Kinect, move or wii for exercise?

Associate
Joined
20 Oct 2008
Posts
291
Location
Mission beach, Queesland.
Hello guys,

I'm Wanting to get a bit more active and since all of the above have motion control and exercise/sports games I'm having a hard time deciding which to go for....I guess Im looking for some anecdotal experience people have had with each system.

So, what are peoples experiences?
 
The Wii does give you a work out on games such as Wii Fit, though you have to do it properly, if you try and cheat the system then it is no use to you.
 
Hello guys,

I'm Wanting to get a bit more active and since all of the above have motion control and exercise/sports games I'm having a hard time deciding which to go for....I guess Im looking for some anecdotal experience people have had with each system.

So, what are peoples experiences?

The Kinect is the best out of those, my firend has one and its fun. However maybe try going running outside in the real world, or getting a sporty hobby that doesn't involve staring at a PC screen to exercise? :)
 
Defo the Kinect.

Kinect sports will work up a good sweat!

As for going outside for exercise, lose some weight/get in shapre first, then go out when you look/feel good :)
 
I'm not being funny or anything, and I'm sure the move controllers are great fun but why don't you buy a second hand bike or some proper fitting running trainers or some swim shorts and do that as well as gaming?

You could be doing this as well for all I know.

I'm not trolling just proper exercise is way more beneficial.

By all means buy these products as a new way to play games but as exercise tools I think thats pushing it somewhat :D
 
Another vote for Kinect, it's gameplay style forces physical movement, and the fitness programs seem to really take advantage of things, you can't 'cheat' it by waggling/doing small gestures like you can with the majority of Wii/Move stuff.

Move is more about precision of hand movements, not 'whole body' stuff, so whilst it's still excellent for somethings, physical movement/exercise isn't it's forte..

(I've got Move/Kinect and had a Wii, which is what my opinion is based on)
 
If you want to become more active then a computer game is not the answer. No matter how much you sugar coat a device which requires moving your hand a little more, or having to stand up to play instead of sitting down.
 
So i heard that EA sports active 2 for Wii/move/Kinect is prob the best, better routines heart rate monitors resistive ands etc and it was in supermarkets from between £20-25 rather than the RRP of £70.
http://www.ea.com/ea-sports-active-2
http://uk.ps3.ign.com/articles/113/1139664p1.html
Active 2 is a great, if patience trying, way to get a workout, but the sheer variety of options makes it an attractive choicefor those seeking an alternative to a gym. You can answer surveys to give the program an idea of your basic health, set goals for yourself such as the amount of calories you want to burn in a week, tell the program what weights you want to use in place of the included resistance band, and create custom workouts that target the areas you know are problematic. The Wii version also includes some additional support for the Wii Balance Board, though it isn't required. If you want it to be, Active 2 could be a tool to seriously help change the way you live and organize your life.

Closing Comments
Active 2 on Wii and PS3 functions well and will give anyone who’s willing to put the time in one hell of a workout. It has activities that can make exercising a little more fun, and the way it tracks your diet and general health both locally, and online if you choose to upload your stats to EA’s servers, makes it a unique tool that can help you reshape your life and your body. Occasional sensor issues will frustrate people, but either of these versions are a better pick over the Kinect version.
 
With help from Kinect, Your Shape: Fitness Evolved, EA Sports Active 2, Dance Central and a few others I've lost 30lbs since New Year and feel a lot fitter.

Do the 12 week EASA2 program and stick with it.
 
got all 3, definitely kinect, like someone earlier said, it forces physical movements. I've only got the first game for it Kinect Adventures and it is tiring, it's real cardio exercise you're getting with this game so don't take any notice of the "get some trainers" brigade :)
 
Back
Top Bottom