HTC G1 - ended up getting one.

Soldato
Joined
31 Mar 2006
Posts
6,606
Location
Sydney Australia
Well after holding out for ages and swearing that I wouldn't do it, I gave in and got one. Got a great deal on it too - free phone, £20/month including unlimited internet and then due to having contacts that is cut in half to £10 per month.

My first impressions are pretty good - the web browsing is close to the iphone once you get away from the multi touch and the functionality is something that I have yet to explore further but thus far the touch screen response has left me impressed as has the Android operating system.

Anyone else got one? It seems pretty quiet in here regarding the phone.
 
Android has great potential, but i think T-Mobile/HTC missed the boat with this one which is a shame. T-Mobile are forcing (most) people to pay too much in an iPhone like strategy. HTC manufactured a horrid looking phone (why when they can make the Pro/Touch/HD etc...?). It almost certainly will be a hit eventually but i'm not feeling it right now. G2 should be something awesome especially if the community takes of around Android (which i probably will).
 
I'll whip up some form of review tonight I think when I have some time with a camera. The hardware is somewhat less horrible to use than it is to look at - I'd be the first to admit that it is sod ugly - but it works.

So far my bugbears are:

- My alarm doesn't work, well it works but it refuses to make any noise. On the plus side with one of the zillions of apps in the market I was able to edit an MP3, resave it, and then not listen to it on my alarm. Brilliant!!! Actually the App is awesome, like a stripped down audio editing tool where you slide bars for the start and finish of the music that you want and then save it as an alternative track. Very clever.

- The menus are very convoluted and need to be rethought - I would like to go to the same menu to turn on and off everything 3G, GPS, WiFi and Bluetooth but they have put GPS under the Security & Location menu... kinda makes sense but at the same time - irritating from an accessability standpoint.

- Due to some interesting file management options there is a little quirk that is frustrating at times. When the phone is plugged into your computer it makes the Micro SD onboard into a drive that appears in your drive list. This is cool because you just drag and drop music, pictures and video into the directories and then they get listed on your phone when you unplug it. The problem is that if you are charging the phone on your PC it won't let you access the SD unless you go into the menu system and turn off 'Use SD as Storage'. It seems like a clumsy solution to me.

- As you install apps from the Market the menu screen just gets longer and longer - I would like to be able to create directories like: Games and Apps and then drag and drop the icons into it to make it a bit more tidy.

- Web browsing is a doddle but there are definite signs that Android has been developed by geeks. The forward and backward shortcut keys are Menu + J to go back and Menu + K to go forward. These are remenants of the UNIX VI Editor (VI=Visual) where J and K were used to go forward and backward along your lines of code. Not at all intuative.

Lastly - having come from using an iPod touch for the last 6 months or so and enjoying the intuative interface and uncluttered approach to doing things Android needs some polish. It has a learning curve - not a killer one by any means but it certainly has one.

My first days thoughts were that I could sell it on the bay, hope to get close to £500 for it, and get an HTC Touch HD but you know I might just stick with it for now. There are things in the Market (apps store) that are really making me realise how impressive this thing can really be.
 
- Web browsing is a doddle but there are definite signs that Android has been developed by geeks. The forward and backward shortcut keys are Menu + J to go back and Menu + K to go forward. These are remenants of the UNIX VI Editor (VI=Visual) where J and K were used to go forward and backward along your lines of code. Not at all intuative.

J/K aren't remnants of VI, they are the same shortcuts used in Gmail.
 
J/K aren't remnants of VI, they are the same shortcuts used in Gmail.

Sorry where in Gmail? I used to work in UNIX specifically with SUN Solaris so the origin of J & K are from VI - it's been around significantly longer - if they are in GMail then they are there for the same reason. I have no idea where or why you would use J and K to go forward and backward in Gmail when the web browser has buttons...

Maybe you're thinking of Google reader - I've just tested it in there and it works... curious.
 
Last edited:
Sorry where in Gmail? I used to work in UNIX specifically with SUN Solaris so the origin of J & K are from VI - it's been around significantly longer - if they are in GMail then they are there for the same reason. I have no idea where or why you would use J and K to go forward and backward in Gmail when the web browser has buttons...

Maybe you're thinking of Google reader - I've just tested it in there and it works... curious.

Gmail has a LOT of keyboard shortcuts - j/k move conversation, n/p next previous message. Google generally uses similar shortcuts across their different apps to keep them consistent.

I don't doubt the origins of J/K are Vi, but they have been used much more recently in other Google apps, which was my point.
 
Gmail has a LOT of keyboard shortcuts - j/k move conversation, n/p next previous message. Google generally uses similar shortcuts across their different apps to keep them consistent.

I don't doubt the origins of J/K are Vi, but they have been used much more recently in other Google apps, which was my point.

Fair enough - it's just the first time I've come across it and coming from a Solaris background I found it a little amusing. Cheers for the heads up - I use the Google Reader every day - most excellent tool - nice to learn new things - cheers.
 
Fair enough - it's just the first time I've come across it and coming from a Solaris background I found it a little amusing. Cheers for the heads up - I use the Google Reader every day - most excellent tool - nice to learn new things - cheers.

I'm a big Google Reader fan as well (although hopefully my boss doesn't know that!). Hope you enjoy the G1 - thanks for the review.. still debating whether to get the G1 or the HTC Touch HD...
 
I'm a big Google Reader fan as well (although hopefully my boss doesn't know that!). Hope you enjoy the G1 - thanks for the review.. still debating whether to get the G1 or the HTC Touch HD...

heh that's not the review - I'll do a full one with photos when I get home tonight hopefully.
 
Try this on your G1 -

Ignore what's on the screen and press enter, then type "reboot" then press enter again. :)
 
I went and bought one on a whim, got it unlocked but I'll probably end up putting it on the bay - I'm missing the JesusPhone already!

Give it time - it's early days and the OS holds some serious potential. I'm currently writing up a review and it would be nice if what I write could be confirmed or denied by someone who hasn't just looked at pictures or read what other people have said.
 
Back
Top Bottom