• Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

Is it worth upgrading?

Associate
Joined
21 Jun 2011
Posts
1,448
Hello,

current system:

Core 2 Quad Q6600
HIS Radeon HD 5850
4 Gig DDR2
64Gb SSD main drive, various hard drives for data (most big stuff stored on NAS)
Decent brand (can't recall offhand) modular 750w PSU
Antec Centurion C5 case
all-in-one CPU cooler (the single-fan, single-rad Kuhler... 620 I think?) - chosen for silence and 'I want that it's cool' rather than for overclocking headroom or anything else.

I have a 1080p monitor. I am unlikely to move to anything bigger in the next few years. I don't have room in my PC room to be farther away from the screen and the current one is absolutely fine. I might (possibly) add a second monitor at some point, but would only be gaming on one (other for web browser/chatting or what have you), so no super-wide-screen-eyefinity shenanigans.

Most things run PRETTY well at the moment. I'm fine coping with Skyrim on not-quite-highest settings, but I wouldn't think I'm getting the best possible play experience I could, and I wouldn't contemplate a high res texture pack for example. I've not tried it in BF3, but I think I was nearing and occasionally exceeding the limits of 'playable' for BFBC2 or stalker:CS unless I turned down bells and whistles. I'm therefore thinking about upgrading to give myself back that comfortable "I can probably play that just fine" feeling when I look at a new title. To that end I'm enlisting forum help to try and work out the weak point(s) in my setup.

Q1: Is it worth upgrading my graphics card given the processor and desired resolution? What kind of upgrade would I have to be looking at to make a realistic difference in terms of playability on high settings for reasonably modern games? (i.e. if we're looking at a minimum £400 card then I won't be buying one, but If something in the £100-£150 range would make a big difference, then I might well be interested).

Q2: Would I be better off buying a new Mobo + CPU + RAM and keeping my HD 5850 for now? (off the top of my head, an i5 and 8Gb DDR3 in a basic motherboard)

Q3: Would I be best of all saving up and upgrading everything together?

Note: Overclocking the current system's not really an option. I've had an intermittent fault with the system for a LONG time - random lockups/freezes. It has persisted through replacing literally every component except the CPU and Mobo, and gets MUCH worse with overclocking. At stock it happens maybe once a month, and I've therefore given up trying to solve it as a time-invested-versus-annoyance thing.

Edit: Bugger, meant to put this in 'General Hardware' - any mods mind moving it please?
 
Last edited:
Sell what you have and update the CPU, motherboard and graphics card if you can't as you say overclock the Q6600 to 3Ghz-3.6Ghz. Would not be worth updating the graphics card if you can't get a good overclock out of a Q6600. You will only find the CPU bottlenecks any faster graphics card.
 
Try the second point you raised, and upgrade to a new cpu / mobo. I actually think your ram may well be quite adequate, but seeing as DDR3 is so cheap, you could consider dropping in 4 or 8gb for little expense. You'd benefit enormously from a new gpu too, though I would sort out the 'foundations' first, and see how the frame rate fairs with a new cpu (it should be a lot better). Please clarify what make your psu is. :)
 
Last edited:
Yeah I would get a new platform (i5 etc) first and save for a your gfx.

I think I only paid about 300 quid for my i5 cpu, motherboard and ddr3 then got a better gfx card when I had the fundage (not a real word I know :p)
 
Fair enough, that gives me something to plan and work towards.

arc@css: I understand not trusting the concept of a 'decent brand' PSU without actually getting a name - It's a Corsair TX750 (went through my OCUK/(other site)/(other other site)/amazon etc etc order histories to find it).
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom