Is it just me or is finding a comfy chair impossible?

Soldato
Joined
20 May 2011
Posts
6,027
Location
Aberdeen, Scotland
Over the past few years I've tried a number of chairs, including some so called championed ergonomic chairs, and I just never truly get on with any of them!

I'm not the tallest guy at 165cm, but that usually means I have no issues fitting into the most common types of chairs, so that's not really the issue, it's just that chairs which attempt to shove my lumbar too much where it is noticeable end up agitating my lower back after some time. I lift heavy weights a few times a week, so it's not like it is an issue with my muscles or posture either - maybe I just have a weirdly straight lumbar which is easily bothered by these kinds of chairs?

For the past couple of years I was using a Steelcase Gesture, but I noticed over time I wouldn't really ever sit properly on it because whenever I did lean back into it (or recline for long periods of time), the lumbar support just killed my lower back and I never did get used to that, and I certainly gave it enough time. I also really missed having some way of properly reclining while resting my head, and Steelcase's headrests are all complete crap.

Before that, I spent 3 years on a DXRacer. Was it comfortable? Sure, but after 3 years I started getting lower back pain because, as it turns out, these chairs with flat backs don't properly support your lower back (creating gaps) that lumbar cushions just do not properly fix (and again, would dig into my back if I raised it up too much).

The chairs I've actually never had any issues with comfort on even for extended periods of seating are... the cheap crappy executive style ones, ironically enough. They don't last too long, but they never caused me issues either (granted, I was younger then and late teens, but I'm still young at 27!). My favourite one was some microfibre chair that I had no idea of the name any more, I just remember stealing it from @mrk when I saw it in some of his old pictures :D. It didn't have the highest back, but was good enough for resting my head on with my height regardless.

Currently, I'm a few days into an IKEA MARKUS, and once again, while it seems I'm perfectly built for everything else the chair offers (seat is good, armrests are a perfect height, I am in love with having a high backed chair I can lean fully into again and just recline far back without feeling like my head wants to fall off eventually), that damn lumbar foam is causing me discomfort because it's just too intense... and it's just a bit of god-damned foam.

So... am I the only one finding out that apparently what I actually like is a nice plush chair with good padding for support and I just drank the ergo chair kool-aid?
 
I probably spend 70+ hours a week sitting at the computer. The Markus I had was better than the generic office chairs I'd had before but still gave me back problems. Since I replaced it with a (secondhand) Humanscale Freedom Hi Back about 12 months ago I haven't had anyway near the same problems.
 
Get a kneeling chair off eBay for £80 or get a Herman miller from John Lewis for £1200.

Choice is yours

Sounds like you didn't really read the OP, because I mentioned the overly ergonomic chairs like HM still cause me discomfort, even when adjusted. It's obviously a very subjective thing.
 
Sounds like you didn't really read the OP, because I mentioned the overly ergonomic chairs like HM still cause me discomfort, even when adjusted. It's obviously a very subjective thing.

Well the Markus is causing you issues and it's a standard chair. You will need the right ergonomic chair with a proper assessment by a professional.

Try a kneeling chair it's where you have zero back. Or try a yoga ball.

Will take 3-4 weeks to adjust to it but after that plain sailing.
 
Best chair I've ever owned is a cloth (I don't like leather chairs) AK racing one I've had for about 6 years now, which I bought for around £150. No wear on it either.

Good lumbar support is hard to find on a desk chair though. When you look at actual racing seats they are a more supportive shape.
 
Last edited:
I lift heavy weights a few times a week, so it's not like it is an issue with my muscles or posture either
Actually, it could be.
I used to lift weights around your age and had similar discomforts from 'standard' chairs. Turns out part of the problem was indeed poor form when lifting, but being young I never noticed it or suffered any issues.... fast forward a couple of decades and the problems have now come to light.

Worth getting checked out by a specialist, and I mean a proper musculo-skeletal type doctor not just 'Todd down the gym' who spots for you or something.
 
I'm going full executive chesterfield for my next office chair. If that's what company CEOs sit on, then they must be comfortable.
 
Well the Markus is causing you issues and it's a standard chair. You will need the right ergonomic chair with a proper assessment by a professional.

Try a kneeling chair it's where you have zero back. Or try a yoga ball.

Will take 3-4 weeks to adjust to it but after that plain sailing.

Causing my issues mainly because of the lumbar area. Rest of the chair is fine. Since IKEA has a generous return policy I may try just removing the foam insert for that before giving up if I can't adjust to it. The mesh should still give some support I hope.

Best chair I've ever owned is a cloth (I don't like leather chairs) AK racing one I've had for about 6 years now, which I bought for around £150. No wear on it either.

Good lumbar support is hard to find on a desk chair though. When you look at actual racing seats they are a more supportive shape.

Well, racing seats are designed in a way to stop you flying off the thing with high g forces when doing quick turns and the like, not really something you'd care about in an office chair! Can't imagine they're rated for more than a few hours usage either.

Actually, it could be.
I used to lift weights around your age and had similar discomforts from 'standard' chairs. Turns out part of the problem was indeed poor form when lifting, but being young I never noticed it or suffered any issues.... fast forward a couple of decades and the problems have now come to light.

Worth getting checked out by a specialist, and I mean a proper musculo-skeletal type doctor not just 'Todd down the gym' who spots for you or something.

That's fair, although I did pay proper attention to form when starting out and using next to no weight before I started adding it on once I was happy with my lifting form, I just didn't clarify that in the OP.

I'm going full executive chesterfield for my next office chair. If that's what company CEOs sit on, then they must be comfortable.

Did a quick google and they seem fairly cheap? Seems like it'd suffer from the standard PU leather problem of just disintegrating after a year or two.
 
Have you tried a standing desk? Great for back pain and you'll live longer too according to the research.

Another option is to consider your posture and fix any imbalances that you may have.

Haven't tried a standing desk, although I have an area suitable that I do use with a laptop sometimes, I also often get up and walk around instead of staying seated for long periods of time.
 
Did a quick google and they seem fairly cheap? Seems like it'd suffer from the standard PU leather problem of just disintegrating after a year or two.
Like most things, there seem to be cheap imitations which I'm sure aren't as good.

The decent ones seem to be £600+.

Now that I'm permanently working from home, I can justify that kind of expense for a comfy seat a lot easier.
 
Like most things, there seem to be cheap imitations which I'm sure aren't as good.

The decent ones seem to be £600+.

Now that I'm permanently working from home, I can justify that kind of expense for a comfy seat a lot easier.

Fair. Personally I'm after something with a nice high back/headrest that is supportive when leaning back and lounging in. This seems particularly difficult to find in office chairs. Far easier in gimmicky gamer chairs which don't have ergonomic support, lol...
 
You also have to bear in mind that sitting in an Ergo chair, or any with proper support will ache for the initial usage whilst your body adjusts to be supported in the correct areas. so whilst they may feel uncomfortable in the short term, long term they are doing you good.
 
That's fair, although I did pay proper attention to form when starting out and using next to no weight before I started adding it on once I was happy with my lifting form, I just didn't clarify that in the OP.
Still worth getting that extra pair of eyes, for peace of mind if nothing else. The doc may even be able to pin it down to something else that you might never have considered.
 
I love comfy soft office chairs, but tricky to find one that fits unless you live near a seat superstore.

10 years ago i had the most comfy chair, it was a herman miller, but it was super soft and comfy, had really thick cushions. I chucked it when I moved thinking I would find another. Now they just sell the wire ones and I miss that chair. I sometimes browse ebay looking for it. it's gone forever.
 
I love comfy soft office chairs, but tricky to find one that fits unless you live near a seat superstore.

10 years ago i had the most comfy chair, it was a herman miller, but it was super soft and comfy, had really thick cushions. I chucked it when I moved thinking I would find another. Now they just sell the wire ones and I miss that chair. I sometimes browse ebay looking for it. it's gone forever.

I kinda feel that way when I see all the past raving of the Kashmir chair. I would've probably loved it, but it's gone now too.
 
Back
Top Bottom