn't HD that makes it so.

I'm loving my 360 guys, I just fail to see why all the fuss now. It is mainly on pc forums that people are going gaga over the 360. On the console sites I visit people are very happy with their 360, and having great fun online, but just view it as another console.
 
People seem to be reading a lot more into my comment than I meant. It wasn't really that derogatory, it was just a comment on these boards and the 360 as a whole. It's won a big fanbase of PC gamers over because the console is quite PC-like in terms of what it offers, compared to the other consoles now and in the past. No previous console has offered things like HD (something PCs have had for years, even if it wasn't classed as "HD" ;)), a hard drive, an online gaming service, a trailer/demo/video/patch download service, a background OS complete with media centre functionality and a games list very similar to a PCs (lots of FPSs and racing games, two of the most popular genres on the PC) all in one package. I'm not insulting the console (I think it's a great piece of kit, and coule be excellent with a bigger range of titles), but you can't pretend it's not the most PC-like of all the consoles. The PS3 might be very like it when it does come out, but the previous Sony offerings haven't had anything like that on offer, and Nintendo have stated their disinterest in going down that route repeatedly.

The "funny" statement was just in reference to how this forum has changed. A year or two ago it was 80% PC gamers with monster fill-my-sig-with-irrelevant-info specs telling us how nothing would ever better the PC for gaming, now it's all Live signatures and PC gaming is apparently dead forever. I just think a bit of perspective is needed. No current system is dead or close, and I very much doubt anyone who says otherwise has gone to any more bother than their own personal view point. If you don't want to play PC games any more, then don't, but don't presume that there's no future in PC gaming for everyone else, or those of us that don't spend thousands of pounds on a PC every year and are still happy playing Oblivion at low-res and deail. ;)
 
Back
Top Bottom