Kitchen Appliances - Ice Cream Makers

Soldato
Joined
23 Nov 2007
Posts
4,969
Location
Lancashire, UK
The last time I made any sort of ice cream or sorbet I was still living at home, and therefore just swiped my parents' machine - needless to say it was a while ago!

I'd like to get a domestic volume machine for doing both ice creams and sorbets, but I'm only just starting to look around at the various offerings and was wondering if there were any OcUK experiences I could draw upon. Price is very definitely a consideration, but equally I don't want to buy a useless piece of tat.

Any recommendations of models to either select or avoid at all costs?

Cheers.
 
There are basically 2 kinds of ice cream maker (for home) on the market. The difference is whether it has a compressor built in or not, the compressor is basically the part that make your freezer freeze.

1 - the one without.

These are cheaper, generally Round £30. It basically comes at a bowl that has dual wall with a freezing agent inside, you put the bowl in the freezer over night and when you need to make the ice cream you take it out, put it in the bowl. The other part of the machine for is the motor that spins the arm, so what you paid for is basically a plastic bread maker thing with a arm that spins, instead of dough, you are spinning and turning custard into ice cream.

The plus side to these are they are cheap, and they work. Down side is you can make 1 batch and the bowl is done for until refreeze. The motor in some of these are also weak and prone to break.

2 - the second kind are the expensive kind, Gaggia makes he best home one no the market, it fluctuate between £200 to £300 on Amazon. It has a compressor built in so it is heavy and once it is in place, it doesn't like being moved because if you move it, you disturb the coolant inside which means you can't use for 24 hours. Once in place though, if you switch it on at the wall, after 15 mins the bowl in it is cold enough to make ice cream.

The plus side to these are you can make as much as you like, on the moment without planning ahead to put the bowl in the freezer. If you don't have lots of freezer space then option 1 will never work. The down side is costs and you need a worktop space for it to be there almost permanently.

I got the Gaggia, don't buy it to save money, buy it because you want to experiment with flavours, make ice cream of your dreams, you will never make your money back making your own, a tub of double cream will cost you £1' plus flavours ingredients like a bar of 80% cocoa is another £1, plus electricity, plus sugar, eggs and a shot of vodka (cheap) to act as a conductor it actually cost the same if not more to a tub of Ben & Jerry's.

However, there is nothing like fresh ice cream, you can't buy fresh ice cream anywhere.

The other plus is you can make ice cream as healthy as you want, replace full fat cream and milk with half fat, use real ingredients, not syrup for flavours, it's fun and addictive.
 
Last edited:
dont think id ever buy one unless i had spare money that couldn't be used a bit more sensibly. you can get ice cream so cheap these days on 2 for 1's etc that making your own is too pricey. I've done it once without an ice cream make and although it was really nice couldnt justify the cost ofthe ingredients./
 
Icecream makers are like breadmakers, unless you get a good one you're wasting your money.

Not true. You can get great ice cream from a £20 machine but it's more hassle.

dont think id ever buy one unless i had spare money that couldn't be used a bit more sensibly. you can get ice cream so cheap these days on 2 for 1's etc that making your own is too pricey. I've done it once without an ice cream make and although it was really nice couldnt justify the cost ofthe ingredients./

You can make flavours you can't buy in shops.
 
Last edited:
This is the one I have

http://www.amazon.co.uk/Gaggia-RI9101-08-Gelatiera-Cream/dp/B004R9OST4

The model that it replaced (only cosmetic change in colour and name), This one has many many favourable reviews online, with regard to its reliability, there are users who has had it over a decade and it still works. There are cheaper built in compressor machines on the market, at around £150 mark but read the reviews and decide for yourself.
 
dont think id ever buy one unless i had spare money that couldn't be used a bit more sensibly. you can get ice cream so cheap these days on 2 for 1's etc that making your own is too pricey. I've done it once without an ice cream make and although it was really nice couldnt justify the cost ofthe ingredients./

The reason you can buy ice cream cheap is that they use cheap ingredients. Even making something as simple as vanilla ice cream with a whole vanilla pod is a taste experience that you cannot get from the store.

I managed to a this model from Amazon for £110 as it was returned unused but had a little dent in front. It has been a great purchase, and love experimenting with flavours.

Used to have one that needed the bowl to be frozen but found it was too much hassle, but was inspired by it to try different combinations so bought the model below. If you are just wanting to see what you can do, buy a cheap non compressor one and try it out, if you love the taste and want to continue then buy a compressor model

http://www.amazon.co.uk/Ice-Applian...r_1_2?s=kitchen&ie=UTF8&qid=1375700348&sr=1-2

The following book is a wonderful resource for ideas as well as explanations of the processes behind getting smooth ice cream

http://www.amazon.co.uk/Ice-Applian...r_1_2?s=kitchen&ie=UTF8&qid=1375700348&sr=1-2
 
Last edited:
Icecream makers are like breadmakers, unless you get a good one you're wasting your money.

I kinda expected to see a comment like that in here :(

Anyway it's not true at all, I picked up a factory reject for £10 and it makes the best vanilla ice cream I've ever tasted. (obviously using real vanilla pods).
Only apathy stops me digging it out.

What is true is that the cheap ones are a bit more work and only make small quantities, but then you don't always want to be churning this stuff out 24/7
 
Back
Top Bottom