Microsoft Comments On Sony Conference

Soldato
Joined
21 Oct 2002
Posts
6,543
Location
West Sussex
http://www.mozlapunk.net/homepage/?p=241


Microsoft’s executives have offered their opinions about last night’s Sony pre-E3 press conference. Of course, it’s direct competition, so bring on the food fight!

IGN spoke with Microsoft’s Game Studio general manager Shane Kim and the general manager of Microsoft’s game developer group Christ Satchell.

Satchell:
“From a gamer’s perspective, I’m pretty disappointed in Sony’s lack of innovation. I mean, they didn’t deliver anything terribly new, and at the cost of $600, $200 more than our system, it’s hard to get excited about it. The ‘new’ controller was even disappointing. It’s basically the same design. It doesn’t seem good for consumers, just good for Sony.”

Kim offered her opinion on why he believes Microsoft is offering a better package.
“Our top-priced premium system is $200 cheaper than theirs. And when you look at the whole package, our innovative online service, our price structure, the high quality of games, and the leadership we have provided, it’s really hard justifying the price difference. We’re in a real sweet spot with our pricing tier. We’re really confident about where we are pricing-wise.”
Satchell also wasn’t impressed by the announcements surrounding online gaming, saying that Sony provided no real commitment to actually delivering their online service. Also, innovation and leadership in that respect were lacking. “I think customers will want the best games and the best services. And the differences between 1080i and 1080p are miniscule; the differences are too hard to determine for most consumers; 1080p is a niche market. The sweet spot is 720p. But you know what? the real question is will your TV be able to run 1080p?”

We’ll see how Microsoft fairs at 11:30 PST today. First up however is Nintendo’s conference in a few hours.
 
All valid business points.

A rare circumstance of a company able to say what they want to say without needing to lie...
 
the differences between 1080i and 1080p are miniscule

dont think you cant notice the difference when playing a fast moving game


We’re in a real sweet spot with our pricing tier. We’re really confident about where we are pricing-wise.

the price of the aracade games are stupid imho


Sony provided no real commitment to actually delivering their online service

no offense but i still think its too early to say that


but i have to say overall the sony conference was carp, roll on nintendo :D
 
Valid points he makes there bceause at the moment, it doesn't offer much more than the 360 other than graphics, and doesn't sound as innovative and 'next-gen' as Wii. But of course, this is Sony and they always know how to sell millions. Despite seeing early screenies from E3 last night from the PS3, I still went ahead and paid for an XBox360 (only £140!) because 1. I cannot wait and 2. I'm getting a Wii anyways :)
 
Dont sony already have an online section with planetside and everquest (and other stuff)? If so, surely they experience with this kind of thing and implementing an online service wont be that difficult.
 
PikeyPriest said:
Dont sony already have an online section with planetside and everquest (and other stuff)? If so, surely they experience with this kind of thing and implementing an online service wont be that difficult.

Very different to an online service like Live. Either way SOE's MMOs haven't exactly been 'stable'. Neither has WoW's been stable for that matter. Live is the only service I know of to have fairly consistant performance, just doesn't work with NTL. Live is massive in comparison to every other online service I know of, except possibly for government stuff (ID databases, etc.).

I had a discussion with someone about 1080i / 1080p. Ultimately there was no difference if the de-interlacer is very high quality. Basic deinterlacing that literally just halves the vertical resolution doesn't look as good. In short 1080i is fine if you have a good deinterlacer, even with extremely fast moving imagery.
 
Boogle said:
Live is the only service I know of to have fairly consistant performance, just doesn't work with NTL.
I've never had problems with live on NTL, unless it's only incompatible on a 360.
 
PikeyPriest said:
Dont sony already have an online section with planetside and everquest (and other stuff)? If so, surely they experience with this kind of thing and implementing an online service wont be that difficult.

And SWG, and look how that turned out................
 
they are right about the 1080p. who the hell has a 1080p TV set?
unless you plug the console to a monitor...which means downsizing the pic anyway...
 
Of course competitors are going to say that - nothing much else they can say really

They omit of course the two premium packs differ in availability of a hi def drive as well as a decent sized hdd....... no doubt not enough to justify the £100 really, (if only the blue ray drive was a burner instead) but when you actually look at it the figures are a lot closer than MS are saying.

Again you are comparing a released product with something thats 6 months away - not really a fair comparison but hey ho I myself will be happy with my x360 until early november and then get to do a proper side by side comparison at home.
 
Back
Top Bottom