Is David Moyes a good manager?

[Youstolemyname]

I'm just curious on the opinion of folk as to the pedigree of Moyes. With little to no money he has kep Everton plodding along but winning precisely nothing along the way.

If he had the unlimited money cheat mode active like Chelsea and City do you think he has the tactical nous to cut it at the top level and manage the big egos that go along with it? Or is he a 4-5-1 hoof merchant who isn't used to managing huge talents who have won titles/cups.

I'm not convinced by him myself; despite Everton plodding along they have never been a joy to watch under his stewardship. He's a Scottish Sam Allardyce in my opinion.

But what next for the ginger prince? He's stalling on a new deal at Everton. Does he have his sights on a big club in the summer and could he cut it at the top?

OcUK, it's over to you

 

[Youstolemyname]

You don't need to manage a top club and win trophies to be a good manager.

Surely the purpose of a football club is to win trophies? If you don't win trophies then you aren't a good manager, in my opinion.

And I am sure Moyes has had plenty of offers to manager other clubs but lacks the guts to take on the task. His Everton job is a cushy, pressure free number and he knows it.

 

[Youstolemyname]

Such as?

I don't think he's had any offers from anyone above where Everton currently sit, do you? Why would he take a job at a lower placed club? I can't think of a single club other than Villa when Oneil left, but that was hardly a step up. There was mild speculation spurs would come in for him when harry got the boot but they quickly got AVB.

I can't think of any club that has actually come in for him.

I reckon there have been plenty of offers that haven't made it to the press.

 

[Youstolemyname]

When the Arsenal job comes up in the summer I still don't think he will have the bottle to take it