Calm down, calm down........
D.P., I think that your arguements are clear and lucid and show an application of thought to the matter under discussion. They show an active, intelligent use of the english language.
ElRazur has shown intelligence in asking the question in the first place and shows an interest in other peoples' opinions. (At least until the sniping, anyway)
From my experience, I know a lovely girl with a 2:1. She is bright, keen, pretty and jobless. She fails at every interview as she gets so nervous, but from experience, I know her to be very intelligent. So are the people interviewing her less intelligent as they cannot get past her nervousness?
I also know an Oxford don who has writted books on his subject but is totally incapable of anything practical about the house. Does this make him stupid? His daughter is also an intelligent soul and completely lacking in common sense. What does this make her?
I used to be able to tackle all sorts of problems, think laterally and was known for keeping a cool head in an emergency. But this was before my major mental collapse, leaving me almost incapable of logical thought right now. (It may just be the medication and the fact that it's past my bed time) Does this make me stupid?.............Don't answer that!!