• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

  • Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

Help Required!

Associate
Joined
14 Mar 2010
Posts
28
Hello all,

Just registered to these forums to ask a small graphics card question. I'm purchasing a new PC soon (I'll build it myself) but basically I'm stuck between which graphics card to get. It's either 1GB Nvidia Geforce GTX285 or the 2GB ATI Radeon HD 5970. I know it sounds like a stupid question, as one's clearly powerful than the other but I'm also keen on trying out the Nvidia Geforce 3d Vision as I've got the monitor etc so I don't know what to do. I've been told to wait for the Nvidia Firmi cards being released end of this month? Will they be 2GB cards like the HD 5970? If so then I'll definitely wait for them!

Thanks for reading if you did, and I'll be grateful for all replies regarding the topic :) (Apologies if posted in the wrong section)
 
The Fermi cards are going to be 1.5GB and 3GB (i think, havent looked very hard at them) so i guess wait for them. ATi is bringing some sort of 3D to the table in summer so you could have the 5970 now and then use it with ATi 3D technology later. but research it yourself because i probably dont know what im talking about... :/
 
Hi, welcome to the OCUK forums :D

I would wait, even if Fermi turns out to be a bit poo - it should finally introduce some competition and perhaps bring back AMD 5800 prices to what they were at launch. For the sake of waiting a few weeks, I think it makes sense (Fermi release on March 26th).

You seem to mention video RAM, but bear in mind that this isn't as it appears. The 5970 does have 2GB in total, but this is shared over 2 GPUs - so it really only has 1GB (like the 5850/5870/gtx 285). However, unless you are playing at massive resolutions, or using modded textures 1GB video memory should be plenty for modern gaming.

What is the planned spec of the rest of your machine and your budget? We should be able to help you on that front too. Is the machine going to be mainly for gaming, or will it need to perform well in other areas too?
 
Thanks for your replies all, and I'll definitely wait for the fermi now.

Hi, welcome to the OCUK forums :D

I would wait, even if Fermi turns out to be a bit poo - it should finally introduce some competition and perhaps bring back AMD 5800 prices to what they were at launch. For the sake of waiting a few weeks, I think it makes sense (Fermi release on March 26th).

You seem to mention video RAM, but bear in mind that this isn't as it appears. The 5970 does have 2GB in total, but this is shared over 2 GPUs - so it really only has 1GB (like the 5850/5870/gtx 285). However, unless you are playing at massive resolutions, or using modded textures 1GB video memory should be plenty for modern gaming.

What is the planned spec of the rest of your machine and your budget? We should be able to help you on that front too. Is the machine going to be mainly for gaming, or will it need to perform well in other areas too?

I don't really know much about the video ram, but I'm looking to buy the best graphics card so it'll last me a good few years without any problems. My budget is anything upto about £3k but I'm only looking to spend about £1,500 because I've noticed most machines that cost beyond £2k are extreme watercooled machines which I would not be able to manage and I'll be able to get the following for £1,500 which I think will be pretty good for me:

Intel i7 920
12GB Corsair DDR3 Ram
Gigabyte GA-EX58-UD3R: DDR3 or the Asus P6X58D (I don't think I'll need the Asus as I don't plan on using more than one graphics card etc)
Graphics card as mentioned above
Asus Xonar Sound Card
160GB Intel SSD x2 (Also have a 1TB normal hard drive alongside a 1TB external hard drive at home)

Those are the main specs I guess, with discount etc I'll get it for around £1500. Will also be purchasing other things too alongside it e.g. a case, 5.1 logitech speakers, 3d glasses etc. The purposes of the machine will most likely only be gaming (Quake Live) which I can run already at 125FPS in my native res for my 22" 120hz samsung monitor but I would also like to use it for video editing, music, movies, other new games and so on. Unfortunately I'm one of those people that will buy something that they might even make full use of, e.g. the 12GB Ram. The current PC I've had, is now 7 years old therefore I will be hoping to make this new one I make last the same time too (without upgrading it). I hope that helps! :)
 
Last edited:
Holy- That's a big bugdet for a pc! Well the best single core card is the 5870 at the moment. The 5970 is good but not many games like crossfire, but newer games are more compatible. You only need to worry about memory if you plan to play in large resolutions. With your 22" 1gb is enough. Also AMD does plan to release 3D support soon, so it doesn't matter which company you go for. But I would wait for Fermi as they might be better to get, or if not, it should at least cause the 5000 series to drop in price, even if it's a little.
 
Ah, sounds good. I agree with your assessment that an X58/i7 will give you the best performance and a long lifetime.

If you haven't already, I would suggest looking at how to overclock an i7 CPU. The i7 920 2.66GHz CPU almost always overclocks happily to 4GHz with good air cooling. If you don't want to do it yourself OCUK offer pre-overclocked bundles (on that one I would suggest paying the extra for the Corsair H50 cooler.

As for 12GB of system RAM, I would not suggest getting it for your uses. 6GB is plenty, and if you populate all 6 RAM slots you put a lot more strain on the integrated memory controller (which is on the CPU) which restricts CPU and RAM overclocking.

For the system disk, the Intel X-25M 160GB you chose is a fantastic bit of kit, but I wouldn't suggest putting it in RAID as you will lose TRIM (at least at the minute) and 1 drive should be more than fast enough. Make sure you get a storage drive like this so you can put things on that don't need SSD speeds.

Asus Xonar sound cards are great, I have used both the D1 and D2X and they have both been fantastic.

Make sure you get a good quality PSU, it is the most important component in the system. I would suggest something like this.

Also, Windows 7 64 bit will be required.

Finally, if you have the money to spend I cannot emphasise enough how nice it is to have a non-TN monitor. These are often not the best for games, but for every other use you state an IPS (or even S-PVA) panel monitor will make everything look so much better. Here is an explanation of LCD panel technologies.
 
Thanks again for your replies.

That sounds like a good idea actually Orcvader, I'm assuming the prices would drop and even if it's just a slight decrease, it's still a bonus in the end. A friend of mine suggested me to have a look at a website called Tomshardware (I don't really know much about computer websites) which had charts of best graphics cards etc. I noticed the 2GB 5970 by ATI was performing better than all the other graphics cards (http://www.tomshardware.co.uk/charts/graphics-cards,1.html) in the tests I had a look at (not seen all). Therefore thought this was the best one. Also could you explain what you mean by "not many games like crossfire". Do you mean using two graphics cards?

Cmndr_andi, I'll reduce the SSD drives to one then and the 1TB harddrive I have at home is the one you linked me too so that should be ok I hope. Everyone's told me to stick with 6GB Ram, but I genuinely don't think I'll overclock anything. I've never done any sort of overclocking in my life so doubt I'll risk to try it. However, I will check the overclocked bundles and see what it's like. Would you recommend overclocked bundles mate? Initially I was looking at getting a 1100W PSU but then was told a 750W will be fine (which is what you've linked me again hehe :D).

Any views on the 3d vision at all? Will I be able to watch 3d movies too or is the 3d vision just designed for games?

Thanks again!
 
Aye, the 5970 comes out very well in the benchmarks because it is actually two 5870 graphics chips sandwiched together in one card. This means it runs an internal crossfire. Therefore, for most games it runs very fast, but for others which are not optimised for crossfire then it doesn't do so well.

As for the overclocked bundles, I would certainly recommend them. They are set up by OCUK, stress tested and sent out. Then after you have installed it they can give you help if you have any troubles. Considering you get a 50% clockspeed boost for a small price premium, I think they are a great deal.

Yea, you won't need a 1100W PSU, 750W is plenty and will give you headroom for future upgrades. Have a look at this PSU calculator and see how much power you system will draw, I bet you will be surprised.

I don't have 3D vision and haven't tried it - so I can't offer any first hand experience of it. But from what I hear it is very good and makes games very immersive.

As for watching movies in 3D, I hear that both AMD and Nvidia will have their own implementations of 3D Blu Ray. I imagine that existing nvidia 3D vision kit would work fine with Nvidia's implementation, as it should all be the same tech.

However, my problem with the 3D technology is that it requires a 120HZ monitor. So far all of the PC monitors of this spec have been relatively small (22-23.6") and only use TN panels. Perhaps when some nice big IPS 120HZ monitors come out I will get excited about the technology.
 
Aye, the 5970 comes out very well in the benchmarks because it is actually two 5870 graphics chips sandwiched together in one card. This means it runs an internal crossfire. Therefore, for most games it runs very fast, but for others which are not optimised for crossfire then it doesn't do so well.

As for the overclocked bundles, I would certainly recommend them. They are set up by OCUK, stress tested and sent out. Then after you have installed it they can give you help if you have any troubles. Considering you get a 50% clockspeed boost for a small price premium, I think they are a great deal.

Yea, you won't need a 1100W PSU, 750W is plenty and will give you headroom for future upgrades. Have a look at this PSU calculator and see how much power you system will draw, I bet you will be surprised.

I don't have 3D vision and haven't tried it - so I can't offer any first hand experience of it. But from what I hear it is very good and makes games very immersive.

As for watching movies in 3D, I hear that both AMD and Nvidia will have their own implementations of 3D Blu Ray. I imagine that existing nvidia 3D vision kit would work fine with Nvidia's implementation, as it should all be the same tech.

However, my problem with the 3D technology is that it requires a 120HZ monitor. So far all of the PC monitors of this spec have been relatively small (22-23.6") and only use TN panels. Perhaps when some nice big IPS 120HZ monitors come out I will get excited about the technology.

That's quite interesting actually. I didn't know the 5970 was basically two 5870's. I've been reading a few reviews recently and I've noticed a lot of people have had problems with ATI drivers therefore will definitely wait for the new nvidia cards to be released end of this month. Also been informed that the two nvidia cards being released will most likely be the 1.5GB one and and another so I'll most likely get the 1.5GB one so I can experiance the 3d vision too.

Would like to say thank you to everyone that posted in this thread as I only have the basic knowledge on computer parts and have not looked into anything since I bought my current machine (5 years ago I think now). I've found these forums very friendly and easy to get help from so thanks again!

Edit: A quick question, are all the graphics cards that have higher video ram than 1GB two graphics cards combined?
 
Edit: A quick question, are all the graphics cards that have higher video ram than 1GB two graphics cards combined?

Not all. Here is the list of dual cards that are on the market at the moment and their video RAM is shared:

- 9800GX2 (old card, but you may see it at some places, effectively two GTS 250s sandwiched together and downclocked)
- GTX 295 (effectively two GTX 275s sandwiched together and downclocked)
- 4870X2 (EOL now, but you may see some around - 2 4870s sandwiched together, as you would guess)
-4850X2 (see above, but with 2 4850s)
- 5970 (two 5870s sandwiched together and downclocked to 5850 speeds)

If you see a card which isn't one of these and has 1GB+ of video RAM, then it is a proper single-GPU card (likely a special edition with more VRAM - like this one and this one). But please bear in mind that if you have a 22in 1680x1050 samsung monitor - Video RAM greater than 1GB will simply not be utilised in modern games. Also, to use much more video RAM, these cards (like that gigabyte) clock the RAM slower than usual - this means that in a game that doesn't use more that 1GB video RAM, a standard card would be faster than the special edition extra VRAM edition.
 
Last edited:
Not all, I think some board partners produce 'extreme' versions with more RAM, like this 285gtx:
http://www.overclockers.co.uk/showproduct.php?prodid=GX-121-GW&groupid=701&catid=56&subcat=1341
Mainly though, yes. It's pretty easy to tell though, the only current dual GPU cards are the 295gtx and 5970.

Also, the driver talk is pretty exagerated these days. nVidia have been having a terrible run of driver releases recently, they've even had to pull their latest version (196.75) because of fan control problems. At the same time ATi's drivers have been getting consistently better. It definitely shouldn't sway your purchasing decision.

Personally I'd wait for Fermi - not for that card because it's going to disappoint - but to see what ATi release in response. Maybe a 5890?

And IMO buying the absolute best graphics card and then not upgrading for 3 years is a waste of money. Spend half now, half later (18-24 months) and you'll be able to run everything and end up with a much better system. Likewise 12GB of RAM is totally unnecessary, but I guess you knew that already.
 
Last edited:
Thanks again for the posts guys.

If that's the case Andi, I doubt I'll purchase a graphics card with 2GB video ram. Will definitely be less than that (1GB/1.5GB) but I doubt I'll even make full use of that so now I'm going to research a bit more on graphics cards. I'm assuming higher video cards such as 3gb are designed for larger monitors?

I'll definitely be purchasing an Nvidia card as I don't think I'll be able to wait till the summer to try the ATI 3d vision out (that's if it's released in the summer). I've always had Nvidia, but I will wait till the end of the month to see what happens. Thanks again guys and I will post if I have more questions :)
 
Back
Top Bottom