Hoya uvc filters for all my lenses? (protection)

Caporegime
Joined
13 Jan 2010
Posts
33,192
Location
Llaneirwg
Should I get these for protection?
I just received one for my sigma as it's hood isn't like that of my macro and Tele.

I'm particularly thinking about my macro as it doesn't take much to bump something by accident
 
Last edited:
Should I get these for protection?
I just received one for my sigma as it's hood isn't like that of my macro and Tele.

I'm particularly thinking about my macro as it doesn't take much to bump something by accident

Cue debate. There is no correct answer, it's entirely up to you, your usage and your evaluation of risk and benefit.

I used to use them but don't any more. Front elements are very durable and even visible scratches will be virtually invisible in photos.
 
Yeah I've read about it.
I see no benefit despite potential for protection

Is more of there is any real drawback
 
Yeah I've read about it.
I see no benefit despite potential for protection

Is more of there is any real drawback

Putting anything that wasn't part of the design in front of a lens is going to have some performance impact. A filter is not a correctional optic, so you'll lose some light transmission and perhaps contrast, and probably gain some flare. Whether it's noticeable or not is up for debate, but personally I prefer just to not bother now.
 
And you havent had any issues where it would have saved a lens?
I'm generally really good with not being clumsy with electronics. It's my macro lens when I have no hood. But any optical issues will really irritate me!
 
I had filters for my first few lenses but after a while I decided that buying a good filter as some kind of sacrificial layer was a bit of a waste of time.

To minimise any image quality hit you need to buy the best filters available so it adds to the expense of the lens (especially with big elements). I've just decided to do without and deal with it if I miraculously happen to drop a lens onto something pointy enough to hit the front element.

Use the hood luke!
 
And you havent had any issues where it would have saved a lens?
I'm generally really good with not being clumsy with electronics. It's my macro lens when I have no hood. But any optical issues will really irritate me!

Never. I dropped my 40D once but the lens hood saved the day. Mrk of this very forum had a filter smash and scratch the lens, which rather made me think twice about using them.

Radical idea- buy a hood for the Macro? Costs the same as a decent filter, protects just as well, and will enhance image quality rather than degrade it.
 
I have tested some Hoya Pro1 UV filters on my lenses and there was a distinct gain in contrast and detail with the filter off the lens.

I will only put them on now if I'm going to the beach or something like that.
 
Hood saved my 200-400 when it decided to make a bid for suicide and jumped from my tripod! Can't get front filters for it anyway so it wouldn't have mattered :P
 
I have filters for all my lens, Whether i use them will depend on the conditions though more than me trying to avoid accidents by using them. Wet n windy conditions, beach etc. and the filter stays on, Canon L glass needs a filter on to complete the weather sealing if it's a feature of the lens. 'Normal' conditions and usually no filter and let the lens hood does the protection.
 
OK guys from sounds of it just use them if the situation arises rather than permanent.
Ie the beach

I always use my hood on my Tele and almost always on my macro
 
Back
Top Bottom