Having a similar argument with my wife. We need a 5 door car as our current cars (fiat 500 and 911 cab) aren't exactly practical for family life. We've had a brilliant experience with the 500 and thought about a 500L... until we drove it. Seriously soul destroying, even my wife didn't like it! We can both agree that the 500X is a much better looking car and with the 1.4 turbo petrol isn't too bad to drive either (lol @ sport mode though). However I feel that for a family hack it's too small and can't take a roof box unless you get the silly off road lookalike. Is the renegade equally small inside? For the £15,500 of a pre registered 500X (would be financed at this price) we could probably stretch to something like a Kia Sportage instead which I've been pleasantly surprised by how good it is. Sadly my wife won't entertain the obvious choice of a Focus or Octavia for some reason.