LOTR UHD discs through Panasonic UB820 and 1080p projector, WOW

Soldato
Joined
20 Dec 2006
Posts
3,760
Yeh you read that right, I bought the LOTR UHD collection that just came out (via the WB store as 10% off for new customers, they were short on stock but shipped with next day courier vs 2-3working days like they said they would).

They scanned the 35mm film and raw CGI at 4k Vs 2k when the film's first released. They colour graded to make the film's more consistent (fellowship has a crazy blue green tint now removed) and pulled out more detail though not TOO much as per Jackson's direction. There's a YT video interviewing PJ and other comparison clips available, I'm going to make a video too I think.

I got the UB820 yesterday from Curry's and set it to the SDR/BT2020 setting but didn't change anything else. When I play the UHD disc to my non HDR, 1080p projector (HW40ES Sony) it strips the HDR data and gives me an SDR image.

Well we were both gawping throughout, it's a revelation. The player is downsampling four pixels to one so fine details like hairs are confidently there on screen. You see minutiae on minutiae and it's just beautiful for want of a better one size fits all descriptor.

Contrast is much improved as well with scenes popping and looking HDR in some cases even on a low luminence device such as a Projector, an SDR one at that! You now see capillaries in the subsurface of skin on actors and fine details in clothes previously not visible.

The Atmos soundtrack is amazing with deep thundering bass, can't wait for battles in the later films! The score sounds great with that blackfloor separation/space effect I find you have with individual instruments eminating from your speakers Vs a levelled mix being played through them in non object based audio.

Conclusion: very glad I got the UB820 and the LOTR UHD set for my 1080p projector. Yeh I'd take a faux k or 4k projector but really wonder then if I'd even know what was happening in the film without critiquing every scene lol.

Highly recommended for anyone on the fence. No weird colours or crushed or blown highlights with the Panasonic player, with it outputting a reference SDR image.
 
I try to not focus on the CG but it's hard not to. It's looking the best it ever will due to colour grading and it is matched really well. You'll see the cave troll is well matched and the ENTs. There are times when I think the CG is close to a moderate high budget blockbuster these days, so nothing bad at all considering they're twenty years old?

Dark scenes are just mutch easier to see and some scenes are just plain different esp for example detail retrieval in the orc mining area around the tower.

Go to WB site get 10% off that takes it to £67.50 /3 = £20 something quid for extended edition films that are over three hrs long each, it's nothing too bad.

If you care though, 2021 they will release a deluxe set of sorts with all the extras and things, this current package is the films bare bones which I don't care about + can watch them now. we are just over half way.
 
How can they remaster the CGI without doing it again?

I read a lot of the time CGI doesn't look convincing is colour grading. Beside what you going to do remaster it yourself and never watch them again? It really isn't that bad and there's still great film making in there.
 
The Hobbit, the final fight, everyone blowing their load when the elf archers rock up and procede not to fire a single arrow. Just me?
 
We watched greatest showman UHD disc last night, superb detail with costumes, velvet looks like velvet, new patterns on materials previously unnoticed. Initial garish colours make the film much more fun.
We own the standard blu ray of the greatest showman for what it's worth.

Sound track is amazing, close to Hans Zimmer live in Prague Atmos disc.

Moral of the story standard 1080p blu rays are compromised in terms of bit information with the video and great advances are made with UHD discs, even when played on a 1080p native panel device.
 
What's annoying with greatest showman is the opening song with all that bass impact is used in the disc menu!

So what I do now if we watch it is mute the system, hit play then unmute.

My setup renders it all well, the bass makes people shut up it's so visceral hehe.

Hans Zimmer atmos disc highly recommended cranked up.
 
Thought i'd add some info. So I was an idiot and put on the non-extended version of the return of the king, where it's all fitted onto one disc. We basically got to the end of the film before realising lol.

Last night we finished the extended version over two discs and it looks dramatically different, far better PQ and CGI looked better too I reckon. To me this demonstrates potentially higher video bit rate when spread over two discs.

Per above i've got Joker on blu ray as an xmas gift to watch!

Mulan even streamed on Disney plus is exceptionally sharp IMO and not a bad film either.
 
Back
Top Bottom