i really cant decide between these models
My requirements:
-intended for use with a wii and a PS3, also a PC for movie and a couple of games but this isnt high priority. The ps3 and wii arent plugged in at the same time for the majority of the time, and i have a S-Video to SCART atm for pc to tv so worst case i could do without a VGA port.
-1080p, please keep the 720 vs 1080 to a minimum please i seen the 2 in action in show rooms and to me at least the difference is very clear
-42" is the size i am aiming for, but 40" is fine i dont really want to go any lower than that.
-Be able to play SD at a reasonable rate, this is not a priority at all but i would like the tv to be ok to view
-Approximately £900-ish budget
Now i have narrowed it down to:
Toshiba Regza 42X3030D 42in LCD TV - £840 + free delivery
Trusted Reviews - 9/10
HDTVOrg - 88%
HDTVTest
I was really interested in this tv and it seemed to have glowing reviews, but when searching user pov's and this forum i found it seems to have problems running blu-ray
SUMMARY
The 42X3030D is Toshiba's latest effort in the 1080 LCD arena, holding it's own where colour and low-light detail is concerned.
VGA: 1360x768 WXGA
HDMI: 50/60 Hz (includes 24FPS, altho there is conflicting info from users)
PROS
> True 1080p panel, accepts and displays 1080p source.
> Excellent colour after calibration
> Attractive, gloss frame design
CONS
> Greyscale behaviour inconsistent
> No greyscale or gamma controls
> Mild digital noise
Sharp LC42XD1E 42in LCD TV - £868.10+16.50 del
trustedreviews - 9/10
hdtvorg - 92%
hdtvtest
SUMMARY
As the cheapest 46-inch 1080p LCD TV available on the market today, Sharp LC46XD1E offers excellent value-for-money despite some flaws.
PROS
> Fantastic black level + high calibrated contrast ratio
> Pin-sharp high resolution detail
> Unbeatable price point: £1350 for a 46-inch 1080p LCD TV
CONS
> Screen uniformity issues ('banding')
> Electronic buzz (even in standby) and low-pitched hum
> Red push
Sony KDL40W2000 40in LCD TV - £979.00+Free delivery
1staudiovisual
CNET - 9.3
hdtvorg - 5 stars
Hdtvtest
This ones more expensive but is the extra cost worth it?, also is there a difference between the above and the Sony KDL40W2000U ?
SUMMARY
This model is our current 1080p LCD TV class leader for picture quality and tweakability, this side of 1500 pounds.
HDMI: 1080p
Component: 1080i
VGA: 1360x768
PROS
> Excellent image with good contrast and respectable blacks
> Wide range of picture adjustments
> Independent memory inputs
CONS
> Inaccurate colour and slight motion blurring
> Average styling considering the price
> Some connectivity issues
> 1080p only though HDMI (not component or VGA)
Note: Clouding may be specific to our review model.
SAMSUNG LE40M86BD 40 in LCT TV - £879.10+£16.90 del
I rad on a couple of forums there were issues with this model too on bluray
hdtvtest
SUMMARY
Samsung LE40M86BD is a massive improvement over its predecessor, and one of the best LCD TVs in its class.
1080p over VGA, Component and HDMI
PROS
> Excellent black level + high calibrated contrast ratio
> Super Clear Panel™ adds depth and realism
> Generous connectivity (three HDMI 1.3)
CONS
> Less-defined shadow detail
> Inaccurate colours
> Awkward film mode deinterlacing
Compariosons:
http://www.hdtvtest.co.uk/1080p-LCD-Shootout/
It would be REALLY helpful if people shared their expriences/added recommendations
, at this point in time i am leaning towards the Sharp/Sony as they seem to have the better picture quality according to reviews