I can't make my mind up with this game atm. I'm at the police station level atm...
1. It is as scary as Condemned.
2. The three main characters from part one are all here, except Ethan and Rosa have lost a colossal amount of weight and look different. Wtf was this done? Bring back fat rosa and tubby from heroes plz!
3. Guns are more prominent, but are pretty crap at the same time luckily.
4. The investigation side of things are really good.
5. Melee combat has all these stupid pointless combo moves/modes that detract from the combat that made Condemned so much fun.
6. The devs went overboard on the whole 'Ethan is a bit of a loony drunkard' theme. He keeps seeing visions and the screen goes dark/foggy etc - this happens too much and just gets on my nerves.
7. A lot of levels/areas are just way too dark and you can barely make out your enemies.
8. That torch is ******* useless.
Points 7 & 8, make it feel like Doom 3 at times, especially on the level I just finished where I could barely see what was attacking me, let alone where it came from. The environments you trundle through are really well designed and very atmospheric, yet some are too large. The scares are there aplenty and this is the reason why I'm going through the game slowly.
So far it is a good game, but I don't rate it as high as the first one.