Media encoding?

Interesting.

It would appear that it is indeed encoding to xvid at max quality and upscaling the res aswell. Whether that resolution is of any use or not its hard to say. Looking at the aspect stuff its not encoding black bars so thats not a problem.

I would still say, the compression is dramatic enough to be useful on that. You could keep the DVD quality perfectly and maintain menus/usability and not use much more room, integrates nicer with media centres aswell.

I would suggest looking into x264 rips if your really looking for quality, can add in DTS sound aswell and still reduce filesize.

The increased resolution is not getting you anything, such a small upscale can easily be applied on the fly should you wish. I have my ffdshow setup to upscale dvds/avi to 1920x1080 on the fly and it does it very well.

What your using at the minute is not actuall giving you much benefit. Your not saving much space at all (20% at most prob) and losing dvd functionality. I would either be encoding to x264/xvid at a higher compression and native resolution, heading for 1.4gb final size (ish!) or just ripping the extras/languages etc. from the dvds and having .isos.
 
What your using at the minute is not actuall giving you much benefit. Your not saving much space at all (20% at most prob) and losing dvd functionality. I would either be encoding to x264/xvid at a higher compression and native resolution, heading for 1.4gb final size (ish!) or just ripping the extras/languages etc. from the dvds and having .isos.

I'm not worried about size. I just want it on the computer for instant access and use vista media centre. Don't see the point in ripping everything as I never watch the extras or use other languages. Just want good quality.
ASs well as streaming it to the lounge if I can ever afford to build a htpc.
I Like simple, which is why I selected the max resolution. As I said I don't know if I gain anything but, I don't have to fiddle around with fdshow or anything else.

Are x264 rips really better quality at max settings? as it does have that option, I've just always used xvid since it was released.

Also which is better dts or ac3?
I use a av reciever which has dts and dolby decoders.
 
Last edited:
I'm not worried about size. I just want it on the computer for instant access and use vista media centre. Don't see the point in ripping everything as I never watch the extras or use other languages. Just want good quality.
ASs well as streaming it to the lounge if I can ever afford to build a htpc.
I Like simple, which is why I selected the max resolution. As I said I don't know if I gain anything but, I don't have to fiddle around with fdshow or anything else.

Are x264 rips really better quality at max settings? as it does have that option, I've just always used xvid since it was released.

x264 is a better codec. However support is less common (particularly on set top stuff) and it takes longer to encode. You'd get better results from a ~1gb x264 file than a ~1gb xvid file.

I guess if your not that fussed about what qual/size benefits your getting then stick with what you know. Just know there are better alternatives.
You can rip everything out of the dvd (extras etc.) and keep just the main menu if you want to.

DTS sounds better to me, i dont know the technical difference tbh.
 
Back
Top Bottom