If You Had...
- Thread starter Tute
- Start date
Tempted but I get the impression it's on another level in running costs to the cars above, as well as the fact that I specifically want to scratch my hot hatch itch.
Come on Matt82, which hot hatch would you, personally have?
2006 cars are miles under budget
http://classifieds.pistonheads.com/classifieds?Category=used-cars&M=635&YearFrom=2006&YearTo=2006
2007 cars include edition 30 cars, which remap to nigh on 300bhp
http://classifieds.pistonheads.com/classifieds?Category=used-cars&M=635&YearFrom=2006&YearTo=2006
2007 cars include edition 30 cars, which remap to nigh on 300bhp
http://classifieds.pistonheads.com/...lack-red-leather-fully-loaded-top-spec/882312
How about a 69k mile M3 with about £2k in his back pocket to fix anything (or use it to buy a BMW fully comprehensive warranty for the next two years)
Caporegime
- Joined
- 13 May 2003
- Posts
- 34,564
- Location
- Warwickshire
The R32 didn't excite you and you seem to know a lot about STs, in fact your posting seems to have a pro-Ford slant in this thread. I reckon you want one. It wouldn't (presumably) bankrupt you and will still enable you to run a hot hatch whilst saving for a house that you want in the future. You aren't massively concerned with interior quality and want something that is an engaging drive rather than just powahhh.
The answer is the Ford.
The answer is the Ford.
Am I the only one really not seeing the issue with spending 12k-14k on a hot hatch?
Seems like there's a bit of bandwagon jumping in here - fox made an amusing comment about it so lets all agree to be cool. I can see the perspective that some wouldn't want to spend that sort of money on a hatch, but I don't think it's a big issue if that's what he wants. There probably are better cars for the money but they would be older with higher running costs. He's buying at 50% of the original price and they're mostly considered very good cars so not seeing why it's a huge problem. Yes he could spend less on the same car, but that applies to 90% of the people in this thread - I'm sure you could have all spent less on the same car that was just a bit older
The only one I'd avoid is the Mazda 3, which is a shame because its the one I'd most like to own - I say avoid it because of the depreciation. Other than that, none of these are going to be a poor choice technically.
Saying all that, if you've driven them and are struggling to hand over the cash then maybe a hot hatch isn't what you want or you don't want to hand over that much money. If this is the right decision, one of them would have grabbed you and you'd really want to pay 12-14k of your hard earned... The fact you're so unsure makes me think it might be the wrong direction. You seem to have decided you really want a hot hatch, but none of them are actually giving you what you've built up as a mental picture.
If I had that much cash, in your situation I'd buy a similarly powered small saloon for 10k (330i for example) and chuck the remaining 4 into a savings account - that's half a deposit for a house.
Seems like there's a bit of bandwagon jumping in here - fox made an amusing comment about it so lets all agree to be cool. I can see the perspective that some wouldn't want to spend that sort of money on a hatch, but I don't think it's a big issue if that's what he wants. There probably are better cars for the money but they would be older with higher running costs. He's buying at 50% of the original price and they're mostly considered very good cars so not seeing why it's a huge problem. Yes he could spend less on the same car, but that applies to 90% of the people in this thread - I'm sure you could have all spent less on the same car that was just a bit older
The only one I'd avoid is the Mazda 3, which is a shame because its the one I'd most like to own - I say avoid it because of the depreciation. Other than that, none of these are going to be a poor choice technically.
Saying all that, if you've driven them and are struggling to hand over the cash then maybe a hot hatch isn't what you want or you don't want to hand over that much money. If this is the right decision, one of them would have grabbed you and you'd really want to pay 12-14k of your hard earned... The fact you're so unsure makes me think it might be the wrong direction. You seem to have decided you really want a hot hatch, but none of them are actually giving you what you've built up as a mental picture.
If I had that much cash, in your situation I'd buy a similarly powered small saloon for 10k (330i for example) and chuck the remaining 4 into a savings account - that's half a deposit for a house.
R32 = snorefest
Get something that people either love or hate! Cars with there own personality, basically. A Volkswagen doesn't have one.
Around 12k budget, my list would be:
Focus ST
Clio 200
Astra VXR
Megane 250 (if you be patient or up the budget a little)
New shape Mazda3 MPS (if you can stomach the tax)
Out of the lot i would be aiming for the Megane 250 as they are just epic when it comes to a turbo'ed Hot Hatch.
Get something that people either love or hate! Cars with there own personality, basically. A Volkswagen doesn't have one.
Around 12k budget, my list would be:
Focus ST
Clio 200
Astra VXR
Megane 250 (if you be patient or up the budget a little)
New shape Mazda3 MPS (if you can stomach the tax)
Out of the lot i would be aiming for the Megane 250 as they are just epic when it comes to a turbo'ed Hot Hatch.
![[TW]Fox](/data/man-of-honor/2009.png){kind=avatar}
What? I wouldnt buy one myself but its hardly a snorefest, is it? Certainly not in ways that wouldnt equally apply to the Astra, which would be the worst place to put £12k in the entire universe.
Caporegime
- Joined
- 8 Jan 2004
- Posts
- 32,890
- Location
- Rutland
Probably because they're heavy and don't handle fantastically well. Plus the delivery of a smaller turbo engine suits the hot hatch better.
I see.
So the Astra handles fantastically well?
And a Civic Type R has an engine unsuited to a hot hatch (No turbo)?
Caporegime
- Joined
- 18 Oct 2002
- Posts
- 37,804
- Location
- block 16, cell 12
Lancia Delta?
Caporegime
- Joined
- 8 Jan 2004
- Posts
- 32,890
- Location
- Rutland
[TW]Fox;23462596 said:
No but each has redeeming features, the R32 is meant to be pretty dull apart from the sound and has little scope for tuning, I haven't driven one though just the comments on the R32 from reviews.
I don't think he wants a 20 year old car? His shortlist doesnt suggest this.
Last edited: