High wattage fan controllers - recommendations/owner experiences?

Soldato
Joined
13 Mar 2006
Posts
6,712
Hi - looking to control an 18w ddc pump and up to 9 fans (daisy-chained, ~1-1.5W each) on a high wattage fan controller, ideally automated and software independent.

From what I can see, my best options are:

1) Aquacomputer Aquaero 4.0 USB with powerbooster.

2) Koolance TMS 200

3) T-balancer BigNG

4) T-balancer miniNG

5) manual fan controller - Lamptron FC5 or FC6

Budget isn't really a problem, but would rather not pay silly amounts of money if I don't have to.

Does anyone own any of these or have any experience using them? Would love to know about things like crappy software, bugs, rubbish LCDs etc before I buy one!
 
Im worried about the pump here. How do you want the system to react to temperatures?

Fans keeping water temp within a certain range is fairly simple. However deciding whether a temp increase is best dealt with by spinning up fans or the pump is less obvious.

May i suggest isolating the two? Connect the pump to a flow meter and the fans to a normal controller. Its hard to see how water temp could usefully relate to pump rpm. Have i got the wrong end of the stick here?

There's an alternative for the fans. I couldnt find a controller i liked, parts of the controller getting hotter as fans slow down bother me. Instead, im switching voltage between the readily available 0, 7 and 12v. Quite literally with a toggle switch, so its os independent and can handle high wattage fans. Automating it is probably more hassle than its worth though.
 
Simple. The best and perhaps simplest fan controller is the sunbeam rheobus. It has 20w per channel iirc so is perfect for daisy chaining fans. I don't know about controlling a DDC as I'm not sure it's possible like that. The rheobus is very basic looking but is the most powerfull/cheap controller around and most of all, it's reliable because it is simple.

I have an aquaero atm and although it is very good, it's a little too complex for it's own good. I'm still getting to grips with a lot of the options as I don't use half the things it is capable of (perhaps because the accessories are so bloody expensive!).
 
Im worried about the pump here. How do you want the system to react to temperatures?

Was thinking of having it respond to water temp - the cpu temp is going to be erratic whenever an application puts stress on it so I'd rather not have the pump slowing and spinning as erratically, whereas the water temp is going to be much slower, especially as my loop holds just shy of 2 litres and has 25kg of copper to soak up sudden increases in heat production. Doing it by water temps is going to make it a lot smoother and avoid the juddering you get when the pump suddenly ramps up.

Fans keeping water temp within a certain range is fairly simple. However deciding whether a temp increase is best dealt with by spinning up fans or the pump is less obvious.

I was planning on setting the controller to only power up the fans at very high water temps, and to undervolt the pump at low water temps.

Tbh I don't really know how much I could undervolt the pump and how sensitive my set-up is to flowrate, but the cpu idles at around 30-35C running the ddc at 10w , and the loop doesn't have a sealing top plug atm so flowrate is probably very low atm. :o

I have the silence bug - the fans would be off almost all the time I expect. Still unsure whether to even bother with some - cpu doesn't get above about 55c when gaming.

May i suggest isolating the two? Connect the pump to a flow meter and the fans to a normal controller. Its hard to see how water temp could usefully relate to pump rpm. Have i got the wrong end of the stick here?

There's an alternative for the fans. I couldnt find a controller i liked, parts of the controller getting hotter as fans slow down bother me. Instead, im switching voltage between the readily available 0, 7 and 12v. Quite literally with a toggle switch, so its os independent and can handle high wattage fans. Automating it is probably more hassle than its worth though.[/QUOTE]

Yeah, does sound like a bit of hassle, but hopefully will just be a case of setting it up and leaving it. The absence of fans makes me notice the pump noise now, even with the 10w ddc I'm using atm, and it'd be nice to have it undervolt when just using the web etc. I don't want the bother of having to flick a switch or turn a knob all the time.

Hmmm, wondering whether I could just use the mcubed miniNG. Says it's only rated to 25w total (2 channel - 1st channel up to 20w and total load 25w) seems to have a bigger heatsink on it than the aquaero. It's totally manual - you adjust two rheostats; one for lower temp and one for high temp and it scales the voltage linearly between them I think - but then it looks like it'd be unable to do the fans and pump separately.
 
If the cpu block is more sensitive to flow rate than the radiator, then:

Minimising flow rate maximises the cpu-water delta. Cooler water (say the machine's been off for a few hours) lowers pump rpm to its minimum, which decreases rate of heat flow through the cpu block. Cpu runs hotter, but dumps the same wattage into the loop as it would under high flow conditions. Water temp creeps up, so the pump gradually increases rpm until equilibrium is found. This control being independent of cpu temp looks dangerous to me.

I may be worrying about nothing here, as processors dont really mind being hot.
 
Back
Top Bottom